Skip to main content
.

Parshat Lech-Lecha — questions and answers

Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.

7,971 entries

  1. What animal skins may be used for tefillin, and may the skin of a kosher animal that died of illness be used?

    The scrolls and boxes of tefillin are made only from the skins of kosher animals; elephant skin is unsuitable. This is linked to the Torah’s words that God’s Torah should be “in your mouth.” The skin of an animal of a kosher species may nevertheless be used for the scrolls even if it became a neveilah, for example by dying of illness, although its meat may not be eaten.

    Рав; раби Иегошуа а-ГрасиHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  2. What does the story of the stone Rabbi Hanina prepared for the Temple teach?

    Rabbi Hanina had no wealth, but deeply wanted to fulfill the mitzvah and bring a gift to the Temple. He worked and decorated a large stone with his own hands, then helped carry it himself. In the story, the carriers turned out to be angels, and the stone miraculously reached Jerusalem; the rabbi gave the money intended for their payment to the poor. The story shows that even a poor person can express a desire to fulfill a mitzvah through personal effort and participation.

    Цюпа ГензельHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  3. How should Shabbat meals differ from weekday meals?

    Shabbat meals should be festive and distinct from everyday meals. The text also states that there should be more food than on a weekday.

    Лейб КаханэHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  4. May I say that someone observes mitzvot poorly if I do the same myself?

    Committing the same violation yourself does not permit you to speak about that fault in someone else. The prohibition also covers saying that a person performs a mitzvah inadequately, such as devoting too little time to Torah study. False negative statements about a person are also forbidden.

    Лейб КаханэHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  5. Why should I pray for a friend who has the same need as I do?

    The text cites the Sages’ teaching that someone who prays for a friend with the same need will be answered first. Following this teaching, the woman arranged with a friend who was also unemployed to pray for one another.

    Редакция «Любите делать добро»PrayerRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  6. How can I use a period of unemployment for spiritual growth?

    The woman in the account learned to organize her time to allow for more Torah study, prayer, and volunteer work. Financial limitations taught her to live with less. While continuing to seek suitable employment, she came to rely more on God and face uncertainty more calmly.

    Редакция «Любите делать добро»Bitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  7. How can I help someone who has lost a job if I have no suitable vacancy to offer?

    In Sarah Rosenfeld's account, useful help includes résumé advice, forwarding a résumé to other employers, finding vacancies, and making time to discuss options. She was especially moved by unemployed friends who shared job leads even though they needed work themselves. These actions sustained her hope and showed how much even a small effort can mean.

    Сара РозенфельдCommunity and tzedakahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  8. Why is it important to tell as many people as possible that you are looking for work?

    Sarah Rosenfeld writes that after losing her job she realized the importance of letting many people know she was looking for work. People could forward her résumé to other employers, send information about vacancies, or help improve the résumé. Such assistance broadened her search and gave her renewed hope.

    Сара РозенфельдMoney and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  9. What lesson about medication comes from the story of an older woman whose condition worsened after her husband's death?

    Ann Kreamer recounts that the woman's decline was initially understood in the context of her husband's death, but her daughter's conversation with the doctor revealed a recent change in medication dosage. After the doctor reduced the dose, the woman returned to her normal life. For the author, the case illustrated the importance of paying attention to possible medication side effects and reporting changes in condition to the doctor.

    Энн КримерHealth and soulRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 13 · open and download the PDF

  10. What measures to reduce the risk of falls in old age are presented in the article?

    In Ann Kreamer's account, Dr. Atul Gawande recommends regular exercises to improve balance and strengthen muscles. Another rule reported in the article is to try not to take more than four medications at the same time. The article connects these recommendations with the danger of falls associated with poor balance, muscle weakness, and taking many medications together.

    доктор Атул ГавандиHealth and soulRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 13 · open and download the PDF

  11. Why is a pleasant life not necessarily a good and meaningful one?

    Rabbi Yitzchak Kirzner explains that pleasant experiences can have harmful consequences, while unpleasant ones can be beneficial, so pleasure alone is an inadequate measure of life. He proposes evaluating life through meaning and purpose. Purpose helps a person endure suffering, whereas even a pleasant life without it can leave a sense of inner emptiness.

    Раввин Ицхак КирцнерMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  12. May a believer ask why God allows suffering?

    Rabbi Yitzchak Kirzner distinguishes between judging the Creator by human standards and seeking a deeper understanding of one's relationship with Him. He considers a question about suffering asked for the sake of understanding both justified and essential. In his critique of Harold Kushner, he rejects the conclusion that the Creator is imperfect, emphasizing the limits of human understanding.

    Раввин Ицхак КирцнерBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  13. What does belief in Providence say about the meaning of my life?

    Rabbi Yitzchak Kirzner connects Providence with the Creator's guidance toward a purpose, both for the universe and for each person's life. Everyone has a particular role, and every moment is given for a specific task. In this understanding, the conditions of life serve one's purpose rather than being determined by meaningless chance.

    Раввин Ицхак КирцнерBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  14. Does the world's continued existence depend on the Creator after creation?

    Rabbi Yitzchak Kirzner explains that the world does not exist independently of its Creator: its existence is continually sustained by God's will. Matter itself was created by God and cannot escape His authority. If the Creator withdraws His support from an element of creation, it ceases to exist.

    Раввин Ицхак КирцнерBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  15. Why were some passages about non-Jews omitted from the Russian translation of Kitzur Shulchan Aruch?

    Eliyahu Essas explains the restrictions discussed in the letter as historical precautions against blood libels: an unsuccessful attempt to help could lead to accusations and endanger the entire community. He approves the publishers' omission of several phrases because they could be used out of context to incite antisemitism. In his explanation, these precautions must not be presented as a general prohibition on treating or rescuing non-Jews.

    Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  16. How can a postponed fast bring spiritual repair for a date that has already passed?

    Eliyahu Essas explains that God authorized the Sanhedrin to establish calendar dates according to Torah law, and spiritual work follows those decisions. Thus, when the Ninth of Av fast is postponed from Shabbat to the tenth, its spiritual repair must take place on the postponed date. Shabbat is the exception: God established it directly, and it cannot be moved.

    Элиягу ЭссасHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  17. How does Eliyahu Essas advise responding to antisemitic remarks?

    In his reply to a reader, Eliyahu Essas considers a simple denial of the accusations ineffective and suggests calmly and with dignity saying that the speaker has reminded the family where it should live: in Israel. He connects this advice to his religious interpretation of antisemitism and his conviction that Jewish life should be built in the Land of Israel. He emphasizes that moving alone is insufficient: the spiritual dimension of life must continually grow.

    Элиягу ЭссасBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  18. What place should Torah study have when choosing a path in life?

    According to Eliyahu Essas, Torah study remains central to Jewish life whatever profession one chooses, even if one devotes only an hour or two a day to it. For those seriously seeking to dedicate their lives to Torah, he recommends studying in a yeshiva and kollel and continuing to learn and teach.

    Элиягу ЭссасOtherRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  19. Should I rely on music or painting as my main source of income?

    Eliyahu Essas advises developing artistic skills while also qualifying in another profession. If the attraction to art remains strong after earning a proper degree, one can try pursuing it, while recognizing that, in his assessment, the chances of supporting oneself and a family this way are low.

    Элиягу ЭссасMoney and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  20. Is there a general answer to whether a university or a college is the better choice?

    The reply establishes no general preference for a university or a college; it treats the choice as individual. Age and military service alone are insufficient information: advice also requires knowing the person's family background, previous studies, and religious upbringing.

    Рав Элиягу [?]Money and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  21. Which fields of study are recommended in the reply to the young man choosing a profession?

    The respondent recommends choosing among the natural and exact sciences, medicine, computing, and architecture according to personal interest. He advises against almost all humanities subjects and university Jewish studies departments. He bases this restriction on his assessment that their curricula conflict with a Torah worldview, distinguishing academic discussion of Judaism from studying Torah itself.

    Рав Элиягу [?]Money and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  22. What should I do before choosing professional studies if I lack a foundation in Jewish life?

    The reply advises the young man to first spend at least a year studying Jewish outlook, traditions, and laws while acquiring basic Torah study skills. This advice applies if his family and previous education did not provide that foundation. Choosing a profession is placed within the broader goals of spiritual growth, helping others, and building a family with adequate material support.

    Рав Элиягу [?]Money and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  23. What distinguished Avraham from the righteous people who lived before him?

    Earlier righteous people taught those who sought the truth, whereas Avraham took the initiative to spread faith in the one Creator publicly. He continued this service even under Nimrod's threat of execution and, according to the story, was miraculously saved from the fiery furnace. The author draws the lesson that Avraham independently chose sanctifying God's Name as his life's purpose and entrusted his fate to Him.

    раввин Носон ВайсHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  24. Why did God single out Avraham and grant him prophetic communication?

    According to the explanation attributed to Rambam, Avraham independently came to understand God's unity. He rejected ancient mistaken ideas about the world. In recognition of this achievement, God raised him to the level of a prophet and enabled him to communicate with Him personally.

    РамбамWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  25. Does the promise “I am your shield” guarantee Avraham physical safety?

    In the author's concluding explanation, this promise concerns reward in the World to Come rather than guaranteed physical safety here. By entrusting his life to God, Avraham can concentrate on a spiritual goal. The author connects this with the assurance that the Jewish people's service and suffering will not go unrewarded.

    раввин Носон ВайсBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  26. What place should earning a living have in a person's life?

    Work is necessary to sustain life, but earning a living should not become its main purpose or absorb all of one's creative energy. The author identifies sanctifying God's Name and spiritual development as the central mission. Our earthly time should be used to prepare for the World to Come.

    раввин Носон ВайсMoney and workRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  27. Why does acknowledging God's unity come before accepting the commandments in the Shema?

    A person must first acknowledge God's unlimited authority over the world and affirm faith in the one Creator. Only then can they undertake to fulfill His commandments. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Korcha uses this principle to explain the order of the prayer's sections.

    раби Иегошуа бен КорхаPrayerRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  28. According to this Torah portion commentary, what determines the Jewish people's well-being?

    The author connects the Jewish people's well-being and safety primarily with their relationship with God and observance of the commandments. In this explanation, economic effort and external conditions are not decisive. Choices about where to live and how to act should therefore follow the Creator's guidance, even when personal calculations suggest greater success elsewhere.

    раввин Носон ВайсBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  29. Why is the command “Lech Lecha” considered a test if Avraham was promised wealth and descendants?

    The test lay in entrusting control over his life and safety to God. People feel more secure when they control their circumstances and can see how tomorrow will be provided for. Avraham had to leave familiar supports and accept dependence on the Creator's will.

    раввин Носон ВайсBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  30. What appeal to the nations does the editor see in the promise to bless those who bless Avraham?

    The editor understands this promise as an appeal to let the Jewish people live on their land without harming them. Treating them well is linked to God's blessing. Living on Jewish land and fulfilling the commandments are presented as a gift to be valued.

    Элиэзер ФрейдкинWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  31. Why was it difficult for Avraham to leave his homeland even at God's command?

    Moving means giving up a familiar way of life, established connections, and social standing. Even God's command does not make that step easy: a person finds it difficult to leave everything they have learned to rely on.

    Элиэзер ФрейдкинWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№239 глава Лех Леха, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  32. Why did the Sages give different counts of the fires on the altar?

    Rabbi Yehuda considered two fires sufficient on ordinary days: one for burning parts of the offerings and another for coals used to burn ketoret. Rabbi Yosi added a third fire from which to take fire if the first went out. Rabbi Meir added another for parts of offerings that had not burned since the previous evening. All three agreed that Yom Kippur required an additional fire to supply coals for burning ketoret in the Holy of Holies, bringing their respective totals to three, four, and five fires.

    Раби Иегуда; Раби Йоси; Раби МеирHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 24 · open and download the PDF

  33. What vessel did the Kohen Gadol use to wash his hands and feet on Yom Kippur?

    On ordinary days, the Kohen Gadol washed his hands and feet using a copper basin. On Yom Kippur, a special gold vessel was used for this purpose.

    Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 24 · open and download the PDF

  34. Why did the Kohen Gadol walk along the center of the altar ramp on Yom Kippur?

    On ordinary days, the kohanim ascended the eastern side of the ramp, turned right, and descended on the western side; the right side symbolizes mercy. This route avoided crossing the ramp unnecessarily, which was considered disrespectful to the altar. On Yom Kippur, the Kohen Gadol ascended and descended along the center as a sign of respect for him and of God’s love for Israel: on that day, he is like a son in his father’s home.

    Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 24 · open and download the PDF

  35. Why was the ketoret for Yom Kippur ground more finely than usual?

    The Torah already commands that ketoret be finely ground, yet its description of the Yom Kippur service again emphasizes the fineness of the incense. The Sages explain that the Torah has no superfluous words, so the repetition conveys an additional requirement: the herbs must be ground even more thoroughly for Yom Kippur. On that day, the Kohen Gadol also burned more ketoret than usual.

    Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 24 · open and download the PDF

  36. What kind of shovel did the Kohen Gadol use for the coals on Yom Kippur?

    On Yom Kippur, the Kohen Gadol used only a lightweight gold shovel made from a thin sheet of gold. The text contrasts it with the fairly heavy silver or gold shovel used on ordinary days.

    Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 24 · open and download the PDF

  37. What did God command Avram at the beginning of Lech Lecha?

    God commanded Avram to leave his native country, his ancestral land, and his father’s home and travel to another land. He promised to make Avram into a great nation, make him great, and make him a source of blessing.

    Цюпа ГензельWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 23 · open and download the PDF

  38. Who is identified as the first Jew, and what distinguished him?

    Avraham is identified as the first Jew, a descendant of Shem, Noach’s son. The text says that he was the first to acknowledge God and underwent ten trials for his faith.

    Цюпа ГензельWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 23 · open and download the PDF

  39. How can I avoid despair when comparing my spiritual growth with other people's success?

    Each person has an individual situation and should make efforts according to their abilities. God does not expect one person to achieve another person's results. Comparison can encourage growth, but if it produces apathy and giving up, one should focus on the changes personally within reach.

    Доктор Арье МарголинMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 21 · open and download the PDF

  40. Do spiritual efforts have value when the desired result is not achieved?

    The Chafetz Chaim explains that the reward for Torah study is determined by the effort invested, rather than only by measurable results. The impossibility of completing the entire task does not exempt a person from taking part in it. One should therefore keep trying even when the outcome is limited or not yet visible.

    Хафец ХаимMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  41. According to the explanation cited, why did Avraham's disciples not continue by following Yitzchak?

    Rav Chaim Chanoch explains this through differing forms of spiritual leadership: Avraham embodied chesed, while Yitzchak embodied gevurah. People accustomed to Avraham found it difficult to accept a different form of service to the same Torah. Their attachment to their great teacher did not become a lasting commitment to following his successor.

    Рав Хаим ХанoхWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  42. Why are the people whom Avraham and Sarah brought closer to God called a “soul” they made?

    Avraham and Sarah taught people to serve the one God, which is described as creating new souls. The author connects this with the principle that teaching Torah to another Jew is like giving birth to that person. The singular “soul” is explained as expressing the spiritual unity of people joined by a shared faith.

    Доктор Арье МарголинWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  43. Why is praying for others important when we want to help them?

    The author treats the absence of any mention of Noach praying for others as a sign of insufficient concern for their improvement. He emphasizes that the desire to help should also be expressed through prayer. A personal request should be included in a broader prayer for others, as happens in communal prayer.

    Доктор Арье МарголинPrayerRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  44. Why make an effort if the result still depends on God's help?

    Human effort—hishtadlut—creates an opening for God's help. Noach therefore had to work even though survival in the ark involved a miracle. The author urges people to use their given strengths and abilities and rely on God's help where their own capacities are insufficient.

    Доктор Арье МарголинBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  45. Can a miracle be seen in ordinary daily life?

    Alongside miracles that transcend nature, the article describes miracles within its laws. Ramban Nachmanides regards our very existence as a miracle to which we have become accustomed. The familiarity of an event therefore does not take away its miraculous character.

    Рамбан НахманидBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  46. Can a righteous person have doubts about faith?

    Noach's example shows that even someone the Torah calls righteous and wholehearted can experience doubt. Despite ridicule and inner uncertainty, he continued building the ark for many years and fulfilled his task. The author concludes that doubts do not erase the value of faithfully continuing one's work.

    Доктор Арье МарголинBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  47. Does belief in the one God mean that everyone must become Jewish?

    Dr. Aryeh Margolin explains that recognizing the one God does not automatically make a person Jewish. He distinguishes the obligations of the children of Noach from Jewish commandments, stating that the former are not required to observe Shabbat and kashrut. Universal recognition of God therefore does not mean that everyone must be converted to Judaism.

    Доктор Арье МарголинHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  48. May one complain about a small child's bad behavior?

    Speaking negatively about small children is forbidden when it may cause them harm or suffering. Even when the goal is to help a child improve, one must act with great tact and caution. The example of complaining to adoptive parents illustrates how serious the consequences of such words can be.

    Лейб КаханэHalachaRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  49. How does Tamar Antopolskaya explain the discrepancy between geological estimates of Earth's age and faith in the Torah?

    The author argues that estimates based on layers of earth assume ordinary processes, whereas the Flood and other catastrophes could have changed the outcome. She contrasts the limitations of human theories with the Creator's boundlessness and the Torah's eternal truth. This is her explanation for why scientific estimates should not undermine trust in the Torah.

    Тамар АнтопольскаяBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  50. How can we use technological advances without becoming distant from the Creator?

    The author links the spiritual danger of progress to the belief that people achieved everything on their own and that the Creator had no part in it. She suggests thanking the Creator for new ideas and dedicating technology to His service.

    Тамар АнтопольскаяBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№340 глава Лех Леха, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

By weekly parsha