Why are kiddushin without a prior shidduch or in a marketplace criticized?
According to Rambam, kiddushin through intercourse, in a marketplace, or without a prior shidduch are valid but warrant disciplinary punishment to prevent immodest conduct from becoming habitual. The Tur cites the Rosh’s view that this punishment applies only to kiddushin through intercourse. The validity of kiddushin is thus distinct from the acceptability of the procedure, and the scope of punishment is disputed.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל אדוני אבי הרא"ש כתב שאין הלכה כרב»
- Author
- הרמב"ם; הרא"ש
- Source
- כתב מרדכי — כתב מרדכי — Ki Sisa 5786, p. 34
- Parsha
- Ki Tisa