Does a mitzvah count if it is performed without intending to fulfill a commandment?
The article presents two views: one requires conscious intent to fulfill the mitzvah, while the other allows an act to count without that intent. The ruling follows the first view for Torah commandments, with a separately stated exception for commandments involving eating. If a person consciously intends not to fulfill the mitzvah through the act, it does not count even according to the view that does not require intent.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«3akOH COOTBeTCTByeT NepBOMY MHEHMIO (cornacHo koTopomy ANA Toro, uTo6b! sanoBenb 6bina ucnonHeHa, HEO6XOQMMO COsHaTeNbHOe HamepeHve)»
- Author
- Эзра Ховкин [?]
- Source
- Chevrutah24x7 — 36 RUS BEHAALOTCHA #5 Chevrutah24x7
- Parsha
- Behaalotecha