Parshat Ki Tisa — questions and answers
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
7,177 entries
Why do some postpone tenaim until immediately before the chuppah?
The text describes two customs: holding tenaim after the shidduch is finalized or immediately before the chuppah. The delay is explained through a statement attributed to the Vilna Gaon about the particular gravity of canceling a shidduch and tenaim, even compared with divorce, which the Torah permits and sometimes requires. Tenaim are therefore postponed until the wedding is imminent.
הגר"אFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 40 · open and download the PDF
Is mazal tov merely a congratulation or an actual blessing?
The text emphasizes that mazal tov is an actual blessing, not merely a customary expression. It conveys a blessing and prayer that events should unfold with good fortune.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 40 · open and download the PDF
How does the power of peace on Shabbat unite the delight of soul and body?
The Rebbe of Amshinov explains peace as a power that unites opposites. Ordinarily, strengthening the bodily dimension obstructs the spiritual, while strengthening the spiritual pushes aside the bodily. On Shabbat, the power of peace allows the delight of soul and body not only to coexist but to become a source of delight for each other.
אדמו"ר שליט"א מאמשינובChassidusRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 39 · open and download the PDF
What is wished for a couple with the words lechaim tovim uleshalom when a shidduch is finalized?
The author suggests understanding this as a blessing and prayer for a new shared life filled with goodness and peace. Goodness is linked to overcoming the solitude described as not good for a person. Peace expresses the spouses’ complementing one another and forming a whole together.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Shalom bayitRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 39 · open and download the PDF
What do the handshake and refreshments express after agreement to a shidduch?
The handshake expresses connection, the conclusion of the agreement, and commitment. Sharing refreshments creates closeness and strengthens the bond between the parties. Where they had avoided eating together beforehand, it particularly clearly signals that the shidduch has been agreed upon.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 40 · open and download the PDF
Why do some families avoid eating or drinking together before a shidduch is finalized?
The text describes a custom of not eating or drinking together at the prospective in-laws’ home or meeting place until an agreement is finalized. The author suggests that refreshments could create partiality and closeness while the decision is still open. Serving them only after agreement also makes them a clear sign that the arrangement has been concluded.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 38 · open and download the PDF
Why is calm, considered judgment so important in a shidduch?
The Rebbe of Amshinov explains shidduch in terms of calm, reflection, and considered judgment: the agreement itself calls for a settled decision. He suggests that this may also explain holding a vort and tenaim. A Jewish home is a small sanctuary, and its endurance requires reverence, modesty, and a sense of shame.
אדמו"ר שליט"א מאמשינובFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 38 · open and download the PDF
According to Maharal, how can husband and wife form a unity despite their differences?
Maharal explains that the union of husband and wife creates a divine completeness beyond an ordinary natural connection. Their differences are united through the divine power that joins them. This is indicated by the yud in ish and the heh in ishah, which together form the divine name י־ה.
המהר"לShalom bayitRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 37 · open and download the PDF
How does the Rebbe of Amshinov explain the rest a woman finds in her husband’s home?
The Rebbe of Amshinov connects this rest with returning to one’s spiritual source and root. Drawing on the Torah’s account of woman being taken from man, he explains that her inner essence finds rest when it is at its source.
אדמו"ר שליט"א מאמשינובChassidusRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 37 · open and download the PDF
What meanings of the word shidduch help explain what to seek in a spouse?
The text proposes three meanings for the Aramaic word shidduch: rest, blending, and connection. The author brings them together as a calm, modest bond that joins two different worlds. The practical lesson is to seek someone with whom one can bring those worlds together, build a strong connection, and find tranquility.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 38 · open and download the PDF
Why does the cited ketubah wording not immediately call the man the groom?
Maharam Mintz, citing Rav Saadia Gaon, describes wording in which the title “groom” appears only after the woman’s consent has been recorded. The explanation is that until that point the document has not yet stated that she agreed to become his wife.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 36 · open and download the PDF
Must a man explicitly state the purpose when giving kiddushin?
The text explains that the declaration at kiddushin expresses the intention and purpose of the item being given. It cites Rabbi Yosi’s view that if the man had been discussing their kiddushin with the woman and then gave her kiddushin, no separate explanation is needed. The author distinguishes this rule from the requirement for a prior shidduch: explicit words at kiddushin do not themselves replace that preliminary agreement.
ר' יוסי; Редакция «כתב מרדכי»HalachaRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 35 · open and download the PDF
How does a prior shidduch relate to the blessing before kiddushin?
Gilyonei HaShas, drawing on Radbaz, explains that a prior agreement allows the blessing to be recited before kiddushin without concern that the bride will refuse them. Without a shidduch, omitting the blessing leaves an obligation unfulfilled, reciting it afterward fails the requirement to bless beforehand, and reciting it beforehand raises concern about invoking God’s name in vain. This is presented as an additional reason not to perform kiddushin without a shidduch.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 35 · open and download the PDF
Why are kiddushin without a prior shidduch or in a marketplace criticized?
According to Rambam, kiddushin through intercourse, in a marketplace, or without a prior shidduch are valid but warrant disciplinary punishment to prevent immodest conduct from becoming habitual. The Tur cites the Rosh’s view that this punishment applies only to kiddushin through intercourse. The validity of kiddushin is thus distinct from the acceptability of the procedure, and the scope of punishment is disputed.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 34 · open and download the PDF
Does agreeing to a shidduch create the same status as kiddushin?
A shidduch expresses the couple’s agreement to marry and prepares for marriage, but does not itself create marital status. Mutual consent already forms the basis of the shidduch, while additional actions strengthen the connection and commitments. Calling the celebration a seudat erusin does not change this: in Torah terminology, erusin means kiddushin.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»HalachaRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 36 · open and download the PDF
Does someone violate the commandment to love one’s neighbor if divorce becomes necessary after every effort to restore peace?
According to the explanation given, someone who sincerely did everything possible to establish love and peace at home but ultimately had to divorce does not violate this commandment. The criticism discussed concerns someone who divorces without trying to build peace and love. Concern for fulfilling the commandment to love one’s neighbor should therefore begin even before kiddushin.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Shalom bayitRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 32 · open and download the PDF
By what age should a person begin pursuing a shidduch?
The text instructs a person to pursue a shidduch before age twenty, citing the Shulchan Aruch’s ruling against remaining unmarried beyond that age. If marriage has been delayed, the author says not to postpone it beyond twenty-two or, at the latest, twenty-four.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 32 · open and download the PDF
Why is a man advised to inquire about the bride’s brothers before marrying?
The text states that a man should inquire about the bride’s brothers before marrying. It cites the Talmud’s explanation that most sons resemble their mother’s brothers.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Family and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 32 · open and download the PDF
How does love for a wife differ from general goodwill toward others?
The explanation cited from Lereacha Kamocha, based on the Netziv, makes the required degree of love correspond to the closeness of the relationship. Toward a person outside the family, the mitzvah is expressed through appropriate help and goodwill. A wife is entitled to a distinct, deeper love from her husband, so an attitude sufficient toward a stranger is insufficient within marriage.
לרעך כמוךShalom bayitRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 31 · open and download the PDF
Why must a man see a woman before kiddushin?
The text cites the prohibition against performing kiddushin before the man has seen the woman. The concern is that he might later find something objectionable to him and come to dislike his wife. This is linked to the obligation to love one's fellow and to Rambam's warning about a loveless marriage or subsequent divorce.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 31 · open and download the PDF
What does the Shulchan Aruch say about habitual quarrels and accusations when considering a family for a match?
The quoted passage begins by presuming families eligible for marriage. It nevertheless identifies habitual conflict, extreme insolence, cruelty, and repeatedly attacking others' lineage as grounds for concern and distance. It emphasizes that continually disqualifying others may point to a defect in the accuser.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
Which qualities are most important to examine in a prospective spouse?
The author's main priorities are a good heart, kindness, faithfulness, and good character, in both the woman and the man. The cited sources recommend carefully examining conduct and taking time, especially where anger and quarrelsomeness are present. Rivkah's kindness is given as the example that made her fit to enter Avraham's household.
מרדכי גראזינגערFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
Why is one advised to seek a match from a Torah scholar's family?
The text recommends marrying a Torah scholar's daughter and marrying one's daughter to a Torah scholar. The cited sources explain this through the family's influence on children's upbringing and the conduct of home life. If such a match is unavailable, they list families of righteous people, synagogue leaders, charity administrators, and children's teachers.
מרדכי גראזינגערFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 29 · open and download the PDF
What should one pray for when seeking a match?
The author advises praying for a suitable match. He specifies a general prayer for one's true and good partner, connecting this with the Talmudic discussion of the power of prayer in matters of marriage.
מרדכי גראזינגערPrayerRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 29 · open and download the PDF
What Torah subjects should one study when preparing to find a spouse and build a family?
The author recommends regular study of Kiddushin, Ketubot, and other Torah sections concerning the establishment of a Jewish home. He conveys the Amshinover Rebbe's advice that studying the relevant Torah subjects helps bring their practical fulfillment and can assist in finding a match. Additional subjects include the value of marriage, the mitzvah of having children, and the laws of Even HaEzer.
אדמו"ר שליט"א מאמשינובFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 28 · open and download the PDF
How does the Chatam Sofer explain Yaakov's answer to Esav about his children?
The Chatam Sofer interprets Esav's question as casting doubt on whether Leah was intended for Yaakov. In this reading, Yaakov's answer about the children God granted him serves as evidence that she is his heavenly match. The explanation rests on the idea that having children together demonstrates that designation.
החתם סופרWeekly parshaRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 27 · open and download the PDF
According to Rambam, does a heavenly decree about a match cancel free choice?
In the quoted responsum, Rambam insists that free choice remains the foundation for understanding these statements. He does not treat the declaration of an intended spouse as an unchangeable decree applying to everyone. He explains it as particular recompense, whether reward or punishment, according to divine judgment.
הרמב"םBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 26 · open and download the PDF
What sign of an intended match does Ben Yehoyada give?
The quotation from Ben Yehoyada proposes a sign based on the relative strength of the spouses' attraction: in an intended match, according to this explanation, the wife is more strongly drawn to the husband. It uses this to interpret the distinction between “found” and “finds” as restoring an earlier bond of souls or obtaining a different partner. This is one interpretation within a collection of different explanations of matches.
הבן איש חיFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 26 · open and download the PDF
How does Shivilei Emunah explain a righteous person's difficult marriage?
Shivilei Emunah does not reduce every case to a simple rule that a spouse's character necessarily matches one's righteousness. It allows that a difficult marriage may be a trial, like other suffering experienced by the righteous. When a righteous woman marries a wicked man, the source offers several explanations, including the possibility of encouraging him to improve.
שבילי אמונהBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 25 · open and download the PDF
How does the Ketav Sofer understand a first and second union within one marriage?
The Ketav Sofer explains that the terms can refer to the same wife rather than two marriages. The first union is the joining for having children; the second is living together in unity, contentment, and support. This second aspect depends on the person's merits and deeds.
הכתב סופרShalom bayitRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 24 · open and download the PDF
How is the possibility of preceding someone else in a match through prayer explained?
The discussion presents several explanations. The Ritva and Ran explain that prayer can change the announced match, while the Sfat Emet applies the possibility of preceding another person even to a first union. The cited Zohar explanation concerns a soul returning in another incarnation without its partner and obtaining a different partner through prayer.
מרדכי גראזינגערPrayerRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 23 · open and download the PDF
If spouses are destined for each other, what role do a person's deeds play?
In the cited explanation from the Zohar, joining one's original partner depends on merit and upright conduct. Having an intended partner therefore does not mean that everyone will necessarily marry that person. The author compares this with the Talmudic distinction between a first and second union and notes differences in interpretation.
מרדכי גראזינגערBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Why does the wedding blessing say “Who creates the human being” in the present tense?
The author proposes an explanation based on the teaching about two halves of a soul. At the chuppah, the bride and groom reunite, and in this sense their creation reaches completion at that moment. The blessing's present tense can therefore refer to the union taking place now.
מרדכי גראזינגערFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
What does it mean to describe husband and wife as two halves of one soul?
Drawing on the Zohar, the author explains that the male and female aspects are joined in the world of souls. On entering this world, they separate and inhabit distinct bodies. When the intended spouses unite, their original unity is restored.
מרדכי גראזינגערFamily and educationRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Are there grounds for avoiding weddings in Marcheshvan?
The article mentions different approaches: some righteous leaders avoided weddings in this month, associating it with judgment and bitterness. It also cites the opposite view, that there is no need for concern because kindness sweetens the bitterness. The author additionally notes a positive reading of the month's name as expressing importance.
מרדכי גראזינגערHolidays and datesRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How does Marcheshvan continue the spiritual work of Tishrei?
The Maggid of Kozhnitz is cited as connecting the name Marcheshvan with an expression about lips continuing to move. It suggests that Tishrei's prayers continue almost on their own and that the repentance undertaken then extends into the following month.
המגיד מקאזניץChassidusRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Why does suitable timing matter for a good deed?
The author explains that an undertaking gains special strength when it matches the inner meaning of its time or what all Israel is engaged in then. He cites the Talmudic connection between wedding days and the blessings to be fruitful and multiply pronounced during Creation. In his explanation, those blessings left an enduring imprint on the days themselves.
מרדכי גראזינגערHolidays and datesRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why is it useful to write down what one studies in Torah?
The introduction cites the Maharsha as teaching that study leaves its principal lasting impression through writing. The author explains that this is why he wrote down what he studied while preparing for marriage.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What approach to disease prevention does the publication's author propose?
The author urges preventive care before treatment becomes necessary and overcoming laziness that interferes with it. In connection with coronavirus illness, he recommends vitamins D and C, zinc, and other supplements, referring to unnamed physicians. These recommendations are presented as the author's position; the text provides no substantiation of their effectiveness.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Health and soulRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can acting joyfully help a person feel joy?
The article attributes to the Chazon Ish the idea that acting joyfully helps a person become joyful. The author connects this with Sefer HaChinuch's principle that a person's actions shape the person.
החזון אישMussar and characterRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How does the article connect caring for health with joy?
The author urges attention to strengthening the body and one's emotional and spiritual resources, alongside external measures against illness. He attributes beneficial effects on the body and immune system to joy and smiling. These are medical claims made by the publication's author, rather than findings verified within the text.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Health and soulRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why did Rabbi Aharon of Karlin place such great importance on joy?
In the quoted saying, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin treats joy as neither a separate obligation nor sadness as a separate prohibition, while stressing their immense consequences. Joy leads toward observing Torah, whereas sadness can lead toward rejecting it. Elsewhere, the article cites Nimukei Orach Chaim as describing joy as a Torah obligation.
רבי אהרן מקארליןMussar and characterRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
According to Rabbi Nachman, how does joy affect the heart and mind?
Rabbi Nachman says that joy opens the heart and strengthens the power of the mind. The article cites this statement to explain the value of joy for a person's inner life.
רבי נחמן מברסלבMussar and characterRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
To what did the Arizal attribute his spiritual attainments?
The article reports that the Arizal attributed his attainments in divine wisdom and ruach hakodesh to his great joy in studying Torah and performing mitzvot. The joy of a mitzvah is presented here as a source of spiritual attainment.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How does Rambam assess joy in performing mitzvot?
Rambam calls joy in performing mitzvot and loving the God who commanded them a great form of service. He censures withholding oneself from this joy, citing the verse about serving God with joy and a glad heart.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What does Rabbi Nachman of Breslov advise for maintaining joy?
In the quoted passage from Likkutei Etzot, Rabbi Nachman urges making an effort to distance sadness and maintain joy. He recommends different ways of cheering oneself up, including humor and playful silliness. The passage also links joy with healing illnesses; this is a claim made by the cited source itself.
רבי נחמן מברסלבHealth and soulRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why did the sages not list specific ways to increase joy in Adar?
Nimukei Orach Chaim explains that a list might imply that joy should be increased only through the specified means. The wording is therefore general: each person should identify suitable ways to increase the joy of a mitzvah in their heart and activities.
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What did the Beit Yisrael advise a prosperous man who lacked joy?
A wealthy man with a family and ample means complained to the Beit Yisrael of Gur that he lacked joy. The Rebbe advised him to open his purse and support others. The story teaches that caring for others shifts attention away from constant concern with one's own needs and makes room for joy.
הבית ישראל מגורCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What connection does the Sfat Emet draw between shekels and the joy of Adar?
The article cites the Sfat Emet as explaining that the theme of shekels extends throughout Adar because giving awakens joy. Increasing joy is thus connected with giving to others.
השפת אמתCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why is joy mentioned before mishloach manot and gifts to the poor in the description of Purim?
The author explains that one's own joy helps one bring joy to others and give to them. He connects this with the wedding blessing, where expressions of joy are followed by love, brotherhood, peace, and friendship. The relationship also works in reverse: doing good for another person awakens joy in the giver.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Holidays and datesRead more
Source: כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha