Parshat Shemini — questions and answers — Page 2
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
12,207 entries
Why should a kohen draw inspiration from service rather than alcohol?
The article explains that abstaining from alcohol during Temple service and legal adjudication is about more than clear thinking. The kohen embodies Divine service, so his inspiration should come from Torah and serving God. Knowing that every mitzvah, word of Torah, and word of kindness builds an eternal existence is presented as the source of Jewish happiness.
Rebbe Bunim m’PshiskeChassidusRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What does the overview say about permitted birds and insects?
The overview states that birds outside the Torah's listed forbidden families are permitted. All types of insects are forbidden except four species of locusts. This passage does not explain how to identify those species.
Rabbi Yaakov Asher SinclairHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What signs identify a kosher animal or fish?
The overview lists two required signs of a kosher animal: split hooves and chewing the cud. Having only one of these signs is insufficient. A kosher fish has fins and easily removable scales.
Rabbi Yaakov Asher SinclairHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What does the “eighth day” symbolize as a test in life?
Rabbi Berel Wein sees the “eighth day” as the moment when celebration gives way to ordinary difficulties and tragedy. This is when a person's resilience and faith are truly tested. Aharon exemplifies inner strength: after his sons die, he silently accepts what has happened and does not withdraw from life and service.
Rabbi Berel WeinBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What spiritual lesson can be learned from the prohibition of chametz left after Pesach?
In the text, chametz symbolizes the evil inclination and immoral desires. Self-improvement should therefore continue after Pesach, addressing the faults that remain. The image of low-profile matzah teaches humility and the need to strengthen the discipline acquired during the festival.
Редакция «Parsha.net»Mussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why did selling chametz become widespread?
Rabbi Berel Wein describes the sale of chametz as an ancient practice that became widespread in the late Middle Ages. Increasing numbers of Jews produced and distributed liquor made from chametz grain and fermenting agents. The substantial financial difficulties associated with these stocks encouraged the use of a legal sale to a non-Jew before Pesach.
Rabbi Berel WeinHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why may chametz owned by a Jew during Pesach not be used afterward?
The Sages prohibited benefiting from chametz that remained in Jewish ownership during Pesach. The author explains that the decree discourages keeping chametz for later use and reduces the danger of consuming it during Pesach itself. A valid sale to a non-Jew before the holiday, followed by reacquisition afterward, avoids this prohibition.
Rabbi Berel WeinHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why is the connection between prayer and sacrifice treated as more than a metaphor?
In the presentation of Rav Soloveitchik’s explanation, the Gemara requires prayer to be repeated in a particular case under the principle that the sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination. This shows that concepts governing the acceptance of sacrifices have actual consequences for the validity of prayer. The excerpt does not specify the conditions of that case.
Rav SoloveitchikPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How does the request in Retzei differ from the request in Shema Koleinu?
Rav Soloveitchik explains that in Shema Koleinu we ask God to accept our prayers. Retzei adds the request that He accept them specifically as a sacrifice. The term ritzui concerns the acceptance of an offering, so this is more than a repetition of the preceding request.
Rav SoloveitchikPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why must kohanim begin moving toward the place of blessing before Retzei ends?
Retzei asks that prayer be accepted as a sacrifice and is called avodah, or sacrificial service. In the article’s explanation, this connection between prayer and a communal offering enables the fulfillment of the priestly blessing. The Sages therefore required kohanim to begin moving toward the place of blessing by the end of Retzei.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Is the priestly blessing still a Torah commandment after Temple sacrifices have ceased?
Rav Yaakov Emden held that the obligation today is rabbinic because its Torah fulfillment is tied to communal sacrifices. The Mishna Brura disagrees and maintains that it remains a Torah commandment. Rav Yaakov Karliner and Rav Yitzchok Bruchin explain that the chazzan’s repetition is biblically equivalent to a communal offering, preserving the required connection between the priestly blessing and sacrifice.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why does the Gemara omit mortality from its list of similarities between humans and animals?
The article gives two answers. Rif explains that the Gemara describes humanity at its original creation, before Adam’s sin brought death into the world. Iyun Yaakov explains that the causes of death differ: a person dies as a result of sins, whereas an animal dies according to the order established for its existence.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachOtherRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
According to the Sages, how is a human being like an angel and like an animal?
In the teaching quoted, people resemble angels in possessing intelligence, walking upright, and speaking the holy language of Hebrew. They resemble animals in eating and drinking, reproducing, and expelling bodily waste. The description thus combines spiritual capacities with bodily needs.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachOtherRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What do the words “ishei Yisrael” mean in prayer when there is no Temple?
The article gives three explanations: the souls of the righteous offered on the heavenly altar, future sacrifices after the Temple service is restored, or prayers offered in place of sacrifices. The Mishna Berura cites the Taz’s preference for the first approach and the Vilna Gaon’s preference for the second. The words therefore have different meanings according to the interpretation followed.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What does the angel Michael offer on the heavenly altar?
The article presents the teaching that the heaven called Zevul contains a heavenly Jerusalem and Temple, where Michael offers a daily sacrifice. Tosafot cite two differing midrashim about its nature. One identifies the offerings as the souls of the righteous; the other describes fire in animal form.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachOtherRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What reward is associated with studying Torah at night?
Rabbi Shimon ben Lakish teaches that God grants special grace during the day to someone who studies Torah at night. In the alternative reading quoted, the teaching concerns Torah study in this world and special grace in the World to Come.
Rabbi Shimon ben LakishMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why does the cited beraita about missed prayers omit Mincha?
Missing Mincha also belongs to the category of lost opportunity being discussed. Its omission reflects the beraita’s structure: it places morning and evening prayers alongside the morning and evening recitations of Shema.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What does “that which is crooked cannot be straightened” teach about missed mitzvot?
The article applies this expression to opportunities for a mitzvah whose time has fully passed, such as a Festival offering after the Festival has ended. Maharsha explains that it also includes missing Shema or the relevant prayers throughout the entire day and night. A separate loss is that of someone who prayed but missed the opportunity to join a minyan.
Rabbi Mendel WeinbachPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why does the Zohar compare leading Torah scholars to fish that need no shechita?
Rabbi Asher Meir explains that these scholars live in Torah as fish live in water. Their vitality already comes from holiness, so they need no separate act of cutting themselves off from material sources of life. Even their everyday activities express this connection to Torah.
Rabbi Asher MeirMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How do the laws of shechita serve as a metaphor for spiritual freedom from materiality?
Rabbi Asher Meir compares ways an animal is separated from life with how a person relates to their animal nature. He describes complete absorption in material existence as blocking connection to holiness, while incidental distance from crude materialism allows an ethical contribution to the world. Deliberately drawing one’s vitality from holiness rather than materiality corresponds in this metaphor to kosher shechita.
Rabbi Asher MeirMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Is belonging to a kosher species enough to make an animal’s meat permissible?
The article explains that meat’s permissibility depends both on the species and on how the animal is killed. For Jews, meat from a permitted species requires proper shechita; an animal’s natural death does not make its meat permissible. Permitted fish, by contrast, require no shechita: their collection is treated as the equivalent of slaughtering livestock.
Rabbi Asher MeirHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
What lesson about responsibility is drawn from the deaths of Nadav and Avihu?
The article presents their deaths as a lesson that greater holiness brings greater responsibility and more severe punishment. It cites Rashi’s explanation that Moshe expected the greatest people to be taken at the Mishkan’s dedication and thought this meant himself or Aharon. The deaths of Nadav and Avihu revealed their exceptional greatness to him.
Rabbi Nachman KahanaWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why does Rabbi Nachman Kahana urge religious Jews to move to Israel?
The author views the State of Israel as a harbinger of the end of exile and as God’s call to return home. In his view, building flourishing religious life in the diaspora without responding to that call conveys a contradictory spiritual message. He describes living in the Land of Israel as an opportunity to participate in Jewish history and the fulfillment of the promises to the ancestors.
Rabbi Nachman KahanaMoshiach and geulahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why are consistent spiritual messages so important in education?
Rabbi Nachman Kahana connects Yonatan’s spiritual inconsistency with conflicting influences: Torah study and the absorption of foreign beliefs. He derives an educational principle from this: children, students, and communities need clear, consistent messages about what Torah requires. In his interpretation, mixed messages produce ideological discord, which he relates to the differences among the Haggadah’s four sons.
Rabbi Nachman KahanaFamily and educationRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Is it better to take unfamiliar work than to live on charity?
In the account quoted, Yonatan mistakenly understood Moshe’s teaching as permission to serve idols for a livelihood. David explained that it referred to work unfamiliar to a person’s usual profession. If one cannot earn a living in one’s own field, one should take other work rather than choose to live on charity.
David HamelechMoney and workRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How can someone accompany a survivor of catastrophe when words are inadequate?
The author describes his father, a Buchenwald survivor, walking in silence with Rabbi Yisrael Alter, who had also lost almost his entire family. The rabbi asked a few brief questions, and his final question about God’s presence remained unanswered. In the article, the encounter illustrates sharing grief and religious mystery through presence and silence without offering an explanation of the tragedy.
Benjamin LauHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Does Aharon’s silence after his sons’ deaths mean that he found consolation?
The article presents an interpretation in which Moshe’s words consoled Aharon. The author offers a different reading: Aharon’s silence expresses a refusal to turn the tragedy into an intelligible human explanation. He leaves the event in the realm of mystery without assigning it a meaning people can grasp.
Benjamin LauWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why did Nadav and Avihu bring their own fire at the dedication of the Mishkan?
In the author’s interpretation, they wanted to protect their father Aharon’s dignity. Moshe’s participation in blessing the people seemed to them to show that Aharon’s service still depended on the prophet. They therefore tried to send fire upward from earth, but were struck by heavenly fire.
Benjamin LauWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How should we understand Kohelet’s statement that there is nothing new under the sun?
The text explains that God has already placed in the world the resources, conditions, and possibilities for human discoveries and inventions. People discover what creation already contains. Heaven, by contrast, is described as a realm in which genuine newness exists.
Редакция «Parsha.net»Bitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How does the Vilna Gaon distinguish between simchah and gilah?
Simchah denotes joy over something new that has recently occurred. Gilah is joy over something that happened earlier but continues to bring happiness. The joy of a righteous person’s father illustrates gilah because the son’s righteousness is enduring.
Gaon, zl, m’VilnaPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why is it not enough to acknowledge the truth only privately?
The Minchas Elazar explains that earning others’ trust requires willingness to acknowledge an error publicly, even when doing so is painful. Private honesty is insufficient if a person continues outwardly to defend a mistaken position. Openly conceding the truth helps his words be heard and accepted.
Minchas ElazarMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How is Beit Hillel’s tolerance connected to the law following their opinion?
The Maharal explains that patience and composure support clear thinking and objective judgment. Irritation and anger can cause even a highly capable person to err. Beit Hillel displayed this composure, presented Beit Shammai’s view before their own, and were capable of revising their rulings.
Maharal M’PragueMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why is it helpful to speak calmly during a disagreement?
Loud assertions and shouting make it harder to admit an error because retreating from a forcefully defended position feels humiliating. A calm, respectful discussion leaves room to reconsider. Restraint therefore helps a person yield to the truth.
Rabbi A. Leib ScheinbaumMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How should a Torah teacher respond when a student convincingly challenges his explanation?
A teacher should acknowledge an error even when the objection comes from someone much younger. Rav Isser Zalman Meltzer once accepted a student’s challenge and ended his prepared lecture because he had no answer. Yielding to the truth demonstrates strength of character and helps earn trust.
Rabbi A. Leib ScheinbaumFamily and educationRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Why was Aharon correct not to eat the Rosh Chodesh offering on the day his sons died?
The exceptional command to eat offerings while in the state of an onen applied to offerings specific to the Mishkan’s inauguration. Aharon held that it did not extend to the Rosh Chodesh offering, which was ordained for all generations. Moshe initially disagreed but then acknowledged that Aharon’s ruling was correct.
Rabbi A. Leib ScheinbaumWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How can a desire to serve God lead to errors, as it did with Nadav and Avihu?
Rav Reuven Elbaz explains the “alien fire” as religious fervor that exceeded the established boundaries of service. Nadav and Avihu’s other errors were expressions of this excess rather than malicious intent. Their harsh approach to the people is contrasted with leadership grounded in love, patience, sensitivity, and humility.
Horav Reuven ElbazMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How could Moshe recognize his greatness and still remain humble?
The Avnei Nezer distinguishes between the humility of someone who considers himself insignificant and that of someone who recognizes his abilities but feels small before God. Moshe’s humility was of the second kind: closeness to God heightened his awareness of the infinite distance between them. Aharon, by contrast, keenly felt his own shortcomings and continually remembered his role in the Golden Calf.
Avnei NezerMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What inner meaning does the article find in the prohibition of alcohol for a kohen during service?
The article explains the prohibition as more than a requirement for clear thinking and physical coordination. The kohen embodies Divine service, so his inspiration should come from Torah and the service itself. He should not seek alcohol as the source of that elevation.
Rebbe Bunim m’PshiskeChassidusRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What did the Ba’al Shem Tov identify as a source of profound Jewish joy?
The Ba’al Shem Tov taught that awareness of one’s eternal existence could bring a Jew extraordinary joy. The article explains that every mitzvah and every word of Torah and kindness builds that eternal existence. This awareness gives everyday actions profound meaning.
Ba’al Shem TovChassidusRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What does the “eighth day” teach us about everyday life?
Rabbi Berel Wein understands the “eighth day” as the moment when festive excitement gives way to everyday reality and its difficulties. A person’s real test begins when the initial enthusiasm no longer sustains him. Aharon’s example demonstrates resilience, acceptance of God’s will, and continued engagement in life and service even after a devastating loss.
Rabbi Berel WeinBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What spiritual lesson can be learned from the prohibition of chametz retained over Pesach?
In the article, chametz symbolizes the evil inclination and immoral desires. The work of self-improvement begun on Pesach must continue afterward by removing lingering negative tendencies and strengthening the discipline acquired during the holiday. Matzah represents humility in a world of self-promotion and inflated pride.
Rabbi Berel WeinMussar and characterRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
Why may one not use chametz after Pesach if it belonged to a Jew during the holiday?
The Sages prohibited benefiting from such chametz to prevent Jews from retaining it over Pesach for later use. The article connects this both to the risk of eating the retained chametz during the holiday and to the prohibition against possessing it. Selling it to a non-Jew before Pesach and reacquiring it afterward avoids this problem.
Rabbi Berel WeinHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How does the request in Retzei differ from the request in Shema Koleinu?
In Shema Koleinu we ask God to accept our prayers. In Retzei we additionally ask Him to accept them as a sacrifice. Rav Soloveitchik emphasizes that the connection between prayer and sacrifice has serious halachic significance and is not merely a metaphor.
Rav SoloveitchikPrayerRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
When must the kohanim begin moving toward the place where they bless the people?
The kohanim must at least begin moving toward the place of the blessing before the conclusion of Retzei. This blessing asks that prayers be accepted as sacrifices, establishing the connection that enables the priestly blessing after communal prayer. The poem Vese’erav makes that same theme explicit.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Why is the priestly blessing recited today when there are no Temple sacrifices?
Rav Yaakov Emden held that today this mitzvah is only rabbinic, whereas the Mishnah Berurah insisted that it remains a Torah obligation. Rav Yaakov Karliner and Rav Yitzchok Bruchin explain that the cantor’s public repetition of the prayer counts as a communal offering on a biblical level. The priestly blessing at its conclusion therefore retains the required connection to communal sacrifices.
Rabbi Hershel SchachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini67, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
How does the Chasam Sofer connect the midpoint of the Torah with the serpent and Torah study?
In the explanation presented, the vav in “gachon,” referring to the serpent, marks the Torah’s midpoint by letters, while “darosh dorash” marks its midpoint by words. Without the sin of Adam and Chava, the serpent would have provided for people serving God and shared in their Torah, like Zevulun and Yissachar. After creation’s order was disrupted, the serpent became an enemy, and reasoned Torah study became necessary to separate evil from holiness. “Darosh dorash” expresses this role of inquiry and analysis.
Chasam SoferWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why did Aharon’s ability to look at Moshe’s face not yet prove complete forgiveness for the golden calf?
The Meshech Chochma explains that after the sin, people could not even look at the radiance of Moshe’s face, although previously they had witnessed God’s glory. When Aharon entered the Ohel Moed with Moshe and could look at his unveiled face, this could appear to indicate forgiveness. Yet the absence of the Divine Presence showed that the effects of the sin had only weakened and the sin had not yet been fully expunged.
Meshech ChochmaWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why did the eighth-day shelamim offering include a bull rather than a calf?
The author explains that the shelamim expressed the ceremony’s aspect of Divine revelation, making a reminder of the golden calf inappropriate for this offering. The bull corresponded to the shelamim offered at Mount Sinai. He tentatively suggests that the accompanying ram recalled the binding of Yitzchak as a foundation of the covenant with God.
menachemWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why did Aharon bring a calf as a chatat while the people brought a goat, if both were atoning for the golden calf?
The author explains that the High Priest’s usual bull for a chatat was replaced by a calf to express the connection with the golden calf; a calf is a young bull. For the communal chatat, he identifies the goat as the prescribed offering, so the connection with the sin does not change the animal used. In the people’s olah, however, a calf replaced the bull, likewise recalling the sin.
menachemWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What lesson does the author draw from the actions of Nadav and Avihu?
Nadav and Avihu’s good intentions did not justify offering fire that God had not commanded. The author compares their action with Aharon’s conduct in the sin of the golden calf and with the warning against crossing the boundaries at Mount Sinai. The subsequent presentation of the laws of ritual purity addresses who may enter the Mishkan.
menachemWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Shmini56, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha