Skip to main content
.

Parshat Vaetchanan — questions and answers

Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.

5,433 entries

  1. In what sense did the greatness of the Second Temple surpass that of the First?

    In material terms, the promise was fulfilled: the Second Temple stood for 420 years, while the First stood for 410. In addition, according to the explanation of the sages cited in the answer, Herod's building surpassed the First Temple in architecture and beauty, even though the Second Temple did not become the final one.

    рав Натан АгресMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  2. Could the First or Second Temple have become the final Temple?

    The answer explains that final redemption can arrive before its appointed time through the people's repentance and spiritual growth. Even the First Temple could therefore have become the last: the Talmud discusses the possibility of Chizkiyahu becoming Mashiach. The Second Temple could likewise have become permanent had its generation merited it, but that possibility depended on its spiritual condition.

    рав Натан АгресMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  3. Why does Haggai call the Second Temple “last” if there will be a Third Temple?

    The word acharon can mean not only “last” but also “subsequent,” without ruling out something that follows it. The example given is Yaakov's arrangement of his family before meeting Esav: Leah's family is called acharonim even though Rachel and Yosef stood behind them. Haggai's words can therefore refer to the Temple following the First without denying a future Third Temple.

    рав Натан АгресMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  4. Must I interrupt the Amidah if the cantor has already begun the repetition?

    If you have not finished the prayer when the cantor begins the repetition, you do not need to interrupt it. You may continue calmly and finish without rushing.

    рав Арье ГальчукPrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  5. What place does the rebuilding of the Temple have in the Amidah?

    Much of the Amidah asks for redemption, and the order of its blessings reflects its stages, from the fruitfulness of the Land of Israel and the return of the exiles to renewed Temple service and thanksgiving. The request for the Temple is also included in the request to rebuild Jerusalem, because the prayer's authors did not separate their restoration. Its position toward the end of the prayer therefore does not make it secondary.

    рав Арье ГальчукPrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  6. When and how should clothing be torn upon seeing the site of the Temple?

    If a person has not seen the Temple site for 30 days, upon seeing it they should stand and tear by hand the outer garment worn both indoors and outdoors by a tefach, approximately 10 cm; the Jerusalem custom associates this with seeing the Western Wall. A verse about the Temple's destruction is recited before tearing, followed by “Blessed is the true Judge” without God's name, but not knowing the words does not cancel the obligation to tear. One may prepare a small cut, wear an old shirt, and remove a jacket or sweater before the site comes into view so that only the shirt is torn. According to the answer, tearing is not required on Shabbat, festivals, the night following Shabbat or a festival, or Chol HaMoed.

    рав Яков ШубHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  7. Should each corner of a tallit katan have one hole or two?

    The number of holes depends on the community's custom. Lithuanian and Sephardic communities generally make one hole, while many Hasidic communities make two.

    рав Яков ШубHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  8. May a woman tie the tzitzit on her husband's tallit herself?

    The Shulchan Aruch permits a woman to make tzitzit, while the Rema cites the opposing opinion and says that a man should do so from the outset. Rabbi Yaakov Shub therefore writes that among Ashkenazim a woman should not make tzitzit. Many Sephardic communities likewise do not follow this practice.

    рав Яков ШубHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  9. When does a metal sheet covering the stove and controls allow uncooked food to be left for Shabbat?

    This is permitted when increasing the flame requires first removing the pots in order to lift the sheet covering the controls. Such a stove has the status of tuach ba-tit, an oven sealed with clay. If the section over the controls can be lifted easily, the stove does not have that status.

    рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  10. Does blocking the stove controls allow undercooked food to be left on it before Shabbat?

    Undercooked food may be left in an oven whose lid is sealed with clay: removing the clay will remind the person of Shabbat before they stir the coals. By analogy, the author suggests that uncooked food may apparently be left on a stove if its controls were taped or tied before Shabbat so that the obstruction must first be removed.

    рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  11. May raw food be placed on a room heater before Shabbat and the pot wrapped in blankets?

    Before Shabbat, uncooked food may be left on a radiator or heater intended for room heating and not ordinarily used to cook or warm food. However, the pot may not be completely covered with blankets, because this constitutes insulating it in a way that adds heat.

    рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  12. May undercooked food be left in an electric oven on Sabbath mode before Shabbat?

    If the food has not reached the stage of ma’akhal ben Derusai, Sabbath mode alone is insufficient, because someone might increase the heat. The text proposes taping the control so that it cannot be turned without removing the tape. If the food has reached that stage, it may be left in an oven that does not operate through a thermostat.

    рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  13. Why study the depths of Torah when we cannot yet understand them?

    Rabbi Yechezkel Landau compares this to a child on a deserted island learning letters despite never having seen books. The child trusts the teacher that, after rescue, those letters will open the way to wisdom. Studying depths of Torah that remain unclear similarly prepares a person for future understanding.

    рабби Иехезкель Ландау из Праги («Цлах»)Bitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  14. Why does prayer describe God as redeeming Israel in the present tense?

    Emunah connects the present and the future, allowing the promised redemption to be experienced as certain even now. For this to happen, faith must become lived knowledge rather than remain an abstract idea.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Bitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  15. What do heaven and earth, as witnesses to the covenant with God, teach us?

    The constancy of nature provides an example of reliability: it follows its established order. Human beings have freedom of choice and can therefore prove unreliable, but the covenant with God calls for faithfulness.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Mussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  16. How can faith endure when circumstances seem hopeless?

    In the allegory, emunah means faithfulness that endures even when circumstances oppose it and truth seems hidden. Such faithfulness requires a willingness to sacrifice, while restoring harmony requires acknowledging the truth and correcting unfaithfulness.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Bitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  17. What does the story “The Pit and the Weasel” teach about keeping a promise?

    A young man and woman promised to marry, naming a pit and a weasel as witnesses, but the man forgot his promise and married someone else. After losing two children in incidents involving a pit and a weasel, he remembered the agreement and returned to the woman, who had remained faithful to him. The account is presented as a lesson about the connection between a true commitment and enduring faithfulness to it.

    рабби Натан бен ИехиэльHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 13 · open and download the PDF

  18. What lesson in faithfulness and hope does the account of Miriam and her parents teach?

    After Pharaoh ordered the killing of Jewish baby boys, Amram separated from Yocheved to prevent further births. Miriam objected that his decision prevented both boys and girls from being born; he listened, returned to his wife, and Moshe was born. The article uses this account to show how perseverance in the face of despair opens the way to future deliverance.

    Акива ТатцHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  19. Why does the article connect emunah with the feminine and redemption?

    Akiva Tatz compares emunah to a seed hidden in the ground that requires sustained care: faithfulness supports the process before its outcome is visible. Pregnancy and birth express the connection between prolonged waiting and eventual redemption. The author links the coming of redemption to women's faithfulness and their ability to endure lengthy trials.

    Акива ТатцMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  20. How can a person narrow the gap between knowing what is right and acting on it?

    Even clear understanding and deep knowledge do not by themselves guarantee corresponding actions. Ongoing work on middot, one's character traits, is necessary. A person must train themselves to follow truth rather than passions and emotions.

    Акива ТатцMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  21. Why can a momentary desire overcome something far more important to a person?

    According to the explanation attributed to Rabbi Dessler, an action is governed by whichever desire has taken the central position within a person at that moment. That desire gains control regardless of its strength, rationality, or importance. Even a weak, fleeting desire can therefore displace a far more important goal.

    рабби ДеслерMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  22. What was the Jewish people's test after the revelation at Sinai?

    The revelation at Sinai is described as clear knowledge that left no room for doubt. The test began later, as the impression of the revelation faded and the people had to remain faithful to the covenant. Initial clarity is therefore only the beginning; continued faithfulness requires spiritual work.

    Акива ТатцBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  23. Does emunah mean blind belief or faithfulness to truth?

    Akiva Tatz explains emunah as faithfulness and devotion to what is true, rather than blind belief without knowledge. A person first discovers truth and then remains faithful to it even when it is no longer apparent. As in human relationships, devotion is tested through lasting difficulties rather than declarations alone.

    Акива ТатцBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  24. What matters more in preparing for a bar mitzvah: the celebration or the child's Jewish education?

    The author places Jewish education and preparing the child to observe the commandments at the center. A lavish celebration cannot replace that task, and nonkosher food contradicts the occasion's meaning. He attributes such parental mistakes to lack of knowledge and sees the solution in giving children a deeper understanding of Judaism.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Family and educationRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  25. Why can placing excessive emphasis on a single commandment be dangerous even within traditional Judaism?

    The author argues that excessive emphasis on one commandment distorts the Torah as a whole. He compares the Jewish people to an airplane, where even a small malfunction can cause a tragedy, to explain why changes that are not urgently necessary require caution.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Mussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  26. What does the author see as evidence that faithfulness to Jewish tradition sustains Jewish life?

    The author proposes judging a religious path by its ability to sustain a living connection between generations. In his polemic with the Reform movement, he presents communities where parents, children, and grandchildren pray and share Shabbat meals together as evidence supporting the Orthodox approach.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Community and tzedakahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  27. How does the freedom described by the Torah differ from the freedom of the cult of Baal Peor?

    The article describes the freedom of Baal Peor as freeing a person's animal nature from the divine element within them. The freedom given by the God of Israel comes through strengthening the divine element and restraining the animal nature, allowing a person's spirituality to emerge.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Weekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  28. How is studying Torah connected with human freedom?

    Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi connects “charut,” meaning “engraved” on the tablets, with “cherut,” meaning “freedom.” He teaches that a person who studies Torah is free and that constant study leads to spiritual elevation. This freedom is grounded in standards and laws.

    раби Еошуа бен ЛевиMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  29. Why did Sovta's attempt to degrade Baal Peor become an act of worship?

    The cult of Baal Peor treated exposure and complete lack of restraint as a path to freedom. Sovta performed degrading acts before the idol, but its worshippers praised him precisely for doing so. The account illustrates the contrast with the Torah's approach, in which a person covers himself in the presence of holiness.

    рав Пинхас ГольдшмидтMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  30. What does Moshe's concern for the people teach a leader?

    When Moshe heard that it was better for the people that he not enter the Land of Israel, he accepted giving up his own aspiration. The quoted midrash describes his willingness to die so that not even one Jew's fingernail would be harmed. This illustrates a true leader's willingness to put the people's welfare above himself.

    РАВ БЕНЦИОН ЗИЛЬБЕРMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  31. How does the midrash about copper coins and a gold coin explain Moshe's burial in the wilderness?

    In the midrash, a man cannot persuade others to light a candle to search for lost copper coins, so he drops a gold coin beside them. A candle is lit for the gold, allowing him to collect the copper coins as well. Similarly, Moshe's burial in the wilderness is connected with his eventually bringing the generation that died there into the Land of Israel with him.

    РАВ БЕНЦИОН ЗИЛЬБЕРWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  32. Why did Moshe say he would not enter the Land of Israel “because of you” if his own mistake occurred at Mei Merivah?

    In the explanation attributed to Or HaChaim HaKadosh and Malbim, the initial decision was connected to the people's spiritual decline after the sin of the spies. A Temple built by Moshe could not have been destroyed, so punishment would have fallen on the people themselves rather than on the Temple's wood and stone. It was therefore better for the people to enter under another leader. At Mei Merivah, the decision could still have changed if Moshe had followed God's command precisely and the people had risen spiritually, but this did not happen and the decision became final.

    Ор а-Хаим а-Кадош и МальбимWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  33. Why is the Shabbat of Vaetchanan called Shabbat Nachamu?

    The name comes from the haftarah from the book of Yeshayahu read with this Torah portion. It begins with “Nachamu, nachamu,” meaning “Comfort, comfort My people.”

    РАВ БЕНЦИОН ЗИЛЬБЕРHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  34. Should a person demand that a prayer be answered on the strength of their merits?

    Even Moshe, despite his great merits, asked God for a gift and mercy rather than something owed to him. We should likewise ask for mercy without treating the fulfillment of our request as an earned payment.

    РАВ БЕНЦИОН ЗИЛЬБЕРPrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  35. Why did Moshe want so much to enter the Land of Israel?

    Rav Simlai explains that Moshe sought to enter the Land of Israel not to enjoy its fruit or prosperity. He wanted to fulfill the commandments connected with the Land that can be performed only there.

    рав СимлайWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  36. How can a person learn not to desire what belongs to someone else?

    Ibn Ezra illustrates this with an ordinary young man who sees a princess and royal clothing but does not regard them as available to him. One should view other people's possessions in the same way, as outside the scope of one's own claims. This attitude helps prevent the heart from seeking to possess what belongs to others.

    Ибн-ЭзраMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  37. What does the story of Ahav and Navot's vineyard teach?

    Ahav wanted Navot's vineyard, but Navot refused to part with his ancestral inheritance. To obtain the property for Ahav, Izevel arranged a false accusation and secured Navot's execution. The story shows how an intense desire for someone else's property can develop from coveting into robbery and even murder.

    РАВ ИЦХАК ЗИЛЬБЕРMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  38. What methods must not be used to persuade someone to sell their property?

    When asking an owner to part with something, all arguments must be truthful. One must not repeatedly renew requests and wear the person down. Nor may one send relatives or people the owner respects to pressure them.

    РАВ ИЦХАК ЗИЛЬБЕРHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  39. When does wanting to acquire someone else's property violate “Do not desire” and “Do not covet”?

    According to Rambam, “Do not desire” is violated when a person begins planning how to acquire what belongs to someone else. “Do not covet” is violated when persuasion and pressure lead to actually acquiring the desired property, even at a high price. If the acquisition does not take place, the second prohibition has not been violated. Neither prohibition is limited to the particular object mentioned beside it in the verse.

    РамбамHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 151 VAETHANAN 2019, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  40. If God loves us, why does He require us to observe so many commandments?

    Rabbi Asher Kushnir compares the Creator's love to parental love: concern for a child's future leads parents to set limits and require constructive actions. The Creator gave humanity the Torah as guidance toward the purpose of creation. Prohibitions protect against evil, positive commandments develop goodness, and observing the commandments refines a person and makes life more meaningful.

    рав Ашер КушнирBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  41. How can a bread toaster be kept pareve?

    If the appliance is used exclusively for pareve bread, its toast may be eaten with either meat or dairy. Care is needed during washing, storage, and use to keep it from becoming meat or dairy. After toasting bread with dairy or meat toppings, restoring its pareve status is very difficult and sometimes impossible because it usually cannot be fully dismantled and all its parts kashered.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  42. How should a sandwich press be used for meat and dairy?

    A sandwich press with two heated surfaces should be designated for one type of food. When necessary, food of the opposite type may be heated in a tightly sealed double wrapping, provided both the appliance surface and the wrapping are dry. After use for nonkosher food or unsealed meat and dairy foods, the appliance requires libun kashe, which is difficult to perform at home and may damage its coating.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  43. How are a standard microwave and its turntable kashered?

    If nonkosher food, or both meat and dairy, were prepared in a microwave without tightly sealed containers, it requires kashering. The article instructs washing it thoroughly, waiting 24 hours, and heating a glass of water inside until all the water evaporates. If nonkosher food touched or spilled onto the turntable, Sephardim may wash it thoroughly, while Ashkenazim require hagalah.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  44. May meat and dairy be reheated in the same standard microwave?

    Two opinions are presented for a microwave without conventional heating elements. One permits reheating and defrosting different types of food if they are tightly sealed and are not heated simultaneously. The other requires designating the microwave for meat or dairy, with food of the opposite type heated only occasionally when necessary, in a tightly sealed container.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  45. How do kashrut rules differ between a standard microwave and one with heating elements?

    A microwave with conventional heating elements follows the rules for an oven. To kasher it or change to food of the opposite type, clean it thoroughly, wait 24 hours, and run the heating elements, rather than the microwave function, at maximum temperature for a period of time. The article gives separate rules for a standard microwave without such elements.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  46. Does an oven's self-cleaning cycle allow alternating between meat and dairy?

    The article permits alternating between meat and dairy in a self-cleaning oven after running the cycle, which burns away residue and absorbed substances. Baking trays and skewers must still remain separate for meat and dairy. It also reports a view that does not rely on self-cleaning because substances absorbed into the rubber seals may not be adequately removed.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  47. How is an oven kashered after nonkosher food was cooked in it?

    Thoroughly clean an oven that is nonkosher or of unknown status, wait 24 hours, and heat it at maximum temperature for an hour. Baking trays used for nonkosher food require libun kashe, an intense form of heating. This is difficult to perform at home and may damage the trays' coating.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  48. May pareve food be cooked in a meat oven to be eaten with dairy afterward?

    The article prohibits preparing pareve food in a meat oven when it is intended to be eaten or mixed with dairy. The same rule is stated for pareve food prepared in a dairy oven for consumption with meat.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  49. Under what conditions may dairy be cooked in a meat oven, or kosher food in a nonkosher oven?

    A single-chamber oven should be designated for meat, dairy, or pareve. When necessary, food of another type may be cooked in it if the dish is tightly sealed with a double covering and the surface supporting it is completely dry. In a case of great need, the same conditions allow kosher food to be cooked in a nonkosher oven or one whose kosher status is unknown.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  50. What should be done if dairy food was accidentally cooked on a meat baking tray?

    If the tray had not been used for meat for at least 24 hours, the dairy food is permitted after the fact; clean the tray and heat it in the oven at maximum temperature for an hour. If less than 24 hours had passed since its use for meat, consult a rabbi about the food, tray, and oven. In either case, thoroughly clean the oven, wait 24 hours, and heat it at maximum temperature for half an hour.

    рав Лейб-Нахман ЗлотникHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 249 Vaethanan 2021, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

By weekly parsha