Why does Devarim mention Moshe’s exclusion from the Land of Israel alongside the spies’ sin if his punishment was for Mei Meriva?
According to Ramban, Moshe compares separate incidents: the people’s impatience contributed to sin both in the episode of the spies and at Mei Meriva, but in the latter case Moshe himself was punished. Kli Yakar and Or Hachaim see a closer connection: at the rock, Moshe could have restored the people’s faith damaged by the spies’ sin, but missed that opportunity. In this explanation, a Temple built by Moshe would have been indestructible, so any later sin by the people would have required a harsher punishment because the Temple could not be destroyed instead. Thus, the earlier sin of the spies affected the form of Moshe’s punishment.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Так объясняет, например, Рамбан.»
- Author
- рав Овадья Климовский
- Source
- Fond Nasledia — offline 39 dvarim 2017, p. 17
- Parsha
- Devarim