Parshat Korach — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
3,898 entries
Is a royal servant exempt from liability for carrying out a message on Shabbat if a different courier receives it?
Rabbi Yehuda includes royal servants who carry messages out to couriers on Shabbat among those liable to punishment. The discussion clarifies that liability remains even if the servant intended to give the message to one courier but another received it: incomplete fulfillment of that intention does not provide an exemption.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Does a woman’s liability for carrying out an object attached to her apron depend on whether it is in front or behind?
In the cited Mishnah, a woman who ties an object to her apron and carries it from a private domain into a public domain on Shabbat incurs punishment. It makes no difference whether the object is in front or behind.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How does intending to carry an object in front or behind one’s back affect liability on Shabbat?
The Mishnah states that someone who intended to carry an object in front but carried it behind the back is exempt from punishment, while the reverse incurs punishment. Rabbi Elazar explains the apparent contradiction by attributing the clauses to different authors: one emphasizes fulfillment of intent, the other the unusual method of carrying. Rav Ashi sees no contradiction: someone who intended to carry behind the back and did so fulfilled the intention. Someone who instead carried the object in front fulfilled the goal of keeping it intact more effectively.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Is carrying an object on the head considered an ordinary method of carrying out on Shabbat?
Most of the Sages regard carrying on the head as an unusual method that exempts a person from punishment. Others object that the residents of Hotzel regularly carried loads this way. The Talmud’s conclusion as presented is that a rare local custom does not make this method ordinary for most people, so the exemption from punishment remains.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Does carrying a load more than ten handbreadths above the ground on Shabbat exempt a person from punishment?
According to the cited statement of Rabbi Elazar, carrying a load from a private domain into a public domain more than ten handbreadths above the ground incurs punishment. The explanation is that this was how the sons of Kehat carried the sanctuary’s utensils in the wilderness.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How does the way an object is carried on Shabbat affect liability for carrying it out?
In the cited Mishnah, carrying an object from a private domain into a public domain in an ordinary way—in the hand, against the chest inside one’s clothing, or on the shoulders—incurs punishment. An unusual method, such as carrying it on the back of the hand, in the mouth, or behind the ear, exempts the person from punishment. The discussion specifically concerns liability for carrying out.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Should I assume that a quiet neighbor is unfriendly?
In the story, Chana mistakes Sarah’s quietness for pride and dislike of her family. When Chana’s son brings Sarah a challah for the eruv, Sarah welcomes him warmly and praises him. Chana recognizes her mistake, and the neighbors reconcile: quietness alone does not prove ill will.
Цюпа ГензельMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
When should I examine my actions?
The article cites the Alter Rebbe and Tanya in teaching that a person should examine their actions every day before going to sleep. This examination should be regular, even for someone in a prominent position.
Алтер РебеMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
Why can even a spiritually elevated person make a serious mistake?
Spiritual stature does not remove free choice or a person’s material nature. Fame, wealth, and respect can make temptation easier to yield to and make wrongdoing seem justified. Resisting wrongdoing therefore requires sustained, intensive work on oneself.
Лейб КаханэMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How should I respond when my wishes do not come true?
We do not always recognize that the right time and place for what we want have not yet arrived. The author advises accepting an unfulfilled wish with dignity, trusting that God does not allow what is unnecessary now to come about.
Юдит АккерманBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
What future awaits Korach’s soul?
The text says that in the future Korach’s soul will be able to reveal its greatness, purity, and beauty and rise to the level of Aharon the Kohen’s soul. It will then fulfill the purpose toward which it strove prematurely in Moshe’s time.
Юдит АккерманMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
What does the conflict between Korach and Moshe teach about self-realization and humility?
The article suggests that Korach sought a higher expression of his soul but could not accept either that his aspirations might be premature or that his assigned role already fulfilled his purpose. Even lofty motives can be distorted by a personal view of events. Moshe’s humility, expressed in wanting nothing for himself, is presented as enabling him to receive the Creator’s light without that distortion.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Weekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Why was the spiritual unity at the giving of the Torah short-lived?
The article presents the giving of the Torah as a brief opportunity to rise above a distorted perception of reality: the people received the Torah as if with one heart. Yet they did not sustain a stronger connection to the higher worlds than to the lower ones. The golden calf revealed the influence of the lower world despite the Jewish souls’ longing for spirituality.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»Weekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How is the separation of the upper and lower waters explained in relation to free choice?
The women’s column interprets the separation of the waters as the concealment of higher truth and a diminished manifestation of God’s light in our world. People receive this light only to the extent they can bear and accept it. This concealment leaves room for disagreement and negative tendencies, and with them, free choice.
Редакция «Любите делать добро»ChassidusRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What should a child do if they drop something in front of a bus?
The article advises against bending down to retrieve the object, since the child may disappear from the driver’s view. The child should tell the driver that something has fallen and needs to be picked up.
Елена ДемидоваFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How should a child wait for and board a bus safely?
The author advises waiting on the sidewalk at least two meters from the road, in a single-file queue. Children should approach to board after the driver opens the doors and gives permission. They should make sure a heavy schoolbag does not get caught while boarding and fasten any available seat belt before the bus moves.
Елена ДемидоваFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why is it important for a child to behave calmly during a journey?
Shouting, jumping, and running around distract the driver and endanger all passengers. Elena Demidova advises explaining the need for calm behavior in both cars and buses. Children should remain seated while a bus is moving.
Елена ДемидоваFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why are children advised to sit in the back and follow the rules even in someone else’s car?
The article recommends that children under 13 ride in the back because an airbag designed for an adult can injure a child when it deploys. Children should follow the rules in relatives’ or neighbors’ cars even if other passengers do not. If asked to sit in front, the author suggests politely declining and choosing a rear seat.
Елена ДемидоваFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
What seat-belt rules should a child learn?
Elena Demidova advises fastening the belt before the vehicle moves and keeping it fastened until the trip ends. All provided belt components should be used, the shoulder belt should not pass under the arm, and two children should never share one belt. The child seat or belt should suit the child’s age and be used correctly.
Елена ДемидоваFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why should we help people without endlessly analyzing our motives?
Timothy Wilson describes a study in which analyzing the motives behind a kind act led participants to judge their own kindness more negatively. He advises helping others without excessive scrutiny of the reasons for one’s concern. The article concludes that kindness improves life for both those receiving help and those giving it.
Тимоти УилсонMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can we work on character flaws when constant self-analysis does not help?
Timothy Wilson suggests that people dissatisfied with their traits should try to behave better despite their habitual negative tendencies. He links character development to practice: just, temperate, and courageous actions strengthen the corresponding qualities. Action is the principal means of change in this approach.
Тимоти УилсонMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Does discussing a traumatic event again necessarily help rescue workers recover?
The article reports the conclusion of Richard McNally’s team that debriefing rescue workers in a way that makes them relive an event can disrupt natural psychological recovery. The author contrasts this procedure with a person’s spontaneous effort to turn attention away from distressing thoughts. The discussion concerns this post-trauma debriefing procedure rather than every form of psychological support.
Ричард МакнеллиHealth and soulRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can self-analysis affect someone who is feeling depressed?
The article describes a study in which participants with mild depression focused more on negative aspects of their lives and felt worse after introspection. Participants who thought about unrelated subjects felt better. The author suggests that shifting attention helped disperse their negative mood.
Тимоти УилсонHealth and soulRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Does detailed self-analysis always help us understand our feelings for another person?
Timothy Wilson describes a study in which intuitive assessments of relationships predicted their continuation better than detailed analysis of the reasons for satisfaction. He concludes that excessive introspection can interfere with understanding one’s feelings. He regards the insights available through self-analysis as limited.
Тимоти УилсонHealth and soulRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can the world’s interconnectedness help us envision the completion of humanity’s spiritual work?
Eliyahu Essas treats cryptocurrency as an illustration of the world’s unity and interconnectedness. He uses this model to help contemplate the completion of the work of the Six Thousand Years. He describes the transition to the Seventh Millennium as a time when material aspects of life will give way to spirituality.
Элиягу ЭссасMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What can a person rely on when financial stability seems uncertain?
Discussing cryptocurrencies, Eliyahu Essas emphasizes that absolute stability exists neither for individuals nor for states. His spiritual conclusion is that God alone governs the world. He therefore urges people to continue their work calmly and confidently without treating material circumstances as permanent.
Элиягу ЭссасBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What should someone consider before conversion, and where should they turn once they have decided?
Michael Bergman identifies the central condition as a sincere, irrevocable wish to join the Jewish faith without seeking external benefits. Such a decision requires readiness to transform one’s outlook and way of life, even at the cost of comforts and relationships. Once a person is inwardly ready, he advises approaching a recognized Orthodox rabbinical court, under whose guidance conversion takes place.
Михаэль БергманHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew pray to God in their own words?
Michael Bergman writes that God accepts the prayers of both Jews and non-Jews. A person may address Him in their own heartfelt words.
Михаэль БергманPrayerRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Must someone convert to Judaism to lead a righteous spiritual life?
Michael Bergman explains that a non-Jew can lead a spiritual life, do good, believe in the One Creator, and observe the Seven Laws of Noah. For moral development, he suggests books on ethics issued by Jewish religious publishers. He advises someone considering conversion first to reflect on whether joining the Jewish people is truly necessary for them.
Михаэль БергманBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
May meat found to be non-kosher after shechita be sold to a non-Jew?
In the case described, the animal underwent shechita, but the subsequent inspection established that a Jew may not eat its meat. The author permits a Jew to sell it to a non-Jew because the animal underwent shechita. He stresses that the restriction concerns kashrut rather than the meat being unsanitary.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew eat meat without shechita, and may a Jew sell such meat to a non-Jew?
Eliyahu Essas notes that there is no unequivocal answer and gives his own understanding: such meat is not forbidden to a non-Jew, but he does not recommend eating it. Regarding a Jew’s sale of this meat to a non-Jew, he reports that the Torah teachers do not share a single position. He likewise does not recommend that sale.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
May one eat meat grown from animal cells?
Eliyahu Essas considers that, in his understanding, this product should not present a kashrut problem for non-Jews. He gives no definitive permission for Jews and advises waiting for authoritative rabbis to establish a clear position. The response does not address the product’s health effects.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Are plant-based meat substitutes permitted for Jews and non-Jews?
The response describes products of purely plant origin as permitted to both Jews and non-Jews without restrictions under the kashrut rules being discussed. The author expressly excludes any assessment of their health benefits or risks.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How can I connect with a religious community and give my life in Israel Jewish meaning?
Eliyahu Essas advises gradually getting to know the families of community leaders and participating in volunteer mutual aid. He connects the purpose of aliyah with realizing the Jewish soul’s potential through Jewish living, Torah study, and acts of kindness. One should pray for Heaven’s help along the way.
Элиягу ЭссасCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How does the author explain the refusal to recognize Reform and Conservative marriages and conversions?
Rabbi Noson Weiss contrasts his understanding of religious procedures as actual spiritual acts with the symbolic understanding he attributes to the Reform and Conservative movements. In his account, the validity of marriage and conversion depends on compliance with Torah law rather than the sincerity of a ceremony or public recognition. He therefore regards recognition contrary to those requirements as a departure from spiritual reality, even if refusing compromise makes the traditional position less popular.
раввин Носон ВайсOtherRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why, according to the article, do changes in human values not imply that Torah laws should change?
The author regards the Torah as a description of objective reality and its laws as instructions for acting within it. Human awareness and values may change, but in this explanation those changes do not alter the reality described by the Torah. Just as a scientific discovery changes our understanding of the world, Torah study can reveal new depths without creating new laws governing that reality.
раввин Носон ВайсBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How does the article explain the spiritual meaning of Jewish marriage and divorce?
The article presents a married couple as one person whose male and female halves complement each other. Marriage and divorce are therefore understood as actual spiritual changes rather than simply expressions of feelings or solemn ceremonies. The author describes divorce as the spiritual equivalent of separating Adam from Chavah.
раввин Носон ВайсFamily and educationRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why does the author view conversion as an actual change in a person rather than merely a ceremony?
Rabbi Noson Weiss explains that a convert is, in a certain sense, like a newborn and receives an additional Jewish soul. Conversion therefore marks the spiritual beginning of a new life as a child of Avraham and Sarah, rather than simply expressing an intention to join the community. The author concludes that this change requires following established instructions even when its spiritual mechanism is not understood.
раввин Носон ВайсOtherRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What sign of death does the article mention when explaining the connection between life and breathing?
The article associates the departure of life primarily with the cessation of breathing. It presents a statement described as Jewish law: a light feather remaining motionless near the nostrils is treated as a sign of death. This appears within its explanation of the connection between breath and life; the passage gives no other conditions for determining death.
раввин Носон ВайсHalachaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why did incense bring death to some and deliverance to others in the story of Korach?
Rabbi Noson Weiss explains that ketoret operates within spiritual reality rather than merely symbolizing reverence. The identity of the person performing the service is therefore decisive: in the article’s account, Aharon fulfills the mission assigned to him by God and stops the plague, while unauthorized claimants perish. The author connects the kohen gadol’s Yom Kippur service with the source of life and the inscription of the people of Israel in the Book of Life.
раввин Носон ВайсWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How did Rav Dov-Ber explain to his friend why his prayer took so long?
Rav Dov-Ber suggested that his friend imagine a trading journey instead of making the actual trip. His friend objected that he needed to transport real goods and bring home real money. The rav explained that his prayer likewise sought an actual result rather than an imagined journey, and therefore required time.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why did Moshe tell all the claimants to the high priesthood to offer incense?
In Rashi’s explanation quoted in the article, Moshe emphasizes that the Jews have one God, one Torah, and one kohen gadol. The incense offering was to reveal whom God had chosen. Moshe warned the claimants that the chosen person would survive, while the others would meet the fate of Nadav and Avihu.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What did Korach and his followers mean when they said that the entire community was holy?
Rashi explains their words as a reference to everyone having stood at Mount Sinai: God addressed them all, not only their leaders. Korach and his followers used this to support their objection to Moshe and Aharon’s special position.
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why did the distinguished lineage and learning of Korach’s followers not justify their claims?
The article emphasizes that Korach’s followers were distinguished, learned men whose equality with other Jews was not questioned. Yet entitlement to a particular sacred role does not follow from social standing or a high opinion of oneself. In Moshe’s response, the decisive factor is God’s choice rather than the merits cited by the claimants.
раввин Носон ВайсWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What should I do if people invite me to join wrongdoing and promise shared profits?
In the quoted passage from Mishlei, King Shlomo warns against accepting such invitations. Even promises of wealth and a shared purse should not lead someone to join people who plot evil. One should keep away from their path and their plans.
царь ШломоMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What does the story of Datan and Aviram teach about distorting facts for personal gain?
Eliezer Freidkin explains that the pursuit of comfort and power can lead a person to accuse a righteous person for personal advantage. Datan and Aviram even portrayed Egypt as a land flowing with milk and honey. Their descent into the earth conveys a lesson: demagoguery, scheming, and distortion of facts place a person in a spiritual pit even during life.
Элиэзер ФрейдкинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Love Doing Good — Любите делать добро№220 глава Корах, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How can faith support a parent during a child’s serious illness?
Rabbi Yigal Noy recounts how his son Yishai’s surgical complications and resuscitations shattered his sense of being in control and strengthened his reliance on God. In his son’s recovery, he sees the power of faith, prayers, and the commitments of people who prayed for the child and worked to overcome anger and sadness for his sake. Even when the prognosis is grave, faith reminds him that his Father in Heaven is present.
הרב יגאל נויBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: טועמיה — טועמיה — Shlach/Korach 5786, p. 31 · open and download the PDF
How did the parents in the story sustain themselves when their baby was in intensive care?
The parents recount that they allowed themselves to cry, but then tried not to sink into despair and recited prayers of gratitude. They understood the ordeal as coming from a loving Father and reminded themselves that it would have an end. Their approach was to make the necessary efforts while entrusting the course of events to God.
Редакция «אור השבת»Bitachon and emunahRead more
Source: טועמיה — טועמיה — Shlach/Korach 5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
How can an unexpected change of plans be understood as divine guidance?
In the story, Rabbi Mordechai Pogromansky and his companion, who was a mohel, became absorbed in Torah discussion and missed their station. At their unexpected destination, they met a Jew who had been praying to find a mohel for his son before Shabbat. Rabbi Mordechai understood this as divine guidance: what appeared to be a travel mistake had brought them to someone who needed their help.
רבי מרדכי פורגמנסקיBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: טועמיה — טועמיה — Shlach/Korach 5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
When is it better to examine my mistakes: during a crisis or afterward?
Rabbi Baruch Choresh advises postponing the examination of personal mistakes and the drawing of conclusions until the crisis has passed. He explains that self-examination in the midst of distress can intensify the crisis and damage a person’s self-image. He also reminds readers that everyone makes mistakes and that endlessly regretting what has already happened is unproductive.
ברוך חורשHealth and soulRead more
Source: טועמיה — טועמיה — Shlach/Korach 5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha