Skip to main content
.

Parshat Tzav — questions and answers

Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.

9,850 entries

  1. What is kinyan odita, and how does it relate to selling chametz?

    Odita means acknowledging that property belongs to the person to whom one wishes to transfer it. The Ketzot considers it a full-fledged kinyan valid for selling chametz, and Mechirat Chametz Kehilchato adopts its use. The passage also notes that the Mishnah Berurah and Aruch Hashulchan do not mention odita among the kinyanim used for this sale.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  2. Why is using hefker beit din hefker in the chametz sale disputed?

    Rav Moshe Feinstein, together with two other rabbis, additionally transferred ownership of chametz to the non-Jew through the authority of beit din. Some Rishonim, however, hold that this authority only allows property to be declared ownerless, rather than transferred to another owner. It is also uncertain whether ordinary authorization to sell chametz empowers the rabbi to convene a beit din for this purpose. For this reason, Rav Zalman Nechemia Goldberg did not consider introducing the practice worthwhile.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  3. Can a handshake serve as a kinyan when selling chametz?

    Situmta is an act that finalizes a transaction under an accepted commercial custom, and a handshake can serve this role. The Mishnah Berurah and Aruch Hashulchan include it in the chametz sale procedure. A handshake alone is not relied upon because its significance is not universal, and authorities dispute situmta’s Torah-level validity and its applicability to transactions undertaken for religious requirements.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  4. Can chametz be transferred to a non-Jew through kinyan sudar?

    Rav Yechezkel Landau considered kinyan sudar especially suitable for selling chametz, and Tosafot recognize its effectiveness between a Jew and a non-Jew. The Shach questions the evidence for its applicability to such a transaction. It is therefore used alongside other kinyanim, without treating money, agav, and sudar together as sufficient by themselves.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  5. How is kinyan agav used in selling chametz, and why is it not relied on alone?

    Kinyan agav allows movable property to be acquired together with real property; in the example given, the purchaser pays to rent shelves attached to the house and acquires the chametz with them. Authorities disagree about whether this kinyan works on a Torah level and whether it applies between a Jew and a non-Jew. It is therefore not treated as sufficient even when combined with a monetary kinyan.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  6. Why is payment insufficient as the sole kinyan in the sale of chametz?

    Rashi considers money an effective means of acquiring movable property in a transaction between a Jew and a non-Jew. Rabbeinu Tam and most Rishonim require meshichah, an act of physically acquiring the item. Since the purchaser generally does not take the chametz, the monetary kinyan is supplemented with other methods of acquisition.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  7. Why are several methods of acquisition used when selling chametz?

    Halachic authorities disagree about which kinyanim work between a Jew and a non-Jew and which are effective under Torah law. Many hold that chametz sold with the intention of repurchasing it is not included in bittul, so its sale must be valid on a Torah level. Combining several kinyanim accommodates as many opinions as possible.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  8. Must the types of chametz being sold be listed?

    The Aruch Hashulchan requires each seller to specify the types of chametz being sold; describing its location and approximate value also demonstrates seriousness. Rav Moshe Feinstein explains that when one person or a few people sell, a list is necessary so the purchaser knows what he is acquiring. For a communal sale, he permits omitting the list because the purchaser understands that he is buying a broad range of chametz products.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  9. Must one personally perform a kinyan to appoint a rabbi to sell chametz?

    A verbal statement appointing the rabbi as one’s agent to sell chametz to a non-Jew is sufficient. The authorization form and lifting an object supplied by the rabbi express seriousness of intent rather than constitute a necessary condition of appointment. Rav Moshe Feinstein permits appointment by telephone in a situation of great need.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  10. How does the author explain why selling chametz can be a legitimate solution rather than a subterfuge?

    The author proposes understanding the sale as a genuine transfer of ownership that removes possession of prohibited chametz. He draws an analogy to Tosafot’s explanation that bittul chametz works by declaring it ownerless, whereas Rashi connects bittul with fulfilling the commandment to destroy chametz. Selling likewise removes ownership, and this is offered as a possible justification for the accepted practice.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  11. May actual chametz be included in the sale, rather than only mixtures containing chametz?

    The text presents a dispute: Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik opposed selling actual chametz with its subsequent return, but allowed mixtures containing less than half chametz. Rav Henkin advised a pious person to avoid selling actual chametz, while allowing reliance on the accepted practice in cases of significant financial loss. Rav Moshe Feinstein permitted including actual chametz, and his position is described as commonly accepted. Because of the disagreement, the author recommends consulting one’s rabbi for practical guidance.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  12. What lesson emerges from the story of someone mocking the chametz sale in Brisk?

    When someone began ridiculing the chametz sale, Rav Simcha Zelig Riegeur removed him from the room. Rav Chaim Soloveitchik approved of this response. He explained that accepted practices of the Jewish people must not be mocked.

    Rav Chaim SoloveitchikHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  13. Why is the sale of chametz usually entrusted to a rabbi?

    People conducting their own sales made mistakes: they forgot to sign the contract, sold after benefiting from chametz became forbidden, or omitted the places where it was stored. Entrusting the sale to a halachic expert greatly reduced these errors. Although communal sales faced objections as a possible subterfuge, they became accepted practice.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  14. How can sold chametz remain in a Jew’s home?

    The Bach permitted ownership of chametz to pass to a non-Jew while the chametz remained on the premises when removing large stocks of liquor and equipment was impractical. The sale must genuinely transfer ownership. The Bach emphasized that the purchaser must also understand that this is a real transaction.

    Rav Yoel SirkesHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  15. What helps reinforce a serious attitude toward selling chametz?

    Rav Yosef Eliyahu Henkin recommends placing the chametz in a designated area that one does not enter during Pesach. This reinforces the seller’s understanding that the sale is genuine. He also prefers a sale valid under civil law, although other authorities discuss whether this is necessary.

    Rav Yosef Eliyahu HenkinHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  16. What intention is required when selling chametz?

    The sale of chametz must be treated as a genuine transaction transferring ownership to a non-Jew. The Kitzur Shulchan Aruch stresses that it must not become an empty habit or a joke. The seller must seriously intend to carry out a valid sale.

    Kitzur Shulchan AruchHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  17. Is there an early source for selling chametz and receiving it back after Pesach?

    The Tosefta allows a Jew traveling on a ship with a non-Jew to sell him chametz before Pesach and receive it back as a gift afterward. The Aruch Hashulchan sees this as a basis for the accepted practice. The Ritva objects to an annual sale followed by repurchase, but the Shulchan Aruch does not adopt that restriction and requires genuine intent to transfer ownership.

    Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  18. Why tell the Exodus story through questions and answers when everyone already knows it?

    Rav Shmuelevitz explains that the Exodus should be recounted as though it were being told for the first time. Questions and answers encourage thought and conversation, restoring freshness to a familiar story. Even someone with nobody to ask questions should therefore ask and answer them personally.

    Rav ShmuelevitzHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  19. How can familiarity interfere with spiritual growth?

    Rav Chaim Shmuelevitz explains that familiarity weakens the sense of holiness and the desire to reach higher. A comfortable position encourages resistance to change, while repeated meaningful actions can lose their perceived value. Familiarity can therefore lead to spiritual regression as well as stagnation.

    Rav Chaim ShmuelevitzMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  20. Why did people have to enter the Temple through one gate and leave through another?

    Rav Yaakov Emden explains that passing through the same gate again could make the surroundings overly familiar. A person might begin behaving in the Temple as though at home. Different routes for entering and leaving reminded visitors of the place’s holiness and the reverence it required.

    Rav Yaakov EmdenMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  21. What can a person offer Hashem when asking for blessings?

    Rabbi Dr. Yechiel Michael Kossowsky reads the instruction not to appear empty-handed as a call to bring thoughts of repentance and a resolve for more Torah and sincerity in mitzvot. An immediate transformation of one's entire personality is not required, but a real step toward Hashem is. Requests for gifts should be accompanied by spiritual effort within one's abilities.

    RABBI DR. YECHIEL MICHAEL KOSSOWSKYMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  22. Why is school alone insufficient for Jewish education?

    Rabbi Dr. Yechiel Michael Kossowsky stresses that a warm Jewish atmosphere and parental upbringing leave deep roots even in those who later stray. Passing inner spiritual life to the next generation requires more than schooling: it needs a spiritually rich environment. Such experience preserves good qualities and a connection to the ancestors' path.

    RABBI DR. YECHIEL MICHAEL KOSSOWSKYFamily and educationRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  23. What lesson about the people's future does the author see in the vision of dry bones?

    Rabbi Dr. Yechiel Michael Kossowsky relates the stages of the vision to despair, material rebuilding, and full spiritual life. In his interpretation, building and defending the land alone do not secure Israel's enduring survival. A living community animated by the spirit of G-d is essential.

    RABBI DR. YECHIEL MICHAEL KOSSOWSKYBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  24. What does Yehoshua's encounter with the angel teach about Torah and prayer in difficult times?

    Rabbi Dr. Yechiel Michael Kossowsky explains the angel's answer as addressing the people's present conduct rather than predicting the outcome of the struggle. Even during war and siege, Torah study and divine service must not be treated as secondary. The study hall and synagogue are fundamental to Jewish survival.

    RABBI DR. YECHIEL MICHAEL KOSSOWSKYPrayerRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  25. How can a rebellious child's question become good news?

    Rabbi Dr. Yechiel Michael Kossowsky explains that a rebel often rejects the parents' path because he thinks he knows better. Yet his own child may likewise reject his misguided path and return to the grandparents' tradition. The same question can therefore signal either departure or return.

    RABBI DR. YECHIEL MICHAEL KOSSOWSKYFamily and educationRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  26. How can we rebuke others without becoming arrogant?

    R' Yehoshua Segal Deutsch teaches that self-effacement should not prevent responding to violations of Torah, but the needed authority should be used only for that purpose. Effective teaching requires Torah knowledge to be clear and readily available to the teacher. Blessings for fellow Jews must remain in one's heart, and one should praise them before Hashem.

    R' Yehoshua Segal DeutschMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  27. How can we improve ourselves when sudden change is overwhelming?

    R' Yehoshua Segal Deutsch interprets karpas yachatz as a call to overcome material inclinations gradually by dividing the task into parts. Human nature cannot be brought under control overnight. Encouraging others to improve can also inspire the speaker to change.

    R' Yehoshua Segal DeutschMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  28. Why does the Haggadah separately hope for being in Eretz Yisrael and becoming free?

    R' Yehoshua Heschel of Cracow proposes that future redemption, like the Exodus, will be preceded by six months of relief from oppression. He connects the two hopes to the dispute over whether complete redemption will occur in Nisan or Tishrei. Under the Nisan view, full redemption could come by the next Pesach; under the Tishrei view, if relief has not yet begun, only the preliminary stage is expected by the next Pesach.

    R' Yehoshua Heschel of CracowMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  29. What does Dayenu mean if each subsequent miracle was also necessary?

    R' Eliyahu Hakohen Ha'itamari explains that an argument could be made for a different course at each stage. For example, surviving Egyptian idols might have reminded people of Hashem's victory, but could also have suggested that He was unable to destroy them. Our praise is that Hashem considered these arguments and chose what was best for Israel and the glory of His Name.

    R' Eliyahu Hakohen Ha'itamariHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  30. According to Rav Weiss, what has sustained our ancestors and us?

    R' Yitzchak Yaakov Weiss connects these words to the statement to Avraham that his descendants would be strangers in a land not their own. Maintaining some distance from the surrounding nations has sustained the Jewish people throughout their exiles.

    R' Yitzchak Yaakov WeissHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  31. What does Lavan's hidden plot teach about Hashem's protection?

    R' Shlomo Zalman Auerbach notes that Lavan's intention to destroy Yaakov is known through the Sages even though the Torah does not state it explicitly. Likewise, many plots against Israel remain unknown to their intended victims. The nations can therefore recognize Hashem's kindness especially clearly, because they know their own plans that failed.

    R' Shlomo Zalman AuerbachBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  32. Whom do we praise when the Haggadah moves from our ancestors' disgrace to praise?

    R' David Hanaggid explains that the main praise is of Hashem, who performed miracles and brought our ancestors out of Egypt despite their lowly standing. There is also praise of Israel for preserving faith and Avraham's teaching through hardship. Yet this too returns to Hashem, who chose Avraham and established his descendants.

    R' David HanaggidHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  33. Should a recipient's name be disclosed if doing so would raise more charity?

    When asked about raising wedding funds for a respected person, Rav Yaakov Ruderman ruled that the appeal should remain anonymous even if it raised less. A person's dignity is precious and much harder to restore than a financial loss.

    Rav Yaakov RudermanCommunity and tzedakahRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  34. Why was a poor person's bikkurim basket kept while a wealthy person's was returned?

    Rav Aharon Backs explains that the wealthy brought abundant fruit, while a poor person's modest offering looked more substantial in its basket. The Torah therefore allows an additional financial loss to preserve the poor person's dignity. His self-respect matters more than the basket's value.

    Rav Aharon BacksCommunity and tzedakahRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  35. How should one recline during the Seder?

    Reclining should convey freedom: lean to the left without adopting an uncomfortable position. The text records the custom that women do not recline.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  36. How should the beginning of the Seder be conducted so children stay awake?

    Begin the Seder promptly after nightfall and returning from Maariv. Read the Haggadah without delay and save extended commentary for later, so the children remain awake for matzah, maror, and the meal.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»Family and educationRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  37. May water be drunk immediately after the wine at the Seder?

    A glass of water may be drunk immediately after swallowing the wine. The text says the water should be on the table when the blessing over the wine is recited so that it is included in that blessing.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  38. What size cup should be used at the Seder, and how much must be drunk?

    The cup must hold at least a revi'it; to avoid drowsiness, use a cup no larger than necessary. When the Seder falls on Friday night, a larger revi'it measure is specified for the first cup. Preferably drink the entire cup; if very difficult, most of it suffices, and in exceptional circumstances most of a revi'it suffices even from a larger cup. Two swallows are preferred; if difficult, four minutes are allowed, and some authorities allow five to six when necessary.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  39. What may be drunk for the four cups at the Seder?

    Red wine is preferable; someone unable to drink wine may use grape juice. For people allergic to both wine and grape juice, the text allows chamar medina and gives tea and coffee as examples.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  40. Within how much time should a kezayit of matzah be eaten?

    Preferably eat the kezayit for the Torah mitzvah within two minutes, or at least within four; some authorities allow five to six minutes, and nine is given for very exceptional circumstances. Timing begins when swallowing starts, so chew calmly and thoroughly. If difficulty arises, the text allows sipping a little water while chewing.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  41. How much matzah is required for korech and afikoman?

    Korech is a rabbinic mitzvah requiring a kezayit of matzah and a kezayit of maror. Afikoman is also rabbinic and requires one kezayit of matzah, with two preferable. The text calls for handmade matzah for motzi matzah, korech, and afikoman; if this is impossible or the required quantities are difficult, consult a rabbi.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  42. What is the volume of a kezayit for matzah, and why are different sizes given?

    A kezayit is defined by the volume of half an egg, but authorities disagree about the relationship between present-day eggs and those of Talmudic times. For a Torah obligation, the text gives 45–50 cc according to the Chazon Ish and 25.6–28.8 cc according to Rav A. Chaim No'eh. It cites the Mishna Brura as requiring the larger measure for a Torah mitzvah while allowing the smaller measure for a rabbinic mitzvah. A rabbi should be consulted about the precise portion of handmade matzah corresponding to these volumes.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  43. May I keep leaving for the kitchen while eating matzah at the Seder?

    Eating a little matzah between trips to the kitchen may take too long to fulfill the mitzvah properly. Remain at the table and calmly finish the required amount first. The same applies to wine, maror, korech, and afikoman; the cooking can be checked after completing the mitzvot.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  44. How can Pesach preparations leave room to enjoy the holiday?

    Avoid unnecessary hard work and cleaning. Finish the final preparations early enough to rest a little and be ready to begin the Seder immediately after Maariv.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»Holidays and datesRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  45. Does food become chametz if it falls on the floor or a chair during Pesach?

    According to the instruction given, falling on a floor or chair does not make food chametz, even when it is hot. It should be washed for hygienic reasons.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  46. May the search for chametz be spread over several nights?

    If checking every room in one night is too difficult, divide the search among other nights while observing all its laws and leaving no chametz in checked rooms. Leave at least one place containing chametz unchecked for the search with a blessing on the night of 14 Nisan. If the whole house is already completely clean, the text instructs someone else to hide the customary ten pieces so a proper search can be conducted.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  47. May tahini and other kitniyot be eaten after Pesach cleaning but before Pesach?

    They may be used before Pesach even after the house has been cleaned for the holiday. They should not be cooked in utensils intended for Pesach, and the Ashkenazi practice cited does not permit them on Pesach itself.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  48. Must toys be scrubbed thoroughly before Pesach?

    Any edible chametz on toys must be removed or rendered inedible. There is no need to scrub the toys.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  49. What should be done before Pesach with books that may contain crumbs?

    If siddurim, bentchers, or other books may contain chametz crumbs, clean and check them thoroughly. The other option given is to put them away with the other chametz utensils and include them in the chametz sale.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  50. Must clothing, pockets, and blankets be checked for chametz after washing?

    After washing with detergent or dry cleaning, checking is unnecessary. Otherwise, clean and check thoroughly by brushing or shaking, and wipe inaccessible crumbs in seams or crevices with a detergent-soaked cloth. Clothing that will not be worn on Pesach can be put away without checking, with its chametz sold.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

By weekly parsha