Parshat Shoftim — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
5,913 entries
How can I agree on arrangements for my adult daughter going out while respecting her independence?
Instead of arguing about whether a daughter must ask permission, explain your maternal concern gently and respectfully, and ask for trust. Acknowledge her need for privacy and agree together on a suitable way for her to communicate where she is and when she will return. For example, she could check in after a certain hour. The author recommends reaching agreement through kindness rather than coercion.
Ципора ХаританFamily and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
What can we learn from Rabbi Akiva about facing difficult events?
Rabbi Akiva's life shows that righteousness and outstanding Torah achievement can coexist with severe suffering. Even in tragic events, he found a way to see a necessary stage along the path and inspire hope in others. His example shows that a person can live with God and grow spiritually even when events are incomprehensible.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
What opportunity for spiritual growth does life's uncertainty offer?
The author compares life's apparent contradictions to the development of the Oral Torah, where disagreements produced different approaches, discussion, and deep analysis. Uncertainty encourages a person to ask questions, seek answers, and discover God's presence in life. Independent Torah analysis, however, requires the appropriate skills and must remain within its central truth.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why do wealth, beauty, and high status not always reflect a person's spiritual qualities?
In the author's explanation, the material world originally reflected the spiritual world, but after the prophetic era ended, God's governance became hidden and that connection ceased to be obvious. Physical beauty or high status therefore does not necessarily correspond to inner beauty or righteousness. Prosperity may be a wicked person's reward in this world or a test, so it does not provide a definitive measure of spiritual standing.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why do we eat like free and noble people on Pesach if spiritual freedom is what matters most?
Physical actions influence a person's inner state. Eating like free and noble people helps us experience freedom and reminds us of the spiritual growth and responsibility it entails. The outward action should also encourage noble conduct.
рав Меир МучникHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why does spiritual growth also require physical freedom?
A person in slavery is occupied with imposed labor and cannot make independent decisions, which limits the development of their potential. Freedom allows a person to pursue work that becomes a means of growth rather than an obstacle to it. The Exodus therefore had to bring freedom to both soul and body.
рав Меир МучникHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
What is Yaakov's spiritual beauty?
Avraham passed on kindness and compassion, while Yitzchak passed on discipline, firmness, and willpower. Either quality on its own can reach a harmful extreme. Yaakov's beauty lay in combining them harmoniously and achieving the right balance.
рав Меир МучникMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Is chesed only for the poor, and whom should we help first?
Chesed should be extended to everyone, including one's own family, rather than only to poor or unfortunate people. The closer a person is to us, the greater our obligation to help them, so relatives and loved ones come first.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How can I make sure my help truly benefits the other person?
Help should respond to the other person's actual needs, rather than your own idea of what is good for them. For help to be an act of kindness, personal ambitions should not influence it.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Mussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
What qualities should a rabbi have to be approached for a judicial ruling?
The response identifies three necessary qualities: knowledge of Torah law, the ability to analyze the actual situation correctly, and genuine fear of God. The author concludes that only such a rabbi is entitled to judge and that people should seek rulings from rabbis with these qualities.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What lesson does the author connect with the story of an attempt to discredit a rabbi using false witnesses?
The author recounts a story about a married journalist who posed as an agunah and brought false witnesses to her husband’s death in order to obtain permission to remarry and ridicule a rabbi. According to the account, her husband actually died before her article appeared. The author connects the story with divine assistance to judges, but explicitly states that he had not thoroughly verified it and therefore omits names.
Яков ГельфманHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What lesson is drawn from the story of a forged permission to remarry?
In the account, a woman whose husband disappeared after the war claimed that a prominent rabbi had permitted her to remarry. When her first husband returned after her remarriage, Rav Moshe Feinstein was deeply troubled because he trusted that rabbi’s righteousness. Investigation revealed that the document was forged; the author presents the story as an example of divine assistance protecting true Jewish judges from error.
Яков ГельфманHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How does Ri Migash explain why false witnesses are not executed after the death sentence has been carried out?
As presented in the response, false witnesses receive the corresponding punishment after the verdict but before its execution; the Sadducees disputed this interpretation. Ri Migash explains that the plot to profane the place of divine justice deserves punishment, whereas an executed verdict indicates that the accused deserved that punishment according to the Heavenly Court. The response limits this explanation to the Temple period, when the people merited the Divine Presence, and does not present it as authority for contemporary courts to impose such punishments.
Ри МигашBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How does the response explain the protection of a Torah court against a fatal error?
Yakov Gelfman points to the stringent safeguards in a Torah court intended to prevent a fatal error. He cites Rabbi Akiva’s statement that, had he served on the Sanhedrin, no one could have been sentenced to death. The author identifies divine assistance to judges who follow God’s laws as the central basis for trust.
Яков ГельфманBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Is it enough to avoid doing wrong oneself without responding to what happens nearby?
The response stresses that inaction also shapes a person’s moral character: everyone bears responsibility for improving the world according to their abilities and understanding. Yaakov did not ignore the shepherds’ apparent idleness, and Moshe helped Yitro’s daughters when they were denied access to the well. These examples do not, however, authorize everyone to administer justice independently without the necessary knowledge and judgment.
Яков ГельфманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why must people establish courts if God can administer justice Himself?
Yakov Gelfman explains that taking part in establishing justice serves human spiritual growth. The commandments develop mercy and justice and teach people to emulate the Creator’s ways. People must therefore appoint competent judges and work to build a just society, rather than remain indifferent to wrongdoing.
Яков ГельфманBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How do local custom and an employment contract affect an employer’s obligations under Torah law?
The response defines minhag ha-medinah as a law or custom accepted by all residents of a locality. Employee payments with this status become the employer’s obligations under Torah law as well; examples include severance pay, recuperation pay, overtime, sick pay, and vacation pay. Business agreements also have force under Torah law, so an employment contract must be honored.
рав Моше СытинMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
When may someone approach a state court directly?
The response permits direct recourse when an institution is legally prohibited from having its dispute heard in any other court. For a dispute with a non-Jew, it cites Rabbi Tz. Weber’s permission to approach a state court when it is clear that the other party will not attend a beit din. In both cases, a knowledgeable rabbi must first help establish whether the claim is justified under Torah law and what the claimant is actually entitled to receive.
рав Моше СытинHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What should be done if a defendant refuses to appear before a beit din?
If a Jewish court lacks the power to compel the defendant to appear, prior permission may be obtained from the beit din to approach another court with the necessary authority. The defendant’s refusal does not itself replace that permission. Even when such recourse is permitted, only what is due under Torah law may be claimed, so the particular claim should be discussed with a knowledgeable rabbi.
рав Моше СытинHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
May a dispute be taken to a secular court if both parties agree?
The response explains that mutual consent does not permit taking a dispute to a non-Jewish court, even if its decision would accord with Torah law. Preferring such a court expresses distrust in a Torah court’s ability to resolve the dispute and diminishes the Torah’s dignity. The cited ruling of Chazon Ish extends this prohibition to Jewish secular courts as well; an actual case requires consultation with an experienced rabbi.
рав Моше СытинHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
May food be eaten if it was returned to the heat on Shabbat in a prohibited way?
If food was returned to the heat in a prohibited way, a rabbi should be consulted about whether it may be eaten. The text gives no blanket permission or prohibition regarding its consumption.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
May food be returned to the heat on Shabbat after being transferred to another pot?
The text cites an opinion that transferring food into another vessel that is not on the heat removes its status as having been left on the heat, so it may not be returned. Other opinions permit returning it in this situation. This is a specific disagreement within the conditions of chazarah and does not remove the other requirements.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
May a pot be returned to the heat on Shabbat if there was initially no intention to return it?
Normally, the intention to return the pot must exist when it is removed from the heat. If the person decides to return it only later, returning it is prohibited. In a case of pressing need, however, the text permits this if the pot was held continuously and never set down; the other conditions for returning it must also be met.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Must a pot removed from the heat be kept in one’s hands to return it on Shabbat?
Ordinarily, the pot must remain held: setting it on a table or floor ends its previous status as having been left on the heat. A heavy pot may rest against a table or counter while one continues holding it until returning it. In a case of pressing need, a pot set on a table or chair may be returned if the intention to return it was maintained throughout. A pot placed on the floor may not be returned, though the text also cites an opinion permitting this when that intention was maintained.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
How warm must food remain to be returned to the heat on Shabbat?
Liquid food must retain warmth from cooking or reheating and must not have cooled completely. According to Beit Yosef, whose ruling Sephardim follow, liquid or sauce must remain at the temperature of yad soledet bo. Some halachic authorities prohibit returning even cooled solid food to the heat; the other conditions of chazarah must also be met.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
May food that is not fully cooked be returned to the heat on Shabbat?
Food that is not fully cooked, or whose readiness is uncertain, must not be returned to the heat, because this would cause cooking on Shabbat. Fully cooked food may be returned when the other conditions are met, even if further cooking improves its taste and the person welcomes that improvement.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
What kind of heat source may a pot be returned to on Shabbat?
A pot may be returned only to a heat source with the status of gerufah u-ketumah, provided the other conditions of chazarah are met. The text accepts a gas stove covered before Shabbat with a metal sheet, or blech, but Chazon Ish considers this insufficient and requires placing the pot on another pot, even an empty one. Food may also be returned to a special electric Shabbat warming plate that is not intended for cooking and has no adjustable temperature.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
What lesson did Rav Kook teach about picking plants unnecessarily?
Rav Aryeh Levin recalled absentmindedly picking a leaf while walking with Rav Kook. Rav Kook was distressed and explained that, for as long as he could remember, he had avoided picking plants unnecessarily. The story teaches care for living things even in small actions.
рав КукHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why should every creature be respected?
Ramak explains that every creature reveals the Creator’s wisdom. Since God Himself brought it into being, contempt for a creature expresses disrespect for its Creator.
РамакMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What does the prohibition against disrespecting the altar’s stones teach us about treating people?
Rashi explains that stones cannot feel offended, yet the Torah forbids treating them disrespectfully because they serve a purpose. All the more so, one must not demean another person, who is created in the Creator’s likeness and can feel hurt.
РашиMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why should food not be treated with disrespect?
Treating food with disrespect expresses ingratitude to the Creator, who gave it to us. Food must therefore not be left on the ground where passersby might trample it.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
May food be treated disrespectfully?
The cited passage from Tractate Soferim prohibits showing disrespect toward food. The author includes this rule in the teaching about treating everything around us with care.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does the prohibition against destruction include useful inanimate objects?
The text extends the prohibition to any object that benefits people, including inanimate objects. It derives this prohibition from the verse in Devarim forbidding the destruction of trees during a siege.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Is it permitted to cause animals suffering without necessity?
The text cites the sages in Bava Metzia: causing animals suffering without necessity is prohibited by the Torah. This is presented as one expression of the duty to treat the surrounding world with care.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How do the laws of nature fit together with God's will and miracles?
The laws of nature are described as an ongoing expression of God's will rather than an independent force. God usually acts through consistent laws, leaving people a choice about how to understand events. Miracles serve as signs that these laws depend on Him and can be set aside when necessary.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Bitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Can human states and feelings be attributed to God?
In the account of Rambam's teaching, God is one and is not divided into parts. The states that human beings experience do not apply to Him. The text gives sleep, hunger, love, and hatred as examples.
РамбамBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does the world exist independently of the Creator?
In the explanation of Rambam presented here, God's existence depends on nothing else, while all creation depends on Him. The world continues to exist through the Creator's constant will. No part of creation therefore has an existence independent of Him.
РамбамBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May a judge simply rely on witnesses when fraud is suspected?
A judge must make every effort to establish what actually happened. When there are signs of fraud, the judge may not simply accept testimony and shift responsibility to the witnesses. The story of Rabbi Eliyahu Chaim Meisel illustrates this pursuit of truth: by testing an explanation favorable to a merchant, he obtained a confession and the return of the stolen money.
рав Бенцион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can a small favor to a judge count as a bribe?
Even a small favor from one party can affect a judge's impartiality. Shmuel declined to judge a man who had helped him leave a boat. Rabbi Yishmael, son of Rabbi Yosi, refused an early delivery of his own fruit and referred the case to other judges, yet still noticed that he wanted the person who brought it to win.
рав Бенцион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What does the prohibition against judicial favoritism mean in practice?
Rambam explains that a judge must treat both parties equally. A judge may not speak warmly to one and harshly to the other, or allow one to sit while making the other stand. Nor may the judge let one speak at length while interrupting the other.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How does the Alter Rebbe explain the connection between just courts and possession of the Land of Israel?
In the explanation attributed to the Alter Rebbe, accepting God's promise of the land should go together with accepting His laws of justice. Judging according to Torah law is linked to other nations recognizing the Jews' right to live in their land. Relying on foreign laws while invoking the Torah's promise is presented as inconsistent.
Алтер РебеWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
May a prohibition be violated for a good cause, such as charity or building a synagogue?
Rabbi Bunim of Pshischa explains the repetition of the word “justice” as a requirement to pursue a just goal through just means. A good purpose does not justify a forbidden act. One may not steal to give charity or work on Shabbat to fund the construction of a synagogue.
раби Буним из города ПшисхиMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How should someone choose which court or sage to consult?
Pursuing justice means wanting the most accurate answer and placing truth above personal advantage. One should therefore turn to those who know Torah better, investigate the case more deeply, and seek the truth more carefully. The Talmud's examples of sages from different eras teach people to seek out the wisest scholars of their own time.
рав Ицхак ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How was a halachic question resolved when the local court did not know the answer?
According to Rambam's account, the questioner and one of the judges went to the court at the foot of the Temple Mount and, if necessary, to the supreme court. An established tradition of the Oral Torah settled the matter without dispute; otherwise, the question was examined in depth. Disagreements involving Torah interpretation, as well as decisions about enactments and prohibitions, were resolved by majority vote.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What are the foundations for rulings of the supreme Jewish court?
Rambam explains that the court uses three foundations: its own enactments and prohibitions, the rules for interpreting the Torah given to Moshe, and the received tradition of the Oral Torah. Different parts of the verse commanding obedience to the court point to these sources. The obligation to obey also includes the court's enactments and prohibitions.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why do Sanhedrin rulings concern even people who are not involved in a court case?
The Sanhedrin did more than settle disputes: it also decided halachic questions, including matters of Shabbat and kashrut. The obligation to follow its rulings therefore applied to all Jews. The author emphasizes that Torah laws must be observed in accordance with the rulings of authoritative Jewish courts.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How did the authority of Jewish courts differ according to their size?
A court of three judges handled property disputes, while a court of twenty-three could hear cases involving a possible death sentence. The supreme court of seventy-one judges decided matters affecting the whole people, including whether to begin a war and whether a prophet was genuine. The Great Sanhedrin was the main governing authority, and its head was a leader of the people.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What kinds of leadership does Parashat Shoftim discuss?
The parashah discusses the duties of judges, kings, priests, and prophets, as well as the people's conduct in wartime. Alongside the leaders' duties, it explains the responsibilities of those who seek judgment, obey the king, bring gifts to priests, or listen to prophets.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Can human sins ultimately prevent Mashiach from coming?
Rabbi David Rachlis states that Mashiach will come and that human actions cannot prevent the Creator’s plan from being fulfilled. If we cannot understand how a prophecy will come true, this reflects the limits of human understanding rather than casting doubt on the prophecy. He gives the liberation from Egypt as an example: it occurred even though, under harsh slavery, it was unclear how it could be possible.
рав Давид РахлисMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 202 Shoftim 2020, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
At what age does a person become accountable for sins?
Rabbi Ovadya Klimovsky distinguishes between the effect of conscious actions on one’s relationship with God and the age at which punishment applies. As he understands Rabbi Naftali-Tzvi-Yehuda Berlin’s commentary, even a young child’s actions have spiritual significance when the child understands what they are doing. The response places liability to punishment by an earthly court at thirteen and by the Heavenly Court at twenty. According to the response, most commentators regard these age thresholds as a tradition received by Moses at Sinai.
рав Овадья КлимовскийHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 202 Shoftim 2020, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha