Parshat Shemini — questions and answers — Page 3
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
12,207 entries
Why are the communal shelamim offerings on Shavuot connected to Mount Sinai?
The people first offered shelamim at Mount Sinai, and these offerings later accompanied the inauguration of the Mishkan, which continued the experience of that revelation. The annual communal shelamim on Shavuot recall Sinai and that inauguration. The author also connects their offering after seven weeks with the sequence of seven days of miluim followed by the eighth day.
menachemHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How is Yom Kippur connected to the inauguration of the Mishkan?
The pattern of Yom Kippur offerings resembles that of the eighth day, with separate chatat and olah offerings for the High Priest and the people. Yom Kippur is also associated with forgiveness for the sin of the golden calf. It can therefore be understood as an annual rededication of the Mishkan as a place of atonement.
menachemHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why were special offerings needed on the eighth day of the Mishkan’s inauguration?
After the sin of the golden calf, the Divine Presence withdrew from the camp, and the Mishkan was intended to make its return possible. The special offerings of the eighth day both atoned for that sin and recreated the experience of revelation at Mount Sinai. The appearance of the Divine Presence marked the culmination of the Mishkan’s inauguration.
menachemWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What was the purpose of the seven days of the Mishkan’s inauguration?
The seven days of miluim sanctified the Mishkan and its vessels, completing their preparation, while also inaugurating the altar’s service. Their offerings represented the main categories of future sacrifices: chatat, olah, and shelamim. This explains why the command appears among the laws of constructing the Mishkan, while the account of its fulfillment appears alongside the laws of sacrifices.
menachemWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why was the sanctification of the altar and kohanim repeated for seven days?
Menachem Leibtag connects the number seven with the seven days of Creation and the sanctification of the seventh day. This repetition reminds people of the Divine purpose of their creation. The seven days of sanctification emphasize that the altar is intended as a means for people to draw closer to God.
Menachem LeibtagWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why was anointing oil alone insufficient to sanctify the altar and the kohanim?
Menachem Leibtag explains sanctification as setting something aside for a Divine purpose. The Mishkan and its vessels represent God’s presence, while the altar and kohanim relate to humanity’s attempt to serve Him. They therefore required additional sanctification through offerings and blood, reminding people of the distance between the human and the Divine. Blood and the kohanim’s ears, hands, and feet symbolize humanity’s purpose and potential to serve God.
Menachem LeibtagWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Do the leniencies concerning chodosh apply to grain in Eretz Yisroel?
Jewish-owned chodosh grain in Eretz Yisroel is prohibited according to all the authorities cited, since the listed leniencies do not apply to it. Gentile-owned grain imported into Eretz Yisroel and baked there by Jews is discussed separately. In that case, Achiezer rules strictly, while Har Tzvi is lenient.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How long before Pesach must grain be planted to be considered yoshon?
The deciding factor is whether the grain took root before the cutoff, not merely whether it was planted. The cited authorities disagree about the time rooting takes: some require two weeks, so grain planted two weeks or less before Pesach may be chodosh. Others allow grain planted three days before Pesach to be considered yoshon.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
May someone who strictly observes chodosh use utensils in which chodosh was cooked?
According to the cited ruling of the Mishna Berurah, even someone who follows the strict approach to chodosh may use such utensils. The condition is that 24 hours must have elapsed since the chodosh was cooked in them.
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What supports the custom of being lenient about chodosh outside Eretz Yisroel?
The article gives three grounds: a double doubt about the crop year and rooting date, an opinion limiting the prohibition geographically, and an opinion exempting gentile-owned grain. Reliance on the double doubt is difficult when growing dates can be established. Other authorities reject these leniencies and regard the prohibition as biblical even outside Eretz Yisroel and for gentile-owned grain. The Mishna Berurah recognizes that those who are lenient rely on accepted authorities and that their custom need not be challenged, but recommends following the stricter approach.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What is the prohibition of chodosh, and which grains does it cover?
Chodosh is a new grain crop that took root after the cutoff associated with the Omer offering on 16 Nissan. Such grain is prohibited until the corresponding time the following Pesach; the article gives 16 Nissan for Eretz Yisroel and 17 Nissan outside it. The prohibition remains in force without the Omer offering and covers wheat, barley, oats, spelt, and rye. Corn, soybeans, peas, and rice are not included.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What exceptions to the prohibition on insects does the Torah mention?
The text states that the Torah prohibits all kinds of insects except four species of locusts. This account does not identify those four species or describe their distinguishing features.
Rabbi Yaakov Asher SinclairHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What signs of a kosher fish are given in the text?
A kosher fish must have fins and easily removable scales. The text presents these together as the identifying features of a kosher fish.
Rabbi Yaakov Asher SinclairHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What signs must a kosher land animal have?
A land animal must have completely split hooves and chew its cud. One sign is insufficient: if the other is absent, the animal remains nonkosher.
Rabbi Avraham PamHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why can Shabbat zemirot be understood as welcoming a guest?
The Sfas Emes explains that realizing the full holiness of the festivals requires pilgrimage to the Temple, whereas the holiness of Shabbat comes into every Jewish home. Shabbat zemirot can therefore be understood as songs welcoming a special guest. This guest visits us rather than requiring us to travel to him.
Sfas EmesHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why was David’s dancing before the Ark consistent with the dignity of a Jewish king?
David understood royal authority as a responsibility and saw himself as a servant of the Torah. Michal believed that dancing before the Ark diminished his dignity, but Rabbi Hirsch explains that this conduct expressed authentic Jewish kingship. David’s loyalty earned him the reward that the Temple built by his son would bear his name.
Rabbi S.R. HirschHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What do the two signs of a kosher animal teach about relationships with people and with God?
The split hoof symbolizes a person’s outward conduct toward others, while chewing the cud represents the inner relationship with God. Just as an animal needs both signs, a person cannot be sound in only one of these areas. Proper treatment of others does not replace service of God, and service of God does not replace proper treatment of others.
Rabbi Avraham PamMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is a person of greater spiritual stature held to a stricter standard?
The greater a person’s spiritual stature, the more exactingly his actions are judged: something that is not a transgression for one person may be unacceptable for another. This is illustrated by Rav Naftali of Ropshchitz telling the Seer of Lublin that he was going to retrieve the sins the Seer had discarded at Tashlich. His point was that the shortcomings of someone on a higher level might look like merits to someone on a lower level.
Rav Naftali m'RopshchitzMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why did Aharon’s involvement with the Golden Calf not prevent him from becoming High Priest?
In Yalkut Yehudah’s explanation, based on the Midrash, Aharon preferred to bear the blame himself rather than leave it with the people. His willingness to sacrifice his own righteousness and share in the World to Come for others became the reason for his appointment as High Priest. Moshe therefore encouraged him to approach the altar: a leader must place the community’s welfare before his own.
Yalkut YehudahCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Why was atonement for the sale of Yosef needed at the dedication of the Mishkan?
According to Yalkut Yehudah, the sale of Yosef was rooted in the brothers’ jealousy of his special position. At the dedication of the Mishkan, the kohanim and Leviim received distinctive duties and benefits, which could again provoke jealousy. Atonement reminded the people that individuals have different roles and strengths, and accepting this division is necessary for the Divine Presence to dwell among them.
Yalkut YehudahMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Why did Nadav and Avihu’s good intentions not justify their “strange fire”?
The different explanations of their sin share one idea: they acted with good intentions but without the necessary guidance, consultation, and consent. Their own initiative was therefore called a “strange fire.” The Dubno Magid’s parable about an officer who violated an order to benefit the king and caused a greater loss illustrates why good aims do not justify disregarding established instructions.
Rabbi Mordechai KamenetzkyWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How can studying Gemara with a chavrusa benefit an older person’s mental activity?
Amanda Bradley presents Gemara study as a combination of mental effort and social interaction that, according to the article, may help delay cognitive decline. She identifies four components: sustained concentration, learning Aramaic, retaining and comparing conflicting arguments, and discussion with a study partner. Chavrusa study requires listening to another person’s explanations, expressing one’s own clearly, and responding quickly to challenges. The author therefore recommends beginning or resuming Gemara study with a partner.
Amanda BradleyHealth and soulRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What prevented Nevuchadnetzar from expressing his awe at the miracle in unsurpassed songs of praise?
The article cites the Sages’ teaching that the rescue of Chananya, Mishael and Azaryah filled Nevuchadnetzar with such awe at Hashem’s power that his songs could have surpassed David’s Psalms. An angel, interpreted here as the force of human desire, intervened and distracted him. The episode illustrates how personal desire can disrupt an elevated moment before it finds expression in words of lasting value.
Meshech ChochmahMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why is the kiddush Hashem of Chananya, Mishael and Azaryah considered greater than that of Nadav and Avihu?
The deaths of Nadav and Avihu restored fear of punishment, whereas the rescue of Chananya, Mishael and Azaryah from the furnace inspired the higher reverence for Hashem’s greatness. Nadav and Avihu retained personal enjoyment in a spiritual experience they were meant to convey to the people with complete selflessness. Chananya, Mishael and Azaryah consciously risked their lives to strengthen the community’s faith, although they could have avoided the confrontation beforehand. Their complete dedication to the people was reflected in sanctifying Hashem’s name and returning to the community alive.
Meshech ChochmahMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why was the entire nation meant to mourn Aharon’s sons?
In this explanation, Aharon understood that his sons’ deaths would teach the entire nation a necessary lesson about the seriousness of Divine judgment. The need for that lesson arose from the collective sin of the golden calf and the subsequent mistaken impression that forgiveness came easily. The tragedy therefore carried national responsibility as well as personal grief, and this understanding helped Aharon bear it in silence.
Meshech ChochmahWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How did the deaths of Nadav and Avihu sanctify Hashem’s name?
According to Meshech Chochmah, the restoration of closeness to Hashem after the golden calf could have suggested that disobeying Him had no serious consequences. The punishment of Nadav and Avihu on the day of the Mishkan’s inauguration demonstrated that Divine compassion does not eliminate justice or the demands of the commandments. The sanctification of His name lay in correcting this dangerous misconception among the people.
Meshech ChochmahWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why is concern about forgetting Torah considered beneficial?
Torah is presented as a gift beyond the ordinary human level, so even an upright person has reason to be concerned about retaining it. This concern has a clear practical response: consistent study and review. Dissatisfaction with one’s achievements is beneficial when it prevents stagnation and encourages further spiritual growth while preserving joy and resolve.
Rabbi Chanan MorrisonMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How does the article explain the connection between fear and sin?
In the spiritual explanation offered, fear is connected with a conflict between a person’s soul and the surrounding world. Unethical conduct and conflict estrange a person from society, while abandoning reason leaves one subject to imagination and its fears. Ethical living and a healthy connection with society are presented as foundations of inner stability.
Rabbi Chanan MorrisonHealth and soulRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How does bitachon help a person remain calm in the face of hardship?
In the author’s presentation, bitachon rests on recognizing that all events are Divinely ordained and that even apparent evil is not ultimately beyond redemption. This trust allows a person to acknowledge difficulties without being overwhelmed by fear and bitterness. Accepting life’s changes and being content with one’s portion help a person face challenges calmly.
Rabbi Chanan MorrisonBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Which twelve heavenly fires does Rabbeinu Bechaye list?
Rabbeinu Bechaye distinguishes six fires that expressed acceptance of offerings and six fires of punishment. The first group includes the inauguration of the Mishkan, the offerings of Gideon, Manoach and King David, the dedication of Shlomo’s Temple, and Elijah’s offering in his confrontation with the false prophets. The second group killed Nadav and Avihu, those who complained against Moshe, Korach and his followers, Job’s sheep and servants, and two captains of fifty with their men at Elijah’s word.
Rabbeinu BechayeWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What unspoken complaint does the Midrash find behind Aharon's silence after his sons died?
In the explanation presented, Aharon could have asked why his joy at the Mishkan's inauguration was shattered when the Torah safeguards the happiness of a celebration's central participants. The comparison draws on the Talmud's explanation of circumcision on the eighth day, allowing the parents to rejoice with their guests, and on the postponement of Nadav and Avihu's punishment to preserve the joy of receiving the Torah. Aharon nevertheless left this complaint unspoken and, according to the article, was rewarded for accepting God's just ways without protest.
Rabbi Ozer AlportWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How should one decide whether to marry before an older sibling when there are so many opinions?
Rabbi Yair Hoffman concludes that the wide range of opinions makes guidance from a posek or halachic teacher essential. A decision must take account of its moral dimension as well as formal permission. The aim is to act in a way that does not hurt people.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanFamily and educationRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What exceptions may allow a younger sibling to marry before an older one?
The article lists leniencies when siblings live in different countries, or according to some opinions even in separate homes; Rav Moshe Shternbuch permits proceeding with the older sibling's agreement, provided it does not cause that sibling pain. The Maharsham permits it when a daughter has reached 22 or the younger sibling has already begun dating, and treats an older sibling's refusal to marry or illness that obstructs finding a spouse as pressing circumstances allowing leniency. Further grounds cited are an older sibling not following the Torah's path and the Beis Yechezkel's permission when the children pay entirely for the wedding themselves. Some authorities permit proceeding when there is an additional need beyond the ordinary desire to marry. The article stresses consulting a beis din or, according to other opinions, a recognized halachic authority before applying these permissions.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Must a younger brother wait for an older sister, or a younger sister for an older brother, to marry?
The article reports disagreement in both cases. For a younger brother with an older sister, the Bach appears to prohibit proceeding, the Maharsham is lenient, and the Chelkas Yaakov reports a stringent custom. For a younger sister with an older brother, Igros Sofrim cites the Chasam Sofer's stringent position, while the Chazon Ish and the Steipler Gaon were lenient.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Is it forbidden to date someone whose older sibling is still unmarried?
The article distinguishes between the younger sibling and the prospective spouse. Any applicable restriction falls on the younger sibling. An outside suitor is permitted to date that person for marriage.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
According to Rav Moshe Feinstein, may a younger brother marry if the older brother has no prospective spouse?
Rav Moshe Feinstein holds that the older brother takes precedence only when both brothers have prospective spouses. If only the younger brother has someone to marry, he may marry first lechatchilah. Regarding two sisters, Rav Feinstein treats waiting as a custom; the article notes that most Acharonim understand the issue differently.
Rav Moshe FeinsteinHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What sources support the practice of older siblings marrying first?
The Rashbam connects this order with Lavan's statement that the younger daughter is not married before the older in his locality. Another possible source is the daughters of Tzlafchad, according to the interpretation that they married in age order. The article also cites Rabbeinu Tam's understanding that an unspecified reference to one of two daughters means the elder, based on the same verse.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Is waiting for an older sibling to marry a halachic obligation or a matter of proper conduct?
The article presents differing approaches. The Chasam Sofer regards waiting as derech eretz, or proper ethical conduct, rather than an actual halachic obligation. The author reads the TaZ as indicating that the rule has halachic status.
Rabbi Yair HoffmanHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How can eating become part of spiritual life?
In the author's account, Judaism seeks to elevate the physical world. Kashrut allows enjoyment of food with awareness and sensitivity, bringing holiness to that pleasure. Even an ordinary instinctive need can thereby acquire meaning.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherOtherRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How can a sense of personal dignity help prevent wrongdoing?
The author suggests that prohibitions on repulsive foods may help cultivate self-respect. A sense of dignity makes wrongdoing seem beneath a person, theft degrading, and gossip petty. He presents this explanation of the dietary restrictions as a possibility.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How does kashrut strengthen connections between Jews from different countries?
Shared dietary rules create a recognizable foundation even across very different regional cuisines. Kosher shops, bakeries, and butchers also become places where Jews meet. The author sees these laws as supporting unity, communal belonging, and resistance to assimilation.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What moral symbolism does the author see in the choice of kosher animals?
The author connects permitted species with qualities a person would want to absorb. He describes ruminants with split hooves as generally tranquil animals without natural weapons. He explains the exclusion of scavengers and predators as a rejection of the traits they symbolize.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is giving to the poor described as justice rather than simply kindness?
The author explains tzedaka in terms of justice: giving to the poor is not treated as optional generosity beyond one's duty. He uses this to explain the requirement to set aside portions of the harvest for those without land. The farmer must act justly before enjoying the produce of his field.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What does keeping meat and milk separate remind us of?
Becher presents this separation as a reminder of where food comes from. Meat comes from a dead animal, whereas milk comes from a living one. Keeping them separate helps preserve awareness that our food is connected to animal life.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why does hunting for entertainment conflict with the lesson of kashrut?
The author explains that permission to use animals for food and clothing does not mean that killing them should become entertainment. Some laws of kashrut aim to prevent cruelty and callousness. In his account, the requirements of shechita and freedom from treif injuries virtually rule out hunting as a way to obtain meat.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How can keeping kashrut develop a child's self-control?
Rabbi Mordechai Becher describes how his five-year-old son calmly gave up a desired chocolate bar after learning that it was not kosher. For the author, this illustrates how habitual observance of kashrut teaches acceptance of limits without a tantrum. A person practices the ability to forgo immediate pleasure.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherFamily and educationRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
May produce in Israel be eaten before tithes are separated?
According to the rule presented in the article, tithes must be separated from crops in Israel. Until this is done, the wheat, barley, or fruit may not be eaten.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What is forbidden with mixtures of meat and milk?
The article states that mixtures of meat and milk may not be cooked, eaten, or used for benefit. It separately states that dairy products may not be cooked or eaten together with poultry.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Is belonging to a kosher species enough to make meat permissible?
No: the animal or bird must undergo shechita according to Jewish law and be free of injuries and conditions that render it treif. Blood must be removed by soaking, salting, and rinsing, or by broiling. Certain fats called chelev may not be eaten, and the sciatic nerve and surrounding fat must be removed.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May products derived from non-kosher animals be eaten?
The article states that food products derived from a non-kosher animal are also non-kosher. Bee honey is identified as an exception. Dairy products, including the rennet in cheese, must come only from kosher animals.
Rabbi Mordechai BecherHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini76, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha