Parshat Shelach — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
5,099 entries
Is there value in being reliable if others still do not trust me?
Reliability is valuable in itself, regardless of how much others recognize it. Yakov Gelfman explains that through reliability a person resembles the Creator, called the Faithful King, and connects a sincere effort to honor people's trust with help from Heaven and the trust of others.
Яков ГельфманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How should I respond when someone fails to keep a promise?
We should try not to become angry and consider that the person may sincerely have expected to keep the promise. Difficulties may have arisen later, circumstances may have been overlooked, or the person may simply have forgotten amid other demands.
Яков ГельфманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Should I make more promises so that people will start trusting me?
Yakov Gelfman advises against making excessive efforts to win trust, since this can itself arouse suspicion. Because unforeseen circumstances may prevent us from keeping a promise, he recommends avoiding promises where possible while working to accomplish what we would like to promise.
Яков ГельфманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Should a loan be recorded in writing if I trust the borrower completely?
Yakov Gelfman explains that available precautions should be taken even with a completely trustworthy person. In the story he cites, a sage requests a written acknowledgment even from Rav Ashi, because his immersion in Torah study might cause him to forget the debt. Discussing and recording the terms helps prevent conflicting understandings and prolonged quarrels.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Why does trust take so long to earn but can be lost after a single failure?
Trust rests on confidence that a person will not let us down. Even one failure calls that confidence into question, so we should be understanding of other people's caution: destroying is easier than building.
Яков ГельфманMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How does Rav Meir Muchnik explain the connection between the concealment of the World to Come and the desire to live?
Rav Meir Muchnik suggests that complete certainty about bliss in the World to Come might lead some people to seek it prematurely. In his explanation, the instinct for self-preservation and uncertainty about what follows death help a person remain in this life longer and earn reward through their actions.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Does the Torah teach us to endure injustice for the sake of a reward in the World to Come?
The Torah demands concern for the poor and disadvantaged and warns against oppressing them. The prophets call for just judgment and protection of the oppressed, and criticize the wealthy and rulers for abuses. The teaching about future reward and punishment does not cancel the demand to end injustice here.
рав Меир МучникCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
Must we endure a joyless life and expect happiness only in the World to Come?
The Torah does not say that goodness will be available only in the World to Come. God also created many accessible sources of joy in this life, including good food, natural beauty, music, literature, time with loved ones, and humor, so we can appreciate them and enjoy life despite its difficulties.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
What can good deeds give us now, even when people do not thank us?
Helping others and doing useful work can bring satisfaction in themselves. Even when criticized, a person knows that they made an effort, overcame their own limitations, and did something good that God sees; this can provide a sense of achievement and personal worth.
рав Меир МучникMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
How can we avoid using our own hardships to justify hurting others?
Rav Meir Muchnik observes that people often see themselves as victims and find justifications for their own unfair conduct. He invites us to recognize this tendency in ourselves: having a difficult life does not prevent us from hurting others, and only God can ultimately judge each person's responsibility.
рав Меир МучникMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
Why should we avoid envying people who have more money and success?
Having more money and opportunities does not by itself mean that a person is happier. Success often brings risk, competition, overwork, loss of privacy, and too little time for children, while these difficulties may remain invisible to an outsider.
рав Меир МучникMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Can a person strive to do good without certainty about a reward after death?
God placed a natural sense of goodness and justice, and a rejection of evil, within people regardless of their faith. A person can therefore do good by following that sense without a promised reward; the sages say that reason would call for the observance of rationally understandable commandments even if they had not been written in the Torah.
рав Меир МучникMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why are we not given certain knowledge of reward and punishment in the World to Come?
Rav Meir Muchnik suggests that complete certainty about reward and punishment could turn service of God into conduct driven by self-interest and fear. The fact that these consequences are not obvious leaves room to choose goodness sincerely, out of love for God and the world He created.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Why can we believe in the World to Come if no one can confirm its existence?
Rav Meir Muchnik explains that emunah means conviction in God's existence and trust in Him, which can develop through experience and reflection. A person with sound reasons to trust God and the Torah can also accept the teaching about the World to Come transmitted by tradition, even though it cannot be observed directly.
рав Меир МучникBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
If the World to Come is associated with eternity, why do souls wait for the resurrection of the dead?
Rabbi Elyakim Zalkind explains that Gan Eden, Gehinnom, the resurrection of the dead, and the seventh millennium still fall within our framework of time. Gan Eden and Gehinnom are temporary abodes for souls until resurrection, respectively for reward and for punishment and purification. The term olam haba can refer to different future stages, not only to eternity beyond time. Resurrection is followed by the seventh millennium's period of rest and the world's re-creation on a higher level. There will also be a transition into eternity, where the familiar passage of time disappears, but its nature is hidden from us.
рав Эльяким ЗалкиндMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
May water be added to a cold-mist or ultrasonic humidifier on Shabbat?
A cold-mist humidifier does not heat the water, so the process described does not involve cooking or returning liquid to the heat. Water may be added when necessary, provided this does not disconnect the electricity. Water may likewise be added to an ultrasonic humidifier under that condition while water remains and the device is still running.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What happens to Shabbat prohibitions when an illness threatens life?
If doctors consider that an illness may endanger life, prohibitions may be violated to save the patient. The text states this permission for a situation in which permitted actions cannot provide the needed help.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
When may a non-Jew be asked to add water to a hot-steam humidifier on Shabbat?
For someone confined to bed by illness who has the status of a non-dangerously ill person, and for small children, a non-Jew may be asked to add water. If boiled water is unavailable, a non-Jew may be asked to add unboiled water for them. For someone merely uncomfortable with dry air, asking for unboiled water to be added is forbidden; possible leniencies for boiled water are mentioned, but their conditions are not specified here.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
May I add water to a hot-steam humidifier on Shabbat?
Water may not be added to a hot-steam humidifier on Shabbat, even if it has already been fully boiled. Its heating element raises concerns involving cooking and the prohibitions on placing or returning something to the heat.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
What role does trust in God play in observing the commandments?
In his commentary on Mishlei, the Vilna Gaon calls reliance on God the central condition on which the Torah was given to Israel. Complete trust in Him is described as the foundation of all the commandments.
Виленский ГаонBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why should I avoid frequently telling a child “I promise”?
Children are particularly sensitive to broken promises, even ones that seem insignificant to adults. The article recommends generally saying “I will try” and backing words with actions, reserving promises for rare occasions. Keeping one's word to a child preserves their trust and teaches them to keep their own promises.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Family and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How does a child's trust in their parents help them trust God?
A child cannot yet think about God abstractly but can experience their parents' reliability. Parental honesty, consistent boundaries, responsibility, and willingness to admit mistakes create an experience of trust. The article explains that this experience becomes a natural foundation for faith and trust in God.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Family and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can spouses gradually build trust in each other?
Trust grows through small actions that demonstrate reliability and conversations in which spouses share their inner worlds. Unity requires mutual respect and a willingness to give without expecting anything in return. Full trust means knowing that spouses are each other's closest friends and will support one another whatever happens.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Shalom bayitRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can I cope better when someone fails to fulfill a promise?
A person cannot always fulfill a promise, and the failure may not be their fault. The article suggests remembering that God gives us what is allotted to us through other people. This trust helps us accept more calmly when outcomes differ from our expectations.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Bitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Should I put the terms of a deal in writing if I trust the other person?
The Hafetz Haim advised recording business terms down to the smallest detail, because even an honest person can forget something. He himself wrote down all his printing requirements before work on his books began. Such care helps prevent disputes and is compatible with loving people and judging them favorably.
Хафец ХаимMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why is honesty between people connected with the blessing of rain?
The Talmud connects rainfall with the merit of honest people. The Midrash explains that when people return property entrusted to them and fulfill their commitments, God responds similarly toward the grain they have sown. They entrust their harvest to Him, and rain becomes a response to their honesty and trust.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Mussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How does the article connect women's exclusion from the minyan count with the sin of the spies?
The article presents the prayer quorum as a means of rectifying the sin of the spies. Citing Rashi and Midrash Tanhuma, it notes that women did not participate in that sin. It uses this connection to explain why women are not counted among the ten required for this rectification.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»PrayerRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Why does a Jewish community need a permanent center for prayer and spiritual life?
Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky explained that the lack of a shared spiritual center during the Babylonian exile contributed to assimilation and intermarriage. The minyan and synagogue were intended to unite Jews and preserve their identity in the absence of the Temple. This explanation emphasizes regular communal prayer rather than occasional holiday visits.
рабби Яаков КаменецкийCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
How is the weeping after the spies' report connected to the Ninth of Av?
Rabbi Yohanan explains that the people wept after the spies' report on the night of the Ninth of Av. Their baseless weeping became the basis for a day of mourning for generations. On that same date, Jews mourn the destruction of both Temples.
раби ЙохананHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
How is the dispersion of the Jewish people connected to their refusal to enter the Land of Israel?
The article explains that the people refused to enter the Land of Israel and concentrate holiness in one place. They were therefore given a task involving all humanity: to spread God's honor while living dispersed among the nations. Exile is thus connected to the sin of the spies and the statement that God's honor will fill the whole earth.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Weekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Why does a minyan require exactly ten adult Jewish men?
Communal prayer with Kaddish, Kedushah, Barekhu, and public Torah reading requires at least ten adult Jewish men. The Talmud derives the number ten through gezerah shavah: matching words connect the commandment to sanctify God's name among Israel with the ten spies called a congregation.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why did the synagogue become the center of Jewish life in exile?
When the Jewish people lost their land and Temple, the synagogue, the small Temple, became the center of their life. Upon arriving in a new place, Jews first established a place for prayer and Torah study.
рав Пинхас ГольдшмидтCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What was the spies' mistake if they truthfully described the difficulties of conquest?
The author explains that the spies viewed conquest solely in terms of natural forces, leaving out faith and God's help. Life in the Land of Israel requires practical action together with trust in God. Faith likewise does not justify losing touch with reality: both elements must work together.
рав Пинхас ГольдшмидтBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Can a person assume that earning a living depends only on their own abilities?
A person should not assume that earning a living is entirely within their own power. Success may depend on being in the right place at the right time, rather than on intelligence and planning alone. One should therefore remember God's help in material prosperity as well.
рав Пинхас ГольдшмидтMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How should prayer for recovery be combined with seeking medical care?
A believer should seek medical care and make efforts to recover through natural means. At the same time, they pray to reach the right doctor and receive an accurate diagnosis and effective treatment. Action and prayer complement one another.
рав Пинхас ГольдшмидтHealth and soulRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What determines a person's spiritual growth or decline?
Spiritual change depends on a person's efforts or lack of effort. God does not prevent a person from choosing a path, even leaving a mistaken path open. When a person chooses a righteous path, God helps them.
рав Бенцион ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What matters more in spiritual life: a high level or continued growth?
A high spiritual standing does not by itself prevent decline. The first spies were outstanding people, but their growth stopped, whereas Rahav, whose starting point was lower, responded vividly to accounts of the miracles and grew spiritually. What matters is the direction a person is moving in and their ability to keep growing.
рав Иерухам ЛейвовичMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What was dangerous about the very desire to send the first spies?
Examining the land concealed a question about whether it was worth the effort and risk of conquest. Each tribe's wish to rely only on its own representative expressed distrust, while the mission harbored doubts about both the value of God's gift and the possibility of victory. Unconditional trust in God was thus lost.
МальбимBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What will happen to the fast days when Mashiach comes?
According to the quoted prophecy of Zechariah, the fasts of the seventeenth of Tammuz, ninth of Av, third of Tishrei, and tenth of Tevet will become occasions of joy and celebration. The article connects this transformation with the coming of Mashiach.
Пророк ЗхарьяMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why is it so dangerous to turn disagreements into hostility?
The Second Temple was destroyed because of baseless hatred, even though people studied Torah, observed the commandments, and helped one another. Differences of opinion can lead people to regard one another as enemies. The destructive power of such hostility must therefore not be underestimated.
рав Ицхак ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How is the weeping after the spies' return connected with the ninth of Av?
The people wept on the night of the ninth of Av. Rabbah, citing Rabbi Yochanan, explains that this needless weeping made the night a time of weeping for future generations; the article clarifies that punishment falls on that day when sins warrant it.
Раба от имени раби ЙохананаHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How was God's mercy expressed in the punishment of the spies' generation?
Entry into the land was postponed for forty years so that the people of that generation would die in the wilderness. Despite the severity of the punishment, God arranged that they would not die before the age of sixty.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What is the purpose of tzitzit on clothing?
Tzitzit are threads to be worn at the corners of a four-cornered garment. They are meant to remind a person of their obligations to God.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why were the Jews defeated when they decided to enter the land after the sin of the spies?
The next morning, the Jews regretted their lack of courage and decided to enter the land. Moshe explained that they could no longer do so, but they ignored his warning and were defeated by the Amalekites and Canaanites.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why did Moshe send spies if he did not consider the mission necessary?
Moshe sent the spies at the people's insistence. He hoped they would return with an account of the land's beauty and thereby strengthen the people's spirits.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 143 Shlach E Israel 2019, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
May I knowingly put myself in danger while relying on G-d’s help?
In the explanation cited from commentators, including Radak, such conduct is considered testing G-d. Where there is real danger, one may not rely on a miracle. One must make every effort to avoid the danger.
РадакBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 167 vaishlach 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How does Rambam understand the prohibition against testing G-d?
Unlike the cited explanation of many other early commentators, Rambam understands this prohibition as testing a true prophet. One may not refuse to trust him and heed what he says in G-d’s name by repeatedly demanding fresh proof of his prophetic gift.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 167 vaishlach 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
May I do a good deed and ask G-d for help in its merit?
One may do a good deed, such as giving to charity, and ask for help in its merit. However, one must allow for the possibility that the request will not be granted, accept G-d’s decision as being for the best, and bear no resentment toward Him. According to the sages cited in the answer, a person with this attitude is called truly righteous.
рав Арье ГальчукBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 167 vaishlach 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Why is testing G-d permitted when giving a tithe?
In the book of Malachi, G-d explicitly permits giving a tithe and expecting His blessing. According to many opinions, this permission also applies to giving a tenth of one’s income to charity, including support for Torah students and help for the poor. Malbim explains that such a test expresses faith in G-d rather than distrust, because He Himself promised the reward and authorized the test.
рав Арье ГальчукCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 167 vaishlach 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
May I observe the commandments on condition that G-d solves my problems?
According to the explanation of many early commentators cited by Rav Aryeh Galchuk, one may not test G-d by making observance conditional on an improvement in one’s life. One should serve G-d without conditions, even when difficulties occur. The author urges trust that events have a reason and are directed toward our good, while the true reward awaits in the World to Come.
рав Арье ГальчукBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 167 vaishlach 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha