Parshat Behar — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
2,970 entries
Was the Torah given on the sixth or seventh of Sivan?
In the discussion presented, the sages give the date as the sixth of Sivan, while Rabbi Yosi says it was the seventh. All agree that the Jews arrived in the Sinai wilderness at the beginning of the month and that the Torah was given on Shabbat. According to Rabbi Yosi, the month began on Sunday; according to the other sages, it began on Monday. Rabbi Yosi also explains that Moshe added a day of preparation and God agreed with him.
Ханох ЛернерHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Why can someone have plenty and still be dissatisfied?
In the story, a wealthy Roman official held a lavish feast but became furious and wrecked the table because the nuts he wanted were missing. His desire to have everything deprived him of joy in what he already had. A righteous person, by contrast, is satisfied with little through God’s blessing. The lesson is to be grateful for what we receive and remember that we cannot have everything at once.
Цюпа ГензельMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How can we do good without turning it into a demand for a favor in return?
Helping someone should not lead us to assume that they now owe us a favor. We should strive to do good selflessly and joyfully, judge others favorably, and try to understand their circumstances. When we receive kindness, we should express gratitude and support the person who helped us when an opportunity arises.
Лейб КаханэMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why should lending money to someone in need not become a way to earn interest?
The article describes lending money to someone in need as a mitzvah and charging interest as a strictly forbidden way to profit. The purpose of this assistance is to ease another person’s situation, rather than increase their expenses. The desire to help should therefore not be combined with a desire to profit at their expense.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why must a Torah scholar be especially careful about personal conduct?
A person with greater spiritual responsibility shapes how others regard what that person represents. A Torah scholar’s misconduct therefore dishonors both the scholar and Torah. The article includes dishonest business dealings, hatred of the sages, and failure to speak calmly with others among such behaviors; serving the Creator requires attention even to details.
Шломо ФрейдкинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
What do the bonfires on Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai’s memorial day teach us?
Fire symbolizes Torah here: it rises upward and can kindle another flame without diminishing itself. The bonfires recall the soul of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, whose inner fervor inspired his students. The lesson is to kindle other souls with Torah and strive for the Jewish people’s unity with the Creator.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Holidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Why is knowing Torah alone not enough to teach it to others?
Failure to accept another person prevents people from fully receiving the wisdom of Torah and passing it on. The text presents Rabbi Akiva’s students as an example of how rivalry and a lack of respect lead to hostility. Rabbi Akiva warned his new students against repeating that mistake, and Torah knowledge spread through them.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Mussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
What mistake did Rabbi Akiva's students make when Rachel approached him?
The students tried to pull Rachel away from Rabbi Akiva by force without finding out who she was. He immediately told them to leave her alone. The author sees their action as a warning sign of disrespect: great spiritual potential does not remove the need to treat a person with care and respect.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Mussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How did Rachel's support help Rabbi Akiva become a Torah scholar?
Rachel recognized Akiva's good qualities and great potential when he was still an ordinary agricultural worker. Despite the threat of losing her inheritance, she married him and gave him confidence in himself. The story emphasizes that her support enabled him to begin studying and become a great Torah scholar.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Family and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
What does the story of the worker whose employer initially withheld his wages teach?
The worker found a favorable explanation each time his employer refused to pay with money, produce, or property. The employer later paid the debt and confirmed that the worker's assumptions had been correct; Sheiltot de Rabbi Achai identifies the worker as Rabbi Akiva. The lesson is to seek explanations in another person's favor as readily as in one's own, since this brings people together while condemnation separates them.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»History and storiesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How does freedom received as a gift differ from freedom achieved through inner work?
Yudit Akkerman calls the liberation from Egypt a merciful gift from God. She connects conscious freedom with the subsequent work on the soul's qualities that prepared the people to receive Torah at Sinai. The release of slaves in the Jubilee year is presented as an image of completing this spiritual work and attaining true freedom.
Юдит АккерманHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What should one work on during the seven weeks of counting the Omer?
Yudit Akkerman describes seven facets of the soul: mercy, restraint, harmony, steadfastness, humility, groundedness, and majesty. Each week develops one facet, while each day explores one of its seven components. She connects this work with the qualities through which the Creator governs the world and with the people's preparation to receive Torah.
Юдит АккерманHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What inner work does the shemittah year teach?
Yudit Akkerman sees the pause in agricultural work as a call to reflect on one's efforts and recognize that their results came through Heaven's blessing. She interprets the field as a person's sphere of activity and the grapevine as a symbol of blessing. Shemittah offers an opportunity to express trust in the Creator and elevate the fruits of one's labor through spiritual work.
Юдит АккерманWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What is the spiritual meaning of stopping work on Shabbat?
Yudit Akkerman explains the 39 categories of work as creating something new in a material world marked by imperfection. Ceasing this work expresses the spiritual elevation of Shabbat, which is filled with prayer, Torah, and meals that connect the material and spiritual. Shabbat gathers and elevates the week's spiritual achievements and provides strength for the following week.
Юдит АккерманHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why forgive someone when I am clearly in the right?
David Elman urges readers to prefer a material loss to hurting another person, since the effects of hurt can persist for years and even generations. Forgiveness matters even when the circumstances support one's own position. He explains that treating others this way brings similar leniency from Heaven and forms a foundation of chesed.
Давид ЭльманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How can I stop justifying hurting someone because they hurt me?
David Elman views this justification as a tactic of the yetzer hara that makes a person focus only on themselves. He connects hurting others with the desire to elevate oneself at another person's expense. Torah study should be accompanied by self-restraint and examination of feelings of superiority, rather than a search for proof that one is right.
Давид ЭльманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Does the prohibition against hurting another person include self-serving advice?
In the quoted commentary, Rashi explains that the prohibition includes causing distress through words and giving advice that harms the recipient's interests while benefiting the adviser. Even when others cannot see the hidden motive, God knows it. The command to fear God therefore applies to actions whose true intention is known only to the person acting.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
What methods of alkaline inhalation does the publication describe?
Elena Demidova describes inhalation using a nebulizer, a saucepan, and a plastic inhaler, presenting these as ways to relieve coughs and a runny nose. The article separately emphasizes caution with hot steam to avoid airway burns. This summarizes the author's medical claims rather than confirming their safety or effectiveness.
Елена ДемидоваHealth and soulRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why is it important for newlyweds to spend plenty of time together?
The authors emphasize that even under ordinary circumstances spouses must make considerable efforts to adjust to each other. The first year is especially demanding because their relationship is still taking shape. They therefore recommend spending as much time together as possible during this period.
Рози Эйнхорн, Шерри ЦиммерманShalom bayitRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Why can giving up one's entire independent life for marriage be harmful?
The authors explain that giving up friends, community, work, and interests can make a husband his wife's sole source of companionship and self-confidence. This dependence can leave her dissatisfied and him feeling overburdened. Moving for marriage should include the prospect of building new social connections and maintaining activities that support a sense of personal fulfillment.
Рози Эйнхорн, Шерри ЦиммерманShalom bayitRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How can I start a family if my work requires frequent long trips?
Rosie Einhorn and Sherry Zimmerman advise the man seeking their help to change his job or schedule so that he spends most of his time in one city. They suggest managing projects partly online and taking shorter business trips. He should begin changing his way of life now, since vague promises to change after a relationship develops are unlikely to reassure a prospective spouse.
Рози Эйнхорн, Шерри ЦиммерманFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How can I begin approaching Torah if I do not yet observe the commandments?
Eliyahu Essas suggests beginning with discussions of Torah topics and reflection on the world and Jewish history. The next step is to make an effort to apply Jewish laws and practices in everyday life. In his explanation, this path gradually opens the possibility of understanding Torah.
Элиягу ЭссасBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
How does knowing Torah differ from studying other subjects?
Eliyahu Essas describes Torah as heavenly light rather than an ordinary field of human knowledge. In his explanation, familiarity with its texts does not by itself amount to an inner understanding of Torah. He links such understanding to belonging to the Jewish people, including sincere converts, and striving to observe Torah law.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What should be ready at home before the Shabbat candles are lit?
Eliyahu Essas explains that everyone in the household should finish their preparations, wash, and put on festive clothing before the candles are lit. The home should be clean, the dishes washed, the food prepared, the table set, and any necessary permitted electrical appliances switched on. If the family welcomes Shabbat early, these preparations should also be completed early.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Can Shabbat be accepted early in summer so that children are not exhausted by the meal?
The response permits lighting candles and accepting Shabbat earlier so that the meal can also begin earlier. The approximate limit given in the text is one hour to one hour and a quarter before sunset, or 40–50 minutes before the local calendar's candle-lighting time; the author does not permit lighting earlier than that. It suggests arranging a separate minyan with a corresponding prayer time for families with young children.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»HalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How should someone approach doubts about God's existence and strengthen their faith?
Eliyahu Essas explains that doubts cannot be eliminated entirely because freedom of choice extends to thought; their appearance should be understood as another occasion to choose one's direction. He points to the transmission of knowledge of the Creator from the patriarchs and Sinai, as well as the survival of the Jewish people, as sources of support. He recommends years of careful, unhurried study of works that deepen understanding of faith, including Gevurot Hashem, Da'at Tevunot, Nefesh HaChaim, Tanya, Emunah Uvitachon, and Michtav MeEliyahu.
Элиягу ЭссасBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How can someone clarify the situation if they are not given a copy of their conversion certificate?
Eliyahu Essas explains that the reason for the delay cannot be established without information about the court and community. He advises checking whether the court is Orthodox, whether it is recognized in the religious world and by Israel's Chief Rabbinate, and what its authority covers. In the case described in the United States, he suggests contacting the Orthodox Union or Young Israel to ask whether the community belongs to either organization, or asking the community's rabbi directly.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why is observing shemittah connected with faith and the people's continued presence in the Land of Israel?
Refraining from cultivating the land for an entire year requires faith that a person's material welfare depends on God and that He will fulfill His promise to sustain the people. Citing the Sages, the author identifies failure to observe shemittah as one cause of exile and sees it as an expression of insufficient faith. He explains that even outstanding leaders cannot bring the people to repair the world without the people's trust in the Creator.
раввин Ари КаннBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What is the spiritual connection between yovel and Yom Kippur?
The article describes yovel as a time when land returns to its owners and the people undergo spiritual renewal, while Yom Kippur offers forgiveness and purification from wrongdoing. Their connection is also expressed in the command to sound the shofar on Yom Kippur in the jubilee year. The author explains that the golden calf created a need both for the cleansing of Yom Kippur and for the restoration symbolized by yovel.
раввин Ари КаннHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why are the laws of shemittah described in greater detail in Behar than in Mishpatim?
Rabbeinu Bahya proposes that during his first ascent of Sinai, Moshe received the general presentation of the laws of shemittah recorded in Mishpatim. During his second ascent, he received the details recorded in Behar. The article presents this as a hypothesis rather than an indisputably established conclusion.
рабейну БахайеWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Do the Jewish sources cited agree about cycles of the world's existence before our own?
The article draws on sources including Sefer HaTemunah to consider human history through the cycles of shemittah and yovel. It presents no single view about our period's place in this system: some commentators consider it the second cycle, others the fourth, and others the seventh. These positions are presented as differing conjectures.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What does the teaching cited in the article about six thousand years of the world's existence mean?
The Talmud cites Rav Katina as teaching that the world will exist for six thousand years, followed by a millennium of destruction. The article explains this as six thousand years of the world in its familiar state, followed by a millennium of rest, using the shemittah year as a model.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why does the account of Creation not reveal all its mysteries?
Ramban explains that belief in the Creator who made and sustains the world is the starting point. The mystery of Creation itself, however, is not disclosed in the Torah's text: it is transmitted through the Oral Tradition originating with Moshe, and those who understand it should not reveal it.
РамбанBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is the shemittah year called “a Sabbath of God”?
Rav Avraham ibn Ezra sees this expression as pointing to the connection between shemittah and the weekly Shabbat. In his explanation, it also contains a hint concerning the mystery of the universe's age.
рав Авраам ибн ЭзраWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What does the Torah require regarding the land during shemittah, and how are people to sustain themselves?
The Torah passage quoted instructs people to sow their fields and prune their vineyards for six years, then stop these activities and let the land rest in the seventh year. The author explains that God promises the people who observe these laws a sixth-year harvest abundant enough to provide for the seventh year as well.
раввин Ари КаннHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How can someone continue growing spiritually after moving to Israel?
Moving to Israel should not be seen as the completion of one's personal development. The author explains that the potential gained there calls for greater spiritual effort, humility, and concern for others rather than a focus solely on one's own life.
Элиэзер ФрейдкинWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What helps a person reach spiritual heights?
Eliezer Freidkin explains that spiritual growth requires reducing pride and developing humility. He identifies sharing one's knowledge and experience with others as another condition for growth.
Элиэзер ФрейдкинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№214 глава Бегар, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Why does the High Priest immerse in a mikveh repeatedly on Yom Kippur?
The article connects this with the special holiness of Yom Kippur and its requirement of absolute spiritual purity. This is why the High Priest immerses in a mikveh repeatedly during the day.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How does a modern mikveh connect natural water with an ordinary pool?
The article explains that once the required Torah measure of natural water has been collected, adding other water does not make the mikveh unfit. The modern arrangement described uses this principle: a reservoir of rainwater or groundwater is connected to the immersion pool as communicating vessels.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Why is the verb “will be” singular in the verse about the mikveh?
The article explains the singular form as indicating that the “spring and pit” form a single whole. It derives from this that the mikveh is “clean” when every element of the reservoir is “clean.”
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Must the water in a mikveh be still?
The text distinguishes between water from a natural spring and rainwater. If a mikveh’s water comes solely from a natural spring, both flowing and standing water are permitted; rainwater may not be flowing.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Can a mikveh be made in a pit dug by a person?
Yes. The text explains that the reservoir may be made by a person, for example by digging a pit in the ground. However, the water must enter it naturally: the mention of a spring indicates the water’s natural state, while the pit permits human work in making the reservoir.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Can an ordinary vessel serve as a mikveh?
According to the discussion, a mikveh cannot be a vessel and must be built into the ground. This is derived from the restrictive word “akh” and the contrast between a mikveh and liquid held in a vessel.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Can a liquid other than water be used for a mikveh?
The discussion emphasizes that a mikveh requires water specifically. This is derived from the Torah’s wording about a “gathering of water,” which excludes other liquids.
Леви Гдалевич и Элиягу ЭссасHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
What does the story of the merchant who wanted to keep 99 entrusted coins teach?
A merchant agreed to deliver a teacher’s hundred coins to his family on the condition that he give the wife as much as he wished, then tried to leave her only one coin. A rabbi interpreted the condition against him: since the merchant wanted 99 coins for himself, those were the coins he had to give her. The story shows how exploiting another person’s hardship through clever wording led to punishment for greed.
Цюпа ГензельMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How is knowledge of God connected with the hope for a world without war?
The author distinguishes stability based on military strength from the peace described by the prophets. In his explanation, when the world is filled with knowledge of God, people will no longer consider attacking and killing an acceptable course of action. The article connects this freedom from oppression with the idea of the Jubilee year.
Доктор Арье МарголинMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why is the ear of a Jewish servant who refuses freedom pierced?
The article explains that this ear heard at Sinai that Jews should serve God, yet the person chooses to continue serving another Jew. Piercing the ear expresses disapproval of that choice. Even someone who wishes to remain a servant must be released in the Jubilee year.
Доктор Арье МарголинWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
How does shemittah turn faith from words into action?
The article presents shemittah as a public expression of trust in God: a person stops working the land, relying on God to provide sustenance. This conduct shows others that the land belongs to God. Its lesson is to put what one learns into practice in actual economic life.
Доктор Арье МарголинBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
How should we understand God’s promise, “I will walk among you”?
The author explains this as an invitation to a close spiritual relationship with God: not merely being nearby, but walking together and acting in harmony. The first human hid and was not ready for such a relationship. By receiving the Torah and observing its commandments, Jews can repair that failure.
Доктор Арье МарголинBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
What can I do when I do not understand why the Torah uses a particular word?
The article suggests looking for other places in the Torah where the word appears. Comparing the contexts can help reveal the additional meaning it brings to the passage being studied.
Доктор Арье МарголинOtherRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№370 глава Беар, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha