Parshat Behaalotecha — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
3,957 entries
What does it mean that the people wept “by their families”?
One explanation describes families gathering and weeping together to make their grievances public. Another, attributed to the sages, connects the weeping with family relationships: they were protesting the unions that had become forbidden to them.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How is the expression “leshad hashamen,” describing the manna's taste, explained?
Dunash ben Labrat explains it as the moisture or richness of oil. An interpretation by the sages connects the word with breasts, but the commentary objects to that reading in this context. Another explanation treats it as an abbreviation referring to dough kneaded with oil and coated with honey; Onkelos's translation aligns with Dunash's reading.
דונש בן לברט; Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Did the manna actually need to be ground and cooked?
Gathering the manna is described as a leisurely walk without toil. The references to grinding, pounding, and cooking are explained as changes in its taste: it took on the flavors of foods prepared in those ways, rather than literally undergoing those processes.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why does the Torah describe the manna's qualities after the complaints about it?
The explanation stresses that the complaint and the description come from different speakers. The people complain that they have only manna, while God points out its qualities. This juxtaposition exposes the complaint as unjustified.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Mussar and characterRead more
Why did the manna not take on the taste of certain vegetables?
Rabbi Shimon explains the exception for the listed vegetables by saying that they are harmful to nursing women. In this interpretation, the limitation on the manna's flavors reflects concern for mothers and infants.
ר׳ שמעוןWeekly parshaRead more
What does it mean that they ate fish “for free” in Egypt?
“For free” is not understood as fish costing nothing, since the Egyptians would not even provide straw for free. The explanation takes it to mean freedom from commandments, which the complainers were longing for.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Did the Israelites really have no meat in the wilderness?
The text rejects that reading: they left Egypt with flocks and cattle. It also rejects the suggestion that all the livestock had been eaten, since they still had abundant livestock before entering the land. Their demand for meat is therefore presented as a search for a pretext to complain.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Mussar and characterRead more
Why does the text say that the fire sank into the ground?
After Moses prayed, the fire sank into the ground where it was. Had it withdrawn in any direction, it would have continued consuming everything along that path.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why did the people turn specifically to Moses during the fire?
Their appeal to Moses is explained through a parable about a king's son who has angered his father. The son approaches the king's close friend and asks him to intercede. Likewise, the people turned to Moses to pray to God on their behalf.
Whom did the fire strike “at the edge of the camp”?
Two different interpretations are given. One identifies the victims as those of low standing, the mixed multitude. Rabbi Shimon ben Menasya understands the phrase as referring to the leaders and prominent people.
ר׳ שמעון בן מנסיא; Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
What was wrong with the complainers' conduct in the wilderness?
The complainers sought a pretext to turn away from God and deliberately provoke His anger. They complained about the hardship of the three-day journey, although the rapid progress was intended for their benefit, to bring them into the land sooner. Their complaint is presented as a distortion of God's benevolent intention.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Mussar and characterRead more
What is derived from the words “myriads of thousands of Israel”?
In the interpretation given, the plural “myriads” means twenty thousand, and the plural “thousands” means two thousand. This yields a minimum of twenty-two thousand Israelites for the resting of the Divine Presence described here.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why are Israel's enemies called those who hate God?
The explanation of Moses' prayer identifies those who hate God with those who hate Israel. Hatred of Israel is treated as hatred of the One who created the world. This is supported by the connection between the verses in Psalms about God's enemies and their plotting against His people.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why did Moses say “Kumah Hashem” when the Ark traveled ahead?
The Ark traveled three days ahead of the people. In the cited explanation, Moses' request means: stop, wait for us, and do not move farther away.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why is the passage “When the Ark set out” surrounded by special marks?
The marks before and after the passage indicate that this is not its usual place. It is positioned here to separate two accounts of calamity.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
What acknowledgment follows recovery from illness in the commentary on Job?
The person who has been saved from illness confesses to the Creator in the presence of others. He acknowledges that he sinned and distorted what was right, and that doing so brought him no benefit.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Mussar and characterRead more
What role does one defender among many accusers play in the Book of Job?
The commentary describes one advocate who presents a person's uprightness among a thousand who report their wrongdoing. The passage then describes God's mercy and His command to rescue the person from destruction because a ransom has been found.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Bitachon and emunahRead more
How does the commentary on Job explain the purpose of suffering?
In this interpretation, suffering is presented as a warning that can stop a person from carrying out a wrongful intention. It humbles pride and encourages repentance in order to save the person from final destruction. Illness appears here within a spiritual explanation of Job's experience.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Bitachon and emunahRead more
Why does Job's interlocutor stress that he too was formed from clay?
He tells Job that he is no stronger than Job and need not inspire fear. He thus addresses Job's wish to debate someone who will not intimidate him, while speaking on God's behalf.
How should I respond to criticism?
The quoted letter advises embracing criticism. It helps a person recognize their true standing and assess themselves more accurately.
אבי אדמו"ר [?]Mussar and characterRead more
How is the word “nihyah” vocalized in the Shehakol blessing?
The quoted instruction from Hayom Yom places a kamatz under the yud in “nihyah.” The word is to be pronounced with that vowel, rather than with a segol.
What does calling God “the Great” mean?
The Tanya passage connects this title with chesed, the extension of vitality to countless worlds and creatures. They are brought into existence from nothing and sustained through freely given kindness. This generosity comes from God's unfathomable greatness, since the nature of goodness is to do good.
Why does the world need continuous creation?
According to the quoted passage from Tanya, being created during the six days of Creation is not enough for creatures to continue existing. Divine vitality reaches them every moment and continually brings them into existence from nothing.
Why is the name Elokim compared to a protective covering for the sun?
In the quoted passage from Tanya, the sun's covering enables creatures to endure its light. Similarly, the name Elokim acts as a shield in relation to the name Havayah. Havayah is explained here as continually bringing everything into existence from nothing.
How did the seven clouds accompany the Israelites in the wilderness?
Four clouds surrounded the people on their four sides, with one above and one below. Another went ahead, lowering high ground, raising low ground, and killing snakes and scorpions.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How did the people cover a three-day journey, and why did the Ark go ahead?
They covered a three-day journey in one day because God wished to bring them into the land immediately. The Ark containing the broken tablets traveled three days ahead to prepare a resting place. The text identifies it as the Ark that accompanied them to war.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
What benefit did Yitro's descendants receive in the Land of Israel?
When the land was divided, a fertile tract near Jericho measuring five hundred by five hundred cubits was left unallocated. It was reserved for whoever would have the Temple built in their territory. In the meantime, it was given to Yitro's descendants, to Yonadav son of Rekhav.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
What did Moses mean when he told Yitro, “You will be our eyes”?
Three interpretations are given. The first refers to the past: Yitro personally witnessed the miracles performed for the people. The second looks to the future, when he could clarify matters they did not understand. The third means that he would be as dear to them as their own eyes, in keeping with the commandment to love the convert.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why did Moses urge Yitro not to leave?
Moses feared that Yitro's departure would be interpreted as evidence of a self-interested conversion: that he had joined to receive land and left upon learning he would receive no allotment. Yitro had also witnessed God's miracles and mighty deeds in the wilderness. Moses therefore regarded staying with the people as fitting for him.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why did Moses say they were about to enter the Land of Israel and include himself?
The first journey from Sinai began with the intention of entering the land within three days, but the sin of the complainers intervened. Moses included himself because the decree barring his entry had not yet been issued. He expected to enter with the people.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Who was Hovav, and why did he have several names?
Hovav was Yitro, Moses' father-in-law. The name Yitro is explained by the additional Torah section associated with him, and Hovav by his love for the Torah. Reuel was the women's grandfather; the explanation notes that children also call their grandfather “father.”
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why is Dan's camp called the gatherer of all the camps?
The cited Jerusalem Talmud explains that the populous tribe of Dan traveled last and returned lost belongings to their owners. The passage also presents two views of the marching formation: a square resembling the encampment, or a long column. The first is derived from the verse linking travel to encampment, and the second from the expression “gatherer of all the camps.”
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How was the Mishkan dismantled and set up during the journeys?
When Judah's camp departed, Aaron and his sons covered the Ark with the curtain, while the descendants of Gershon and Merari dismantled the Mishkan and loaded it onto wagons. The descendants of Kehat departed with the sacred objects after Reuben's camp. This allowed Gershon and Merari's descendants to erect the Mishkan at the next stop before Kehat's descendants arrived and brought the sacred objects inside.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How long did the Israelites camp at Mount Horeb?
They camped at Horeb for twelve months less ten days. They arrived on the first day of Sivan and departed on the twentieth of Iyar the following year.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
What does Elihu mean when he refuses to alter his words out of deference to someone?
Elihu declares that he will not show favoritism or replace direct language with indirect expressions out of deference to his listener. He intends to state his rebuke openly.
אליהוא בן־ברכאל הבוזיMussar and characterRead more
Does wisdom come automatically with age?
Elihu initially expected that many years would bring wisdom. He then emphasizes that understanding comes from the spirit granted by God, rather than from age alone.
אליהוא בן־ברכאל הבוזיMussar and characterRead more
Why did Elihu initially remain silent even though he believed he had something to say?
Elihu gave the other speakers precedence because they were older than he was. He waited until they stopped answering and only then expressed his own view.
אליהוא בן־ברכאל הבוזיMussar and characterRead more
What is called “resurrection of the dead” in spiritual service?
In the teaching quoted, the natural human intellect is described as cold. When it understands a Divine idea and its associated emotions are stirred by the delight of understanding, this is called spiritual resurrection.
How does the verse about the trumpets connect Malchuyot, Zichronot, and Shofarot?
The commentary identifies three elements in one verse: sounding the trumpets, remembrance before God, and the words “I am the Lord your God,” expressing His kingship. Their appearance together teaches the joining of Malchuyot with Zichronot and Shofarot.
How did the trumpet signals differ for assembling the people, assembling the leaders, and beginning a journey?
Two trumpets called the whole community together, while one called the leaders; neither assembly signal included a teruah. Departure used both trumpets with the sequence tekiah, teruah, tekiah. The sons of Aharon, the priests, sounded them.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How were the cloud, Moshe's words, and the trumpets coordinated when Israel traveled?
When the people set out, the cloud folded and extended over the tribe of Yehudah, and the trumpets sounded, but movement did not begin until Moshe said, “Arise, Lord.” When they camped, the cloud took the shape of a canopy and did not spread out until Moshe spoke the corresponding words. The commentary therefore describes three elements governing travel: Divine direction, Moshe, and the trumpets.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
Why does the text say “The words of Iyov are ended” when he speaks again later?
In the explanation cited, this is part of Iyov's conditional declaration, rather than an announcement that all his speeches have ended. If he failed to fulfill the duties he described, let his words cease and let him have no grounds to declare before God that he properly removed the sacred dues.
What practical advice about soil does Rabbi Oshaya derive from Iyov's words?
Rabbi Oshaya explains that a field producing thorns is suitable for sowing wheat. A field producing foul-smelling plants is suitable for sowing barley.
ר׳ אושעיאMoney and workRead more
What wrongs are represented by land crying out against its owner?
The commentary connects this image with failing to set aside the required gifts for the poor and tithes, and the weeping furrows with plowing using an ox and a donkey together. Consuming the produce “without money” is explained as withholding workers' pay; another explanation connects these words with the second tithe.
Редакция «לשקד על דלתתי יום יום»Weekly parshaRead more
How did Iyov make his home accessible to guests?
Iyov did not arrange his entrance in a way that discouraged guests: the doors were not hidden inside, enclosed by an outer gatehouse, or turned into a corner. His home opened toward the road to welcome anyone who came.
How did Iyov restrain himself from taking revenge on an enemy?
Iyov says that he did not rejoice at his enemy's misfortune. The commentary also explains that he did not make fabricated monetary claims against an enemy to provoke him and force him to swear an oath.
How can a wealthy person be considerate of the poor?
Iyov did not display joy in his wealth before poor people, so as not to provoke their envy. He also did not regard his treasures as a means of gaining power over them.
How does Iyov describe his care for people in need?
Iyov describes sharing his bread with an orphan and warming a poor person with wool from his sheep. Caring for those in need was a quality he had followed since his youth.
Why should one not dismiss the complaints of a person under one's authority?
Iyov did not dismiss the claims of his male and female servants, remembering that he would have to answer to God. He emphasized that the same Creator formed both him and them.
Why did Iyov avoid gazing even at an unmarried woman?
Iyov describes this as an additional measure of piety in guarding his gaze. He was concerned that the woman might later marry while his attachment to her remained.
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha