Skip to main content
.

Parshat Devarim — questions and answers — Page 4

Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.

8,171 entries

  1. Why did Moshe remind the people of their past mistakes before his death?

    Moshe reminded the Jews of their experiences and God's lessons in the wilderness so that they would not repeat their past mistakes. He explained how they should live in the Land of Israel, taught laws, and warned of the trials that would follow if they departed from God's path.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Weekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 248 Dvarim 2021, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  2. Why does prayer at the Western Wall have special significance regardless of who built it?

    Rabbi Natan Agres emphasizes that, regardless of the debate over its builder, the wall is one of the Temple’s surviving remnants. It stands closer than the other walls to the site of the Holy of Holies, which he gives as the reason for the special power of prayer there. It is a place where Jews bring their most heartfelt requests before the Creator.

    рав Натан АгресPrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  3. How can rebuilding the Western Wall be reconciled with the midrash that it will never be destroyed?

    Rabbi Natan Agres explains that restoring the wall, even from its foundations or in another location, can be regarded as a continuation of the previous wall rather than its destruction. He compares this with Herod’s rebuilding of the Temple itself from the foundations. That rebuilding is not described as the destruction of the Second Temple.

    рав Натан АгресHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  4. Can we say with certainty that Herod built today’s Western Wall?

    The response identifies Professor Mazar’s position as the most widely accepted among archaeologists: Herod also expanded the Mount westward, so the present western wall is not in its original location. The author considers this approach the most likely, while stressing that it rests on indirect evidence. He also cites other views proposing an earlier construction date or the western wall’s remaining in its former position, allowing for older lower courses.

    рав Натан АгресHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  5. Do the Temple Mount’s dimensions contradict the tradition that David built its wall?

    The Temple building’s dimensions cannot be directly compared with those of the wall surrounding the Temple Mount, since these are different structures. The Mishnah’s measurement of 500 by 500 cubits refers to the Mount’s sanctified area, while the mountain itself was larger. Thus, the proposition that David built this area’s wall or laid its foundations does not contradict tractate Middot.

    рав Натан АгресHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  6. Do the midrashim about the indestructible Western Wall refer specifically to today’s Western Wall?

    This is difficult to establish conclusively: the literal phrase “the Western Wall of the Temple” points to the Temple building, whereas today’s Western Wall supports the Temple Mount. Many commentators apply the midrashim to the Mount’s wall, while some understand the account in Eichah Rabbah as referring to Jerusalem’s city walls. Rabbi Menashe Klein allows that different midrashim may refer to different walls, including remains of the Temple’s own wall that have not yet been discovered.

    рав Натан АгресHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  7. What is the source of the tradition that King David built the Western Wall?

    Rabbi Natan Agres identifies the earliest reference known to him in the commentary Beit Chadash, with the tradition also appearing in later books. Maharam Chagiz specifies that David built only the wall’s foundation; ancient midrashim also attribute the foundations of the entire Temple to David. However, the author found no sources from the Mishnah or Talmud periods explicitly attributing the Western Wall’s construction to David, and considers the tradition’s origin unclear.

    рав Натан АгресHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 17 · open and download the PDF

  8. Must I interrupt my Amidah if the cantor has already begun the repetition?

    If the cantor begins the repetition before you have finished your own Amidah, you do not need to interrupt it. You may calmly finish your prayer without rushing.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  9. Why is there no separate explicit request in the Amidah to rebuild the Temple?

    Following the prophets, the authors of the prayer did not separate the rebuilding of the Temple from the rebuilding of Jerusalem. The request to restore the city therefore includes the Temple. The festival Musaf expresses this connection by referring to Jerusalem as God’s holy Temple.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»PrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  10. How is the request for Redemption expressed in the Amidah?

    Much of the Amidah is devoted to asking for a speedy Redemption. The Sages see its blessings as a sequence of stages: the Land of Israel yielding its produce, the return of the exiles, restored justice, the disappearance of evildoers, the elevation of the righteous, the rebuilding of Jerusalem, the reign of David’s descendant, prayer, and the renewal of Temple service. Thanksgiving follows.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»PrayerRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 16 · open and download the PDF

  11. When may a safety pin be used on Shabbat?

    If the pin pierces the fabric in only one place, there is no prohibition; when it pierces twice, the text cites both permissive and stringent opinions. Someone wishing to rely on the permissive view has grounds to do so, but may not use two or more piercings to replace a permanent seam or repair a tear that would be sewn on a weekday. The permissive view allows temporary fastening like a button, such as at a neckline, as well as attaching ornaments and fastening baby diapers. In these permitted cases, the number of piercings does not matter.

    Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 15 · open and download the PDF

  12. May one tighten a thread at a collar or cuff on Shabbat?

    If a thread is intended to be tightened and loosened regularly, tightening it is not considered sewing under Torah law. For it to be permitted by the Sages, the openings through which it passes must be sufficiently wide; otherwise, the action is prohibited because it resembles sewing. The author clarifies that this restriction concerns thread, not a cord.

    Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  13. May one tighten a loose seam or button thread on Shabbat?

    One may not tighten a loose thread to bring separated parts of a garment back together, even if the separation is slight. This is considered performing the labor of sewing. The same prohibition applies to tightening the thread of a loosened hem or a dangling button.

    Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  14. Does gluing paper or leather fall under the prohibition of sewing on Shabbat?

    Gluing two pieces of material together is described as a derivative of the labor of sewing. Paper and leather are given as examples, so the prohibition extends beyond joining fabric with a needle and thread.

    Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  15. What sewing on Shabbat is prohibited by the Torah, and what is prohibited by the Sages?

    Two stitches secured with a knot count as durable sewing and violate a Torah prohibition; three stitches count as durable even without a knot. Two stitches without securing knots are prohibited by the Sages. Here, stitches are counted by the number of times the needle pierces the fabric.

    Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 14 · open and download the PDF

  16. What hope for Jerusalem’s restoration does Yeshayahu’s prophecy offer?

    The prophecy promises that the city will be cleansed of corruption and its judges and counselors restored, after which it will again be called righteous and faithful. Zion’s redemption is linked to justice, and the redemption of its repentant people to righteousness.

    ЙешайяуMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 13 · open and download the PDF

  17. Can prayer and sacrifices take the place of correcting wrongful conduct?

    In the quoted prophecy of Yeshayahu, God rejects the sacrifices, festive gatherings, and many prayers of people who continue to do evil. They are called to stop wrongdoing, learn to do good, seek justice, and defend the oppressed, the orphan, and the widow. Worship must be accompanied by a change in conduct.

    ЙешайяуMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 13 · open and download the PDF

  18. Why is the Shabbat before the Ninth of Av called Shabbat Chazon?

    The name comes from the opening word of the haftarah, “The vision of Yeshayahu,” read after the portion of Devarim. This haftarah concludes the three mournful haftarot and contains rebukes that echo Moshe’s rebukes and the theme of the Temple’s destruction. Most of it is usually read to the melody of Eichah.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Holidays and datesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  19. How does the Maggid of Dubno explain the double pain of punishment?

    In the parable, a teacher instructs an ignorant pupil to strike another pupil for a mistake in his studies. The pupil suffers both from the blow and from the humiliation of being punished by someone who does not understand the mistake. This illustrates the double burden of punishment inflicted through nations themselves steeped in the sins for which they punished the Jews.

    Магид из ДубныMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  20. What does the expression “sinned doubly” mean?

    The editorial note explains that some sins involve wrongdoing both against God and against another person. This dual wrongdoing corresponds to a double punishment. When a person repents, God’s consolation will also be double.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Mussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  21. How does an eruv between courtyards help explain what was wrong with Korach’s conduct?

    Rabbi Shmuel Hubner explains that an eruv joins homes to promote friendship, whereas Korach divided a single peaceful home into separate “courtyards.” The cited story from the Jerusalem Talmud describes how sending an eruv through a child helped two estranged neighbors reconcile. The lesson is to strengthen neighborly relations rather than create division.

    рабби Шмуэль ЃубнерMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  22. How are Rashi’s two explanations of Chatzerot—the rebellion of Korach and Miriam’s conduct—connected?

    Rav Chagai Preshel proposes understanding both explanations as a single rebuke connected with Korach’s rebellion. The people not only rebelled but also failed to learn from Miriam’s punishment for harmful speech. In his proposed explanation, returning to the same place should have reminded them of that lesson.

    Рав Хагай ПрешелWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  23. Where and when did Korach’s rebellion take place, and how can the different explanations be reconciled?

    Rav Chagai Preshel suggests that the people returned to Chatzerot after the sin of the spies and that Korach’s rebellion occurred there at that time. However, Gur Aryeh and Ramban place it after the sin of the spies in the wilderness of Paran. Malbim’s explanation accounts for their remaining there despite the command to leave: repentance and prayer mitigated the decree and allowed a prolonged stay in Kadesh.

    Рав Хагай ПрешелWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 11 · open and download the PDF

  24. Why do Jews continue to mourn the Temple after so many centuries?

    The text explains this mourning through the story of Yaakov, who could not be comforted over Yosef because Yosef was alive. The continuing grief over the Temple likewise expresses that the loss is not final: the Temple will be rebuilt.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Moshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  25. Why were these particular laws and events included in Devarim?

    According to Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch, Devarim prepares the people for life in Eretz Yisrael after the constant miracles of the wilderness cease. The Jews would need to work, establish courts and public institutions, care for the vulnerable, and preserve their faith amid temptations. The book therefore includes the parts of Moshe’s teaching most relevant to settling the land and establishing national life.

    Раби Шимшон Рафаэль ГиршWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  26. What can we learn from the failed attempt to enter the Land of Israel after the sin of the spies?

    After the decree against the wilderness generation, the Jews tried to correct the situation immediately by launching an attack. They ignored Moshe’s warning that God was not with them and were defeated. The story shows that a desire to correct earlier disobedience does not justify acting against Moshe’s warning again.

    Нахум ПурерWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  27. How should I respond to the community’s suffering if I have not been personally affected?

    A person should feel the pain of the Jewish people and not detach from shared suffering for the sake of personal comfort. The article gives the examples of Moshe praying during battle while seated on a stone, and the Chafetz Chaim refusing to sleep in a bed during wartime because he knew of others’ hardships. This sense of responsibility is expected of both leaders and ordinary Jews.

    Рав Бенцион ЗильберMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  28. Can we confidently identify the spiritual cause of the Jewish people’s present troubles?

    The author says that the cause cannot be identified with certainty: it may involve a particular transgression or the suffering preceding Mashiach’s arrival. At the same time, he emphasizes the connection between the people’s condition, their conduct, and their relationship with the Creator. A practical way to help is to increase spiritual merits through Torah study and heartfelt prayer, which has power in any language.

    Рав Бенцион ЗильберBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  29. How can historical and spiritual explanations of the Temple’s destruction fit together?

    The author distinguishes the outward course of events from their spiritual roots: these explanations concern different levels and can both be true. A historical account connects the destruction of the Second Temple with the revolt and Roman actions, while the Talmud points to baseless hatred among Jews. Recognizing the spiritual root behind outward events requires a deliberate intellectual effort.

    Рав Бенцион ЗильберBitachon and emunahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

  30. What should one reflect on during fasts commemorating calamities?

    According to the explanation of Maimonides cited here, the central task is to examine one’s own actions and the actions of earlier generations that led to calamities. One should consider the spiritual causes of events, rather than merely recall the tragedy itself. Rav Bentsion Zilber applies this approach to the mourning period before the Ninth of Av as well.

    МаймонидHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  31. Why is the Shabbat before the Ninth of Av called Shabbat Chazon?

    The name comes from the haftarah read after the weekly Torah portion on that Shabbat. It is “Chazon Yeshayahu,” “The Vision of Yeshayahu,” from Yeshayahu 1:1–27.

    Рав Бенцион ЗильберHolidays and datesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  32. How were suitable candidates for judicial office found and promoted?

    The Great Sanhedrin sent emissaries throughout Eretz Yisrael to find worthy people. A person was first appointed as a judge in his own city and then promoted.

    РамбамHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  33. What character should a judge have according to Rambam?

    For a judge on a court of three, Rambam lists wisdom, humility, fear of God, indifference to money, love of truth, being loved by others, and a good reputation. A judge must control personal passions and be ready to courageously protect a victim of robbery. Moshe provides the example: while a fugitive in a foreign land, he defended Yitro’s daughters.

    РамбамHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  34. What knowledge and qualities does Rambam require of a member of the Sanhedrin?

    Members of the Sanhedrin must be wise, discerning Torah scholars with great intellectual ability and knowledge of other disciplines and practices relevant to judging. They must know most languages to hear witnesses directly, have a respectable appearance, and have no physical defects. A very old or childless person is not appointed because sufficient compassion is required. Kohanim and Levites should be appointed to the Great Sanhedrin, but it may consist of other Jews if they are unavailable.

    РамбамHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  35. How are the differences between monetary cases and capital cases known?

    These categories of cases fall under different courts and differ in ten procedural details. The details are not set out in the written Torah: Moshe explained them orally, and they were later recorded in the fourth chapter of tractate Sanhedrin.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  36. Why were cases referred to a higher court in the Jewish judicial system described here?

    A higher court was consulted when a lower court could not resolve a case or was uncertain about its halachic basis. This was not an appeal against an existing ruling, which was considered final. In the wilderness, Moshe was the highest authority, and when in doubt he consulted God.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  37. May a judge withdraw from a case out of fear of retaliation?

    The article explains that a judge may withdraw out of fear of one of the litigants only before hearing both sides. Once the judge has reached a decision, the ruling must be announced without fear of a person.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  38. May a judge hear a case involving a close friend or a personal enemy?

    According to the explanation cited from the Shulchan Aruch, the judge must transfer such a case to someone else. Both parties must be equal in the judge’s eyes; the ideal described is for the judge to know neither party.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  39. What do “brother” and “stranger” mean in the command to judge fairly?

    In the explanation of Rashi presented here, the distinction concerns categories of cases, rather than different treatment of people of different origins. “Stranger” here refers to a litigant or a neighbor, so the verse also covers property disputes between neighbors.

    РашиWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  40. How should a judge listen to the parties in a dispute?

    A judge should allow the parties to speak and listen patiently and calmly. The judge should also speak calmly and decide the case objectively and impartially.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  41. What was required of the officers who enforced judicial decisions?

    The officers ensured that judicial decisions were carried out. They needed moral qualities as high as those of the judges, but were not required to have the same depth of Torah knowledge.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  42. Why are the judges appointed by Moshe not described as “understanding”?

    The ability to apply knowledge precisely is uncommon, although it is very important for a judge. Moshe needed judges over tens, fifties, hundreds, and thousands, and could not find enough people who possessed all the required qualities.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 4 · open and download the PDF

  43. What qualities should a Jewish judge possess?

    The article lists seven qualities: fear of God, truthfulness, financial independence, indifference to money, wisdom, understanding, and a good reputation. Wisdom means thorough knowledge of Torah and law, while understanding means the ability to apply the law correctly to a particular case.

    Рав Ицхак ЗильберHalachaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  44. Why did Moshe remind the people of their experiences in the wilderness before his death?

    Moshe recalled past mistakes so that the Jews would not repeat them, and explained how they should live in Eretz Yisrael. He taught laws and warned of the trials and exile that would follow if the people abandoned the path shown by God.

    Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Weekly parshaRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 301 Dvarim 2022, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  45. May someone begin studying Torah for peace of mind or material goals?

    Rav Chaim of Volozhin explains that one cannot immediately attain Torah study entirely for its own sake without beginning with other motivations. A person may start for peace of mind, honor, or material goals, and later develop more elevated motives. This gradual path applies both to educating children and to one's own spiritual development.

    Рав Хаим из ВоложинаMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  46. What does it mean to serve God in purity?

    Ramchal means serving solely to fulfill the Creator's will, without seeking an additional benefit for oneself. Rabbi Moshe Axelrod explains that this is the ideal of divine service. Not having reached this level does not mean that a person's service is worthless.

    рав Моше АксельродMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 20 · open and download the PDF

  47. How does the quoted passage from the Zohar explain the rule of Ishmael's descendants over the Holy Land?

    In the quoted account, Rabbi Chiya explains this as a temporary reward to Ishmael's descendants for circumcision, despite the differences described between their practice and that of Isaac's descendants. According to the passage, they are entrusted with the holy places while the land lies desolate, until that merit is exhausted. Rabbi Chiya weeps because he foresees obstacles to the Jews' return and the suffering this period will bring them.

    раби ХияMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  48. Why was correcting grave sins insufficient to preserve the Second Temple?

    Rabbi Ovadya Klimovsky offers his own understanding of Rav Saadya's words: the people were meant to correct their conduct during the allotted period. Although idolatry, sexual immorality, and murder had been overcome, relationships between people remained far from the Torah's requirements. Injustice, harmful speech, and other expressions of baseless hatred prevented the Second Temple from enduring longer.

    рав Овадья КлимовскийMussar and characterRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 19 · open and download the PDF

  49. How does Rav Saadya Gaon explain the seventy seven-year periods in Daniel's prophecy?

    Rav Saadya Gaon identifies the seventy seven-year periods with the interval between the destruction of the First and Second Temples. In the calculation presented, the Second Temple was built 70 years after the First Temple's destruction and stood for 420 years. Together, these periods total 490 years.

    Рав Саадья ГаонHistory and storiesRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

  50. Why do the prophets not specify the exact length of the exile after the destruction of the Second Temple?

    Rabbi Ovadya Klimovsky explains that the prophets were primarily concerned with the destruction of the First Temple, and prophecy ceased shortly after the Temple was rebuilt. Nevertheless, the warning in Devarim is traditionally associated with the exile after the Second Temple, and some prophetic passages allow that interpretation. An exact duration spanning many centuries was not foretold because the length of exile depends on the people's conduct, and such a prediction could have driven them to despair.

    рав Овадья КлимовскийMoshiach and geulahRead more

    Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 350 Dvarim 2023, p. 18 · open and download the PDF

By weekly parsha