Parshat Lech-Lecha — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
8,934 entries
How does the article explain the place of the “exile of Yishmael” among Israel's exiles?
The author cites Ramchal's teaching that, beyond the familiar four exiles, there is an additional fifth and final exile, the “exile of Yishmael.” He also cites an interpretation connecting the word “עליו” in the account of the Covenant Between the Pieces with this exile and the redemption that follows it.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMoshiach and geulahRead more
Why is Avraham's request that his guests wash their feet treated as grounds for criticism?
According to Maharsha's explanation, the problem was that Avraham immediately raised washing their feet, conveying suspicion that they worshipped the dust on them. Had the guests been human, this could have hurt them, although offering water for washing feet was customary. Even the intention to keep idolatry out of his home required sensitivity to his guests' feelings.
What can we learn from the way Avraham persuaded Sarah to leave with him?
According to the explanation quoted from the Zohar, Avraham spoke gently to Sarah and encouraged her until she willingly agreed to go. Although the command to leave came from God, he did not force his wife. This teaches the importance of gaining a spouse's willing agreement through considerate persuasion even when pursuing a lofty purpose.
זוהר הקדושShalom bayitRead more
How can Sarah's fulfilling God's will be reconciled with Ramban's criticism of her treatment of Hagar?
The author explains that the Tosefta and Ramban address different aspects of the action: sending Hagar away accorded with God's will, but the way it was done caused her suffering. Even when acting for the sake of Heaven, a person remains responsible for how they treat another person. A worthy purpose does not excuse the pain caused in carrying it out.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMussar and characterRead more
How does the story of a wealthy man watching boxing explain the purpose of life's challenges?
Rabbi Yitzchak Dovid Grossman asked an enthusiastic spectator whether he would watch a fighter punching alone without an opponent, and the man said no. He explained that resistance gives the struggle meaning and makes progress possible. Likewise, life's challenges allow a person to rise and bring their abilities into action.
ר' יצחק דוד גראסמאןHistory and storiesRead more
Why is it not enough simply to aim not to be wicked?
Mesilat Yesharim explains that settling for a spiritual minimum comes from wanting an easy life. Even in this world, seeing others advance while one falls behind causes pain. In the world of truth, recognizing that one failed to fulfill one's potential will bring still greater and enduring shame.
מסילת ישריםMussar and characterRead more
Why is it wrong to reproach a new generation by saying, “That never happened in our day”?
Each generation has different challenges, different people, and different circumstances. Simply comparing the present generation with an earlier one and declaring that things used to be better does not express wisdom.
Редакция «Taking the Parshiyos With Us»Family and educationRead more
How should we understand the words “Do not say that former times were better than these”?
Reb Bunim of Pshischa explains that one should not lament having had more strength and potential when young as though these were one's own possessions. Wisdom was lent to a person rather than belonging to them independently.
ר' בונם מפרשיסחא זצ"לMussar and characterRead more
What can help someone decide when they want to leave yeshiva?
R’ Yitzchak Dovid Grossman did not force the young Yosef Gigi to stay, but asked him to consider on his walk to the bus what kind of life each path would lead to. He encouraged him to think about his future family, children, and overall direction. The young man returned and stayed to learn; the story shows how considering long-term consequences can reveal the importance of a present choice.
ר' יצחק דוד גראסמאן שליט''אFamily and educationRead more
Why should I not postpone facing a spiritual challenge until later?
The author explains that a particular trial may offer a unique opportunity to develop abilities that will not return later. Spiritual capacities are compared to muscles: using them strengthens them, while leaving them unused weakens them. Thinking “I will manage next time” risks losing both the opportunity and the strength needed to meet it.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMussar and characterRead more
What made Avraham great if his spiritual potential was already present from birth?
Having great abilities does not mean that a person will fulfil their potential. Avraham had to turn his potential into action, and his trials gave him that opportunity. The article explains that by passing his trials, including the Akeidah, he reached the level originally within his capacity.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אWeekly parshaRead more
How can caring about other people's happiness help a person become happier?
In the story, students had little success finding their named balloons while each searched only for their own. When everyone instead handed each balloon they found to its owner, all the students quickly received their balloons. The lesson is that caring about other people's happiness and doing good for them brings happiness to oneself.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMussar and characterRead more
How is Rachel's silence toward Leah connected with God remembering her?
The author asks why the merit of giving Leah the identifying signs took so long to bear fruit. He connects it with the episode in which Leah accused Rachel of taking her husband, and Rachel did not remind her that she herself had enabled the marriage. Rachel's restraint and refusal to hurt Leah are presented as the merit that opened the heavenly doors.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMussar and characterRead more
What care for others earned Noach and Yosef the title of tzaddik?
The Midrash quoted in the article connects this title with feeding God's creatures. Even when hungry himself, Noach first cared about feeding others, both people and animals. The author presents this as overcoming personal desires and putting another's need before one's own.
מדרש תנחומאMussar and characterRead more
Why was Avraham answered first when he prayed for Avimelech?
The article cites Rashi's teaching that someone who seeks mercy for another while needing the same thing is answered first. Avraham himself was waiting for children, yet he prayed for Avimelech. The author explains that setting aside his own need and focusing on another person provided the merit through which he had a child.
How can I notice when my small personal interests are obscuring someone else's distress?
In the story, a fundraiser saw a synagogue on fire and admitted with embarrassment that his first thought was about three doughnuts he had left there. The example shows how a minor personal loss can dominate one's attention during a much larger crisis. Working on one's character means setting oneself aside for the moment and thinking about others.
ר' ש. קאפלין שליט"אMussar and characterRead more
What does it mean to overcome one's middot for another person?
In the story, Baba Sali postponed a long-awaited journey and held an extended meal with a man seeking a blessing for a child. He explained that giving up one's own comfort for someone else can open closed heavenly doors. The practical lesson is to set aside personal interests and focus on another person's need.
בבא סאליMussar and characterRead more
How should I pray for people taking part in military action that I disagree with?
The author urges heartfelt prayer for everyone's safety even when he considers the operation potentially wrong from a Torah perspective. This prayer rests on God's mercy: He hears pleas and helps even people who are not acting according to His will. Disagreement with a decision does not remove concern for people's lives.
How does Ashrei describe God's response to a request that could harm the person making it?
According to the Hafla’ah, God often gives a person beneficial things even before they pray. Yet someone may plead for something that would harm them and suffer deeply from not having it. The words “He will hear and save them” mean that God answers their plea while preventing the harm that fulfilling the request could have caused.
Does a successful military operation prove that the decision to carry it out was right?
Speaking about the Entebbe raid, R’ Shach distinguished its success from whether the decision was right. The article explains that Divine providence and miracles may accompany even actions that do not follow God's will, because He shows mercy in those circumstances too. Success alone therefore does not establish that an action was right.
ר' שך זצ"לBitachon and emunahRead more
Should I help someone who does not listen to me?
The text explains that following God's ways includes helping someone who does not do what we want. God shows kindness even to people who do not listen to Him. Disagreement with someone should therefore not, by itself, become a reason to withhold help.
Avrohom Dov Kohn – אברהם דוב הכהן כהןMussar and characterRead more
How can I help others without turning kindness into a way to gain recognition?
Kindness should serve the recipient without seeking respect or personal benefit. R’ Meir Lev sent donations to Gateshead Yeshiva under the name Mariano Levito so that the yeshiva would not know who was giving. He disclosed this only when others suspected that he was not supporting the yeshiva at all.
Avrohom Dov Kohn – אברהם דוב הכהן כהןCommunity and tzedakahRead more
What intention distinguishes true chesed from helping for personal gain?
The cited explanation of Rabbi Eliezer criticizes charity performed for self-aggrandizement. The author contrasts this with Avraham’s chesed, which is directed toward the recipient’s benefit. He emphasizes that Jews must also examine their motives, since an outwardly generous act can contain self-interest.
רבי אליעזרCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Why is the example of the ant insufficient for learning the prohibition of theft?
Rav Eliyahu Falk, drawing on the Nesivos, explains that ants do not take grain from one another but do take it from the farmer. Their behavior therefore illustrates concern only for their own group. The Torah demands more: avoiding theft altogether and extending kindness beyond one’s own circle, as Avraham welcomed guests regardless of their origin.
הרב אליהו פאלקMussar and characterRead more
What does Avraham’s eagerness to seek guests teach us?
The author emphasizes that Avraham did not merely welcome guests but actively sought opportunities for hospitality. His kindness extended beyond his own family. The publication identifies this trait as the root of charity and interest-free mutual assistance among his descendants.
ר' ש. קאפליןCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Can a Jew permanently lose their connection with God?
The publication cites the Or Hachaim’s teaching that after the giving of the Torah, a Jew cannot reach a spiritual point of no return. The author concludes that a person does not need to create their connection with God anew. Their task is to feel and strengthen the connection that already exists.
אור החיים הק'Bitachon and emunahRead more
How does the author suggest approaching questions about God that arise from suffering?
The author distinguishes seeking guidance and explanation from accusatory questions directed at God. In his view, the latter can obscure the feeling of connection with God, so he urges seeking guidance. When discussing loss of faith during the Holocaust, he explicitly says that those who endured these trials must not be judged.
ר' ש. קאפליןBitachon and emunahRead more
How do Pesukei Dezimra prepare a person for the Amidah?
R’ Shmuel Zucker connects the word zimrah with cutting and explains that Pesukei Dezimra remove spiritual barriers before the Amidah. The author adds a simpler explanation: words of praise help cut away distractions. This reveals a person’s connection with God and prepares them to approach the Amidah with a deeper awareness of that bond.
How does fasting on Yom Kippur help a person feel close to God?
In the explanation cited from Derech Hashem, fasting is described as the main means of the special closeness to God on Yom Kippur. Withdrawal from physicality helps bring spiritual elevation. The author connects this with revealing a Jew’s existing bond with God.
דרך השםHolidays and datesRead more
How does the author explain the awakening of faith among hostages previously distant from religious observance?
The author understands this as the revelation of an existing connection with God. In his explanation, the loss of familiar material activities and comforts made that connection perceptible. The accounts of prayer, observance, and refusal to change religion serve as examples of this awakening.
ר' ש. קאפליןBitachon and emunahRead more
What do the sukkah and the four species teach about a Jew’s connection with God?
The author explains the sukkah’s lack of a conventional roof as a symbol of the absence of a barrier between Israel and God. He also cites a teaching that the four species have no intermediary angel. Even the aravah, representing someone without spiritual merits, is included: a person’s shortcomings do not erase their direct connection with God.
ר' ש. קאפליןHolidays and datesRead more
According to the explanation given, why did Yaakov himself fight Esav’s angel?
The author explains that the nations have heavenly representatives, whereas Israel is governed directly by God. Yaakov therefore had no angelic representative to fight on his behalf. The episode illustrates Israel’s direct connection with God.
ר' ש. קאפליןBitachon and emunahRead more
How does the account of Rav Yaakov Yehuda Falk illustrate detachment from material concerns?
In the account, Rav Yaakov Yehuda Falk knew neither the asking price of his house nor his own salary and referred the questions to his wife. The author presents these incidents as evidence of how little material matters occupied him. He connects this with the rabbi’s deep spiritual focus.
ר' ש. קאפליןHistory and storiesRead more
Why does the Torah say that Avraham went as God had told him?
The author suggests applying Rav Dunner’s explanation about Noach to Avraham. Although Avraham had been promised great benefits, he departed in order to fulfill God’s command. The wording of the verse highlights that motive.
ר' ש. קאפליןWeekly parshaRead more
Why does the Torah emphasize that Noach built the ark as God commanded?
Rav Dunner explains that Noach could have built the ark primarily to save himself and his family. The Torah instead emphasizes his motive: he was fulfilling God’s will. The lesson concerns performing a commandment because God commanded it rather than for personal benefit.
Rav DunnerWeekly parshaRead more
Why can wanting complete freedom create inner tension?
The author links this tension to the conflict between wanting to do everything on one’s own terms and life’s unavoidable limitations. He recommends accepting the need for rules and boundaries. This addresses the particular conflict between expecting complete freedom and facing reality.
ר' ש. קאפליןHealth and soulRead more
How did a job help a young man understand his difficulties in yeshiva?
The author advised one father to let his son try working, expecting this to reveal his difficulties with discipline. The young man was dismissed for lateness and absences and realized that yeshiva itself was not the underlying problem. The author later met him and noted his progress and continued yeshiva studies.
ר' ש. קאפליןMussar and characterRead more
Can a student feel loved by an educator who treats him strictly?
In the account, yeshiva staff questioned the head’s strict treatment of a struggling student. Rav Indorsky discovered that the boy named his mother and the head of the yeshiva as the two people who truly loved him. The author sees this as an example of a student recognizing care behind strictness and emphasizes the need to balance gentleness with discipline.
ר' ש. קאפליןFamily and educationRead more
How can gentle parenting be combined with the need to say no?
The author argues that a gentle approach should be combined with clear rules and boundaries. A parent must be able to say no because a child needs discipline. Complete freedom, even when it appears attractive, can hinder the child’s development.
ר' ש. קאפליןFamily and educationRead more
May educational methods change when earlier generations educated differently?
When Rav Dovid Soloveitchik was asked whether education had changed, he answered affirmatively. His reason was that children themselves had changed. In the account, this answer resolves a father’s objection that educational methods must not change.
ר' דוד סלובייציקFamily and educationRead more
Why is a gentler approach needed in educating children?
Rav Michl Yehuda Lefkovitz explained that children have become more sensitive, so earlier disciplinary measures cannot simply be applied to them. In his comparison, withholding chocolate can have the effect that physical punishment once had. This supports a gentler approach to education.
ר' מיכל יהודה לפקוביץFamily and educationRead more
What helps when the demands of Torah seem too difficult?
The author advises reminding ourselves that observing Torah is for our benefit. The difficulty of observance does not diminish its value: through it, a person earns eternal reward.
ר' ש. קאפליןMussar and characterRead more
How can a person maintain faith in God’s love during difficulties?
The author encourages remembering that God loves a person unconditionally and acts for their benefit. A mother’s love is presented as an illustration that helps us understand this love. Challenges can cleanse a person of sins and provide opportunities for spiritual growth.
ר' ש. קאפליןBitachon and emunahRead more
According to Rav Koppelman, why did the angel tell Hagar to return to Sarah although God saw her suffering?
Rav Koppelman explained that in this case Sarah’s strictness was intended for Hagar’s benefit and growth. God’s compassion for her pain did not mean that the challenge should end. He used this explanation to persuade a student to remain in yeshiva, and the student later credited those additional years with shaping him.
Rav KoppelmanWeekly parshaRead more
Is it known with certainty how many blessings Rav Moshe Feinstein recited over tefillin?
The article presents conflicting testimony: Rav Dovid Birnbaum and another source report one blessing, while Rav Moshe's grandson heard him assume that two are recited. Rav Moshe himself writes in Igros Moshe of the practice of reciting the second blessing even without an interruption. The recording does not resolve the conflict; his effort to place the head tefillin soon after the hand tefillin makes sense under either practice.
Rav Shimon SzimonowitzHalachaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Does kissing the tefillin count as an interruption between the hand and head tefillin?
In Igros Moshe, Rav Moshe Feinstein inclines to the view that such a kiss is not an interruption because it causes no delay. Permission cannot simply be inferred from the practice of wrapping, since Rosh does not regard the wrapping itself as part of the mitzvah. The recording shows Rav Moshe kissing the head tefillin immediately before putting it on.
Rav Moshe FeinsteinHalachaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
May one hold the head tefillin by its straps while putting it on?
Shulchan Aruch prohibits letting tefillin hang. Mishnah Berurah, following Taz and Pri Megadim, nevertheless permits holding the head tefillin by its straps while placing it on the head, because this is necessary for putting it on.
Mishnah BerurahHalachaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Should one imitate Rav Moshe Feinstein's distinctive order of putting on tefillin?
Rav Moshe initially made only a few arm wraps and wrapped the finger, then put on the head tefillin and completed the wraps; he considered wrapping the finger part of putting on the hand tefillin. However, he did not wish to impose his practice on others. He told students who asked about imitating him to follow the common practice and make the seven wraps immediately.
Rav Moshe FeinsteinHalachaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Should the seven arm wraps be made before putting on the head tefillin?
Tur, citing Rosh, and Shulchan Aruch place the head tefillin before the arm wraps to minimize the interval between the acts of donning and their blessings. Beit Yosef emphasizes that the first blessing also covers the head tefillin. However, the Arizal wrapped first, regarding the wrapping as part of the mitzvah; the common practice is to make all seven wraps before the head tefillin.
Rav Shimon SzimonowitzHalachaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why is Yosef and Binyamin's weeping connected with future destructions of sanctuaries?
Rashi connects their weeping with the two Temples and the Mishkan at Shiloh. Gur Aryeh explains this through the principle that the ancestors' experiences are signs for their descendants: their tears also concern future generations.
רש"י; גור אריהWeekly parshaRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha