Parshat Devarim — questions and answers — Page 6
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
8,192 entries
Why does Devarim mention Moshe’s exclusion from the Land of Israel alongside the spies’ sin if his punishment was for Mei Meriva?
According to Ramban, Moshe compares separate incidents: the people’s impatience contributed to sin both in the episode of the spies and at Mei Meriva, but in the latter case Moshe himself was punished. Kli Yakar and Or Hachaim see a closer connection: at the rock, Moshe could have restored the people’s faith damaged by the spies’ sin, but missed that opportunity. In this explanation, a Temple built by Moshe would have been indestructible, so any later sin by the people would have required a harsher punishment because the Temple could not be destroyed instead. Thus, the earlier sin of the spies affected the form of Moshe’s punishment.
рав Овадья КлимовскийWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Who proposed sending the spies: the people or God?
The people demanded that spies be sent, and God allowed Moshe to grant their request. Rashi explains “send for yourself” as permission dependent on Moshe’s choice. Sforno adds that Moshe was to select the men himself: those he chose were initially upright, and even their later negative report acknowledged the merits of the Land of Israel, helping the people repent.
рав Овадья КлимовскийWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
Why are Jews called Yehudim if they do not all descend from the tribe of Yehuda?
The name Yehudim refers to the kingdom of Yehuda, rather than solely to the tribe bearing that name. According to the text, most of the remaining Jews descend from inhabitants of that kingdom, primarily from the tribes of Yehuda and Binyamin. They retained this name after dispersing throughout the world following the destruction of the Second Temple.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»History and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
What practical lesson should we take from mourning the Temple's destruction?
The text recalls that the Temple was destroyed because of baseless hatred. This sin should be repaired by showing as much love, friendship, and brotherhood toward others as possible.
рав Ицхак ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Which restrictions continue on the tenth of Av?
During the first half of the tenth of Av, the custom is not to bathe, cut hair, shave, or wash laundry. Ashkenazim avoid meat and wine until midday, while Sephardim do so all day; Shehecheyanu is also still not recited. When the tenth falls on Friday, laundry may be washed immediately after the fast in honor of Shabbat, and haircuts, shaving, and bathing are permitted from Friday morning.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
What should be done after the Tisha B'Av fast ends?
Hands should be washed after the fast ends. The blessing of the moon is recited after the evening service, preferably after changing shoes and eating a little.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Is smoking permitted on Tisha B'Av?
The article prohibits smoking on Tisha B'Av. It gives a concession for someone who finds abstaining very difficult: smoking after midday in a secluded place.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
When may housework and food preparation be done on Tisha B'Av?
The custom is to refrain from work, including household chores, at least until midday. Food is likewise not prepared before midday. When preparing food afterward, one should avoid using hot water.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
May one greet people or offer congratulations on Tisha B'Av?
According to the article, greetings containing the word shalom are not used on Tisha B'Av. It permits saying mazal tov and ordinary Russian greetings and farewells such as zdravstvuyte and do svidaniya.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
How is Minchah conducted on Tisha B'Av?
After midday the parochet is restored, and tefillin and a tallit gadol are worn for Minchah; the tallit blessing should also cover the tallit katan that received no blessing in the morning. The Song of the Day and Pitum Haketoret are recited, followed by Ashrei and the Ki Tisa Torah reading; Ashkenazim also read Yeshayahu 55:6–56:8 as the haftarah. The Amidah includes Nachem and the applicable Anenu, and Sim Shalom replaces Shalom Rav; Avinu Malkenu and Tachanun are omitted. When Minchah is close to sunset, kohanim bless the congregation, but a kohen who did not fast does not participate.
рав Ицхак ЗильберPrayerRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How is a brit milah held when it falls on Tisha B'Av?
The circumcision is performed after Kinot. The grape juice over which the blessings were recited is given to a boy approximately six to nine years old who understands blessings but is not yet mature enough to mourn the Temple's destruction consciously. The celebratory meal is held after the fast ends.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
May someone observing shivah attend synagogue on Tisha B'Av?
In the morning, the mourner may attend to hear Eichah and recite Kinot with the congregation, and may receive an aliyah. If three days of shivah have elapsed, attendance on the evening of Tisha B'Av is also permitted.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
May someone who is not fasting on Tisha B'Av for health reasons receive an aliyah?
The article states that someone who is not fasting for health reasons is not called to the Torah. This restriction applies even though the person is permitted not to fast.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How does Shacharit on Tisha B'Av differ from the usual service?
Shacharit is conducted without tefillin or a tallit gadol; the prayer leader must be fasting and adds Anenu between Goel Yisrael and Refaenu in the Amidah repetition, while the priestly blessing is omitted. The Torah reading is Devarim 4:25–40, followed by Yirmeyahu 8:13–9:23 chanted to the Eichah melody and then Kinot. Ashrei and Uva Letzion without Va'ani Zot Beriti follow, then Kaddish and Aleinu, and Eichah is read without a blessing. The Song of the Day, Pitum Haketoret, and Tachanun are omitted in the morning.
рав Ицхак ЗильберPrayerRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
When are Nachem and Anenu recited on Tisha B'Av, and what if Nachem was omitted?
According to the article, Ashkenazim recite both additions at Minchah, while Sephardim recite them in all three services. Nachem is added in the blessing for Jerusalem; if omitted, it is said in the blessing for restoring the Temple service without its special ending, or later in the prayer asking that one's lips be guarded from evil. If Nachem is omitted entirely, the Amidah is not repeated. At Minchah, someone fasting recites Anenu in Shomea Tefillah, including a person who has fasted until Minchah but knows that eating or drinking will be necessary afterward.
рав Ицхак ЗильберPrayerRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
May deodorant, perfume, and cosmetics be used on Tisha B'Av?
The text permits deodorant. Perfume, creams, and cosmetics are prohibited, and one should also refrain from enjoying fragrant scents.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How should one wash and perform handwashing on Tisha B'Av?
Washing is forbidden on Tisha B'Av; morning handwashing and washing after using the toilet are limited to the fingers. A kohen giving the priestly blessing at Minchah, and someone eating bread, wash their entire hands. Someone who must eat for health reasons is advised, where possible, to choose food that does not require handwashing.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What restrictions apply to spouses on Tisha B'Av?
Marital relations and intimate kissing or embracing are forbidden on Tisha B'Av, and spouses do not spend the night in one bed or in adjoining beds. The article states that these restrictions also apply when Tisha B'Av falls on Shabbat, even though the fast is postponed. It specifies an exception when a woman's scheduled immersion falls on that night: she immerses on time, and marital relations are permitted.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Is there a custom to change one's usual sleeping arrangements on Tisha B'Av?
Some people reduce the comfort of sleep by changing their usual routine. Sleeping without a pillow is given as an example.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How is the evening service conducted on Tisha B'Av?
Before Maariv, the parochet is removed and some synagogue lights are extinguished. After the Amidah and Kaddish, Eichah is read; when the scroll is properly written on parchment, the custom is to recite a blessing, and everyone says the final sentence together. The congregation then reads four lamentations from Kinot, followed by Ve'atah Kadosh, Kaddish, and Aleinu, concluding the service with Barechu.
рав Ицхак ЗильберPrayerRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Until when must one sit on a low seat on Tisha B'Av?
From sunset at the end of the eighth of Av until midday on Tisha B'Av, one may not sit more than thirty centimeters above floor level. According to Kabbalah, something should be placed beneath a person before sitting on the ground or floor. Ordinary seating is permitted from midday.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
When does the Tisha B'Av fast begin and end, and what footwear is permitted?
The fast lasts from sunset until the appearance of stars at the end of Tisha B'Av. Leather footwear is prohibited throughout this period; the text lists rubber or fabric footwear as alternatives.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
If my health requires only drinking, may I also eat on Tisha B'Av?
Permission is limited to what is needed: if only drinking is necessary, eating remains forbidden, and vice versa. A person must fast while there is no need to eat or drink. If a sick person recovers sufficiently that fasting can no longer harm him, he must begin fasting.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Who is exempt from fasting on Tisha B'Av, and how should they eat?
The text exempts sick, physically weakened, and elderly people, women within thirty days after childbirth, and children—those for whom fasting is contraindicated. An exempt person who wishes to fast must consult a rabbi, because the exemption generally means that fasting is forbidden. Food and drink may be taken in ordinary portions without a requirement to use small measured quantities, but the food should be simple. Children should likewise not be given sweets.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How is the final meal before Tisha B'Av conducted?
The final meal contains no more than one cooked or fried dish; ingredients normally cooked together count as one dish, and a cooked food counts even if it can be eaten raw. One sits no higher than thirty centimeters above the floor, avoids fish, and preferably avoids pickles, seasonings, alcohol, delicacies, and dessert; a common custom is bread and an egg dipped in ash, with water. Before eating, one says, “This is the meal of Tisha B'Av,” and finishes some time before sunset. The meal is required even for those not fasting, and children begin participating two or three years before bar or bat mitzvah. If an unrestricted ordinary meal is eaten before Minchah, enough time should separate the meals to become hungry again.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
What Torah texts may be studied on Tisha B'Av and after midday on its eve?
Ordinary Torah study is prohibited on Tisha B'Av and, by custom, after midday on its eve, because it brings joy. Permitted texts include Iyov, sorrowful passages in Yirmeyahu, Eichah with commentaries and Midrash Eichah, the chapter Elu Megalchin in Moed Katan, mourning laws, and the Temple destruction accounts in Gittin from folio 55 onward. Books of Jewish ethics and moral instruction are also permitted.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
May interest on a working partner's loan be paid from the partnership fund?
This concerns a loan in the working partner's name when the other partner has no personal liability to either him or the bank. Some authorities allow interest to be treated as a business expense when profits result from increased capital, provided it is paid before profits are divided. There is no consensus when there are no profits, so the arrangement should be discussed with a rabbi in advance.
рав Шауль ВагшалMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why can a loan taken out by a passive partner create a problem of prohibited interest?
When a passive partner invests borrowed capital, part of the money is effectively lent to the working partner, who assumes responsibility for it. Paying bank interest from the common fund can appear to be the working partner paying part of the investor's interest. A rabbi should be consulted before taking the loan to arrange the transaction properly.
рав Шауль ВагшалMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How should business partners arrange a joint loan from a non-Jewish bank?
Partners may jointly borrow from a non-Jewish bank and pay interest from their common fund. If each is personally liable for the entire loan, they must agree that when the bank collects interest from one partner, the other is not obligated to reimburse it from personal resources, but only from the partnership fund.
рав Шауль ВагшалMoney and workRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can I offer correction in a way that helps someone improve?
The article distinguishes between reproaching someone for specific offenses and discussing proper conduct without humiliating details. Shame caused by direct reproach can lead to repeating the sin, while a calm discussion can be heard. A conversation is appropriate to prevent an impending sin; past wrongdoing should be discussed very gently, without excessive lecturing.
рав Реувен ПятигорскийMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How long did Moshe deliver the teachings recorded in Devarim?
The article calculates that the address lasted thirty-six days, beginning on the first of Shevat and ending with Moshe's death on the seventh of Adar. It finds an allusion to this number in the book's opening word, eleh, whose letters have a total numerical value of 36.
рав Реувен ПятигорскийWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Why did Moshe postpone his stern rebuke of the people until the end of his life?
Moshe followed Yaakov's example of addressing his sons critically before his death. Rebuking at that time avoids recurring shame when meeting the person who delivered the rebuke, resentment toward him, and refusal to hear him out. Another explanation is that the teacher will no longer undermine his own rebuke through subsequent sins.
рав Реувен ПятигорскийMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What connects Parashat Devarim with Tisha B'Av?
At the beginning of the portion, Moshe recalls the spies whose report led the people to refuse to enter the Land. According to the explanation given, this happened on Tisha B'Av: their unwarranted weeping foreshadowed future calamities on that date. These included the destruction of the First and Second Temples.
рав Реувен ПятигорскийWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How did Moshe strengthen the people before they entered the Land of Israel?
Moshe recalled the victories over Sichon and Og as evidence of God's help. Addressing Yehoshua, he urged the people not to fear other kingdoms, because God fights for them.
рав Реувен ПятигорскийBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
How did Rav Yosef Mashash protect his community against hostile accusations?
When Jews were blamed for the closure of a Muslim school and a pogrom threatened, Rav Mashash gathered representatives of both religions and addressed them, improving relations. On another occasion, he convinced the king of his Jewish subjects' loyalty, and the king prohibited arrests of Jews on charges of insulting Islam. These accounts show how carefully prepared speech and direct appeals to influential people helped protect the community.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»History and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Does Kol Nidrei release a person from obligations to other people and the state?
Rav Yosef Mashash explained that Kol Nidrei releases a person only from obligations to Heaven. It does not release obligations to other people or the state.
рав Йосеф МашашHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
What lesson about persecuting a sage is conveyed by the story of Rav Yaakov Dobrashvili?
In the story, Rav Yaakov Dobrashvili, who was subjected to torture, expresses confidence that God will hold his tormentor accountable, although he does not consider himself worthy of a miracle. After a tragedy in the interrogator's family, the other interrogators connect it with the rav's words and release him. The story is presented as a warning against cruelty toward a sage and as an example of faith in divine justice amid suffering.
Исраэль СпекторHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
How should judges and Torah sages be treated?
The passage cited from Me'am Lo'ez requires speaking respectfully to judges, exercising patience and avoiding humiliation. It particularly warns against insulting or shaming sages, associating such behavior with severe spiritual and material consequences.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why is it dangerous to care too much about how others see you?
The Rebbe of Kotsk explains that the spies gave excessive importance to other people's opinions instead of fulfilling their mission. Focusing so much on external approval deprives a person of inner stability and leaves them vulnerable to harmful influences. A person should direct attention toward the purpose for which they were sent into the world.
ребе из КоцкаMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How can a person preserve self-worth when others belittle them?
Rav Aryeh Katsin teaches that self-worth should not depend on other people's degrading words. Even when insulted, a person should remember being created in the Creator's image and possessing a soul capable of doing good and improving the world. Faith in God and in oneself becomes the beginning of spiritual growth.
рав Арье КацинHealth and soulRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How does low self-esteem affect what we think others think of us?
Rav Moshe Shaineman explains the spies' words as follows: someone who sees himself as a “grasshopper” assumes that others see him the same way. That assumption may be mistaken, since others may regard him much more highly. A personal sense of insignificance therefore does not establish that others disrespect him.
рав Моше ШайнеманHealth and soulRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Is admitting a mistake a sign of weakness or inner strength?
Rav Aryeh Katsin connects the ability to admit a mistake with a sense of self-worth. Someone afraid of exposing their inadequacy may stubbornly deny a mistake or depend excessively on others' opinions. The article uses Adam and Shaul as examples of the danger of rejecting responsibility and shifting blame to others.
рав Арье КацинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Should a parent admit mistakes to their children?
Rav Avraham Twerski told a father who feared losing his children's respect that admitting mistakes must be taught by example. If a parent wants children to acknowledge their mistakes, the parent must demonstrate that behavior.
рав Авраам ТверскийFamily and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
How do the three grave sins that led to the First Temple's destruction differ?
According to Maharal of Prague, each of these three grave sins belongs to a different sphere. Idolatry violates faithfulness to God, bloodshed deprives another person of life's supreme value, and sexual immorality causes a profound spiritual decline in the person committing it.
Маараль из ПрагиMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why is the destruction of the First Temple attributed both to three grave sins and to abandoning Torah?
Rav Bentsion Zilber explains that there is no contradiction: the destruction resulted from idolatry, sexual immorality and bloodshed. Proper Torah study, however, could have corrected the people and brought them out of that condition. Abandoning Torah deprived them of a spiritual remedy, so strengthening its study is presented as a way to help the entire people.
рав Бенцион ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why does a judge need self-control and courage?
Rambam requires judges to control their impulses and be ready to protect a victim from a robber. Moshe provides the example: as a fugitive in a foreign land, he stood up for Yitro's daughters and helped them water their sheep.
РамбамMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What additional qualifications does Rambam require of Sanhedrin members?
Sanhedrin members must be wise and discerning Torah scholars, with knowledge of other sciences and subjects relevant to the cases they judge. They must know most languages so they can hear witnesses without an interpreter, have a respectable appearance and have no physical defects. Rambam excludes the very old and the childless because of insufficient compassion; the Great Sanhedrin should include kohanim, Levites and Jews of good lineage, but may consist of other Jews if kohanim and Levites are unavailable.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Were monetary cases and capital cases handled in the same way?
These categories belonged to different courts and differed in ten procedural details. The article explains that Moshe transmitted these rules orally and that they were later recorded in the fourth chapter of tractate Sanhedrin.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
Why would a case be referred to a higher Jewish court?
In the system described, a lower court referred a question upward when it could not resolve it or was uncertain about its halachic basis. This was not an appeal against an existing ruling, which was considered final. In the wilderness, Moshe was the highest authority and turned to God when in doubt.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
May a judge withdraw from a case out of fear of retaliation?
The text permits a judge to withdraw out of fear of one of the litigants only before hearing both sides. If the judge has already reached a decision, the verdict must be announced without fear of any person.
рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha