How does Ri Migash explain why false witnesses are not executed after the death sentence has been carried out?
As presented in the response, false witnesses receive the corresponding punishment after the verdict but before its execution; the Sadducees disputed this interpretation. Ri Migash explains that the plot to profane the place of divine justice deserves punishment, whereas an executed verdict indicates that the accused deserved that punishment according to the Heavenly Court. The response limits this explanation to the Temple period, when the people merited the Divine Presence, and does not present it as authority for contemporary courts to impose such punishments.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Если же приговор уже исполнили (предположим, казнили обвиняемого), лжесвидетелей не наказывают.»
- Author
- Ри Мигаш
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 154 shoftim 2019, p. 13
- Parsha
- Shoftim