Parshat Chukat — questions and answers — Page 2
Questions and answers on the weekly parsha from leaflets, newspapers and magazines across the years. Every answer names its author and source issue.
5,563 entries
What is the difference between mishpatim, edot, and chukim?
Mishpatim are commandments that can be explained logically, such as the prohibitions against stealing and murder. Edot are commandments that bear witness, such as celebrating Pesach in remembrance of the Exodus. Chukim are laws whose reasons lie beyond human experience.
РАВ ИЦХАК ЗИЛЬБЕРWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 244 chukat 2021, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How can I observe commandments whose meaning I do not understand?
Rav Yitzchak Zilber compares the commandments to the Creator’s instructions for fulfilling our purpose. We use the laws of nature without fully understanding their essence; similarly, we observe chukim as God’s commands even when their reasons remain hidden.
РАВ ИЦХАК ЗИЛЬБЕРBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 244 chukat 2021, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why is the weekly Torah portion called Chukat?
The portion begins with the words “This is the law of the Torah” and the law of the red cow, which concerns purification from ritual impurity. The name Chukat comes from the word chok, meaning law.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»Weekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 244 chukat 2021, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What should a Jew do after leaving another religion and returning to Judaism?
The rabbi explains that someone born Jewish remains Jewish forever; when only one parent is Jewish, Jewish status is transmitted through the mother. According to the ruling he cites from the Shulchan Aruch, someone who adopted idolatry or Christianity should accept the obligation to observe the commandments before three Torah scholars and immerse in a mikveh. For someone who did not know they were Jewish, he reports a different procedure in the name of an unnamed leading rabbi: the earlier actions are considered inadvertent, and these procedures are unnecessary. That person should begin studying and observing Torah, with particular attention to Shabbat observance.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
Should I stop doing good for someone who shows ingratitude?
The rabbi distinguishes incomplete gratitude from the extreme case of having none at all. Ordinary dissatisfaction or insufficient gratitude does not mean that a person should no longer be helped. Citing the Steipler, he explains that the restriction concerns people who respond to repeated kindness only by feeling increasingly entitled to more. The Jewish people's ingratitude toward Moshe did not reach that level, so kindness toward them should continue.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
After the sin of the golden calf, did the Jewish people become Moshe's people instead of God's people?
Moshe prayed intensely for the Jewish people and saved them, but they remained God's people, connected to the patriarchs. The rabbi compares this to someone who reconciles a husband and wife: helping them does not make the wife the mediator's spouse.
рав Бен Цион ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
Is early acceptance of Shabbat viewed the same way in Israel and outside it?
The article notes that accepting Shabbat from plag hamincha is customary mainly outside Eretz Yisrael. Within Eretz Yisrael, many halachic authorities oppose the practice; Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and Rav Elyashiv are named among them. Their reasons are not explained in this text.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
May I accept Shabbat and eat early, then pray Maariv after nightfall?
One may accept Shabbat from plag hamincha, recite Kiddush and eat the meal, and then pray Maariv after the meal once night has fallen. The meal must begin more than half an hour before nightfall. This arrangement is convenient where there is no minyan or where a minyan can gather after nightfall.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How should I count the Omer if the minyan prays Maariv before nightfall?
If the congregation counts the Omer before nightfall, one may join them without a blessing, intending not to fulfill the mitzvah through that count. After nightfall, the count must be repeated with a blessing; some communities omit the early count entirely and everyone counts individually at night. If the meal has not begun more than half an hour before nightfall, one should wait until nightfall, recite the three paragraphs of Shema and count the Omer with a blessing, and then begin the meal.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
Must an early Shabbat meal continue until nightfall?
Ideally, the meal should continue until nightfall, with a kezayit of bread eaten afterward. This accommodates the authorities who require the Shabbat meal to take place after nightfall. If this is not possible, the meal may end whenever convenient.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How long before nightfall should an early Shabbat meal begin?
After an early Maariv, one may immediately recite Kiddush and begin the meal, planning to start more than half an hour before nightfall. However, someone who recites Kiddush and starts the meal within that final half hour should not be reproached, since some halachic authorities permit it.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How should someone who lights their own Shabbat candles prepare for an early Shabbat?
An unmarried person who is responsible for lighting their own candles should pray Mincha in advance. After plag hamincha, they can light the candles at home or at the place where they will join the meal.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How should candle lighting at home be coordinated with a husband's early acceptance of Shabbat in the synagogue?
The wife should wait until plag hamincha, even if her husband has left for Mincha earlier. Ideally, she should light before he accepts Shabbat during Kabbalat Shabbat; the article explains that his acceptance of Shabbat then extends to her. If this timing is impossible, the text permits her to light later.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
When should candles be lit for an early Shabbat, and how long should they burn?
Shabbat candles may not be lit before plag hamincha; lighting them earlier does not fulfill the mitzvah. Even if the meal takes place before nightfall, it is preferable to use candles long enough, or enough oil, for them to burn until nightfall.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Must I repeat Shema if I prayed Maariv before nightfall?
When accepting Shabbat early, one may pray Maariv after plag hamincha, including Shema and its blessings. After nightfall, all three paragraphs of Shema must be repeated without the blessings. If the meal began at a permitted time and continues after nightfall, it need not be interrupted, but Shema should be recited at the first opportunity after the meal.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
When should I pray Mincha if I want to accept Shabbat and pray Maariv early?
Ideally, Mincha should be prayed before plag hamincha and Maariv afterward. Praying both after plag hamincha but before nightfall combines incompatible approaches of the Sages and Rabbi Yehuda to prayer times. In exceptional circumstances, when a minyan cannot be assembled later, some authorities permit Mincha after plag hamincha followed immediately by Kabbalat Shabbat and Maariv.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
What is the earliest time one may accept Shabbat?
Shabbat may be accepted from plag hamincha, but not earlier. The article defines this as 1.25 proportional hours before sunset: divide the time from sunrise to sunset by 12, then multiply the result by 1.25. Because of the mitzvah to add weekday time to Shabbat, even someone who normally prays Maariv after nightfall may accept Shabbat early.
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
How can a foreign-currency loan be arranged using its value in local currency?
Before making the loan, the parties agree to fix the debt in local currency at the exchange rate when the loan is issued. In the example, a loan of 100 dollars becomes a debt of 420 shekels: if the dollar rises, the borrower repays 420 shekels or their equivalent in dollars, but no more. If the dollar falls, the borrower repays 420 shekels; the text prohibits paying the equivalent amount in dollars in that case. If the rate remains unchanged, the borrower repays 100 dollars.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
May I borrow foreign currency if I already own a small amount of it?
If the borrower owns at least one unit of the desired foreign currency in the city where the loan is made, they may borrow any amount of that currency. If they have none, the lender or another person may first give them one unit as a gift or sell it to them for local currency, and then provide the loan.
Редакция «Фонд Наследия»HalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 17 · open and download the PDF
According to Rav Shaul Wagshal, how should a foreign-currency loan be arranged?
The author classifies foreign currency as goods without a fixed value because its exchange rate changes and it is not a universal means of payment in the country concerned. Under the laws of interest, the rules governing loans of goods therefore apply, and the amount lent should be tied to the current exchange rate. The article also mentions arranging a heter iska as an option.
Рав Шауль ВагшалHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
How does Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vorka explain Moses' striking the rock as concern for the people?
According to this Hasidic explanation, Moses feared the accusation that even a lifeless stone obeys God's word while Jews turn to the commandments only in distress. By striking the rock, he sought to deprive the accusers of that comparison. Thus, even his error expressed concern for protecting his people.
Раби Менахем Мендель из ВоркиChassidusRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
Why was Moses to speak to the rock rather than strike it before entering the Land of Israel?
In the cited commentary of Rabbi Shimshon Hirsch, producing water through speech is described as a higher miracle than producing it through a blow. It was intended to strengthen the people's faith in God's help more deeply. This was necessary because entering the Land of Israel required greater courage and strength of spirit.
Раби Шимшон ИршWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
Why did Aaron bear responsibility for Moses' striking the rock?
Rav Reuven Pyatigorsky explains this by the fact that Moses struck twice. The first blow may have taken Aaron by surprise, but before the second he could have stopped his brother or voiced disagreement. His silence is viewed as consciously sharing responsibility and as a warning about the consequences of silent consent.
Рав Реувен ПятигорскийWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
Is it worth setting aside one's dignity to reconcile others?
When Rav Chaim of Volozhin was criticized for involving himself in a quarrel between two rude men, he referred to the three backward steps at the end of prayer. He saw a lesson in them: for the sake of peace, a person should be willing to step back. Concern for his own dignity therefore did not stop his attempt at reconciliation.
Рав Хаим из ВоложинаMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
What rule guided the members of Rav Chaim Palaggi's peacemaking society?
When a conflict arose in the city, the society immediately sent a member to help settle it. Members pledged not to speak harshly or become angry even when insulted or struck. Peacemaking thus required self-control in difficult circumstances.
Рав Хаим ПаладжиMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Should one actively seek opportunities to make peace between people?
Yes: the cited Midrash distinguishes peacemaking from commandments fulfilled when the relevant circumstances arise. Peace must be sought and pursued, so it requires initiative. Sending messengers to Sihon is presented as an example of that pursuit.
Рав Зелиг ПлискинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Does teaching others hinder one's own Torah study?
The article rejects the concern that teaching others necessarily slows one's own growth. Tosafot and the Rosh explain the image of an open wilderness as a willingness to share Torah with everyone. For someone who does so, Torah is given as a gift, and teaching others helps one master it in less time.
Тосафот и РошMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How did Moses continue helping the people after being punished in connection with their complaints?
The Midrash cited in the article notes that Moses continued leading and caring for the people even though he himself was barred from entering the Land of Israel. He kept doing everything possible to advance their journey, including sending messengers to the king of Edom. His conduct exemplifies helping others despite personal hurt.
Рав Зелиг ПлискинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
Why must a leader be especially careful when speaking about the Jewish people?
The cited Midrash emphasizes a leader's responsibility for the words addressed to the people. According to one opinion, Moses' calling them “rebels” was the reason he did not lead them into the Land of Israel. This example warns against disparaging the entire people.
Рав Зелиг ПлискинMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
What lesson about false accusations is conveyed by the story of the French consul?
In the story, the consul insisted that two Jews be tortured even though the investigation found no grounds for charges. After Rav Nissim Harari-Rafumo cursed him, the consul died, and the authorities released the prisoners, seeing God's hand in the event. The story presents persistent accusations against innocent people as a negative example and depicts retribution.
Исраэль СпекторHistory and storiesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Why did punishment for slander in the wilderness come through snakes?
Rashi explains this through the principle of measure for measure. The serpent, itself punished for slander, became the instrument of punishment for those who spoke slanderously.
РашиMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How did a rabbi help a husband who wanted a divorce over burnt hamin?
Rav Chizkiya HaKohen Rabin showed the husband that the hamin in his own home had also burnt. He explained that the heat could have caused it, rather than any fault of the wife, and reminded him that other food was available. The husband calmed down, apologized, and the couple returned to a peaceful life.
Рав Хизкия Акоэн РабинShalom bayitRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Is it always right to reduce sleep for additional hours of Torah study?
In the story, Rav Avraham Chaim Adas stopped his students' late-night study after learning that Rav Ezra did not eat meat daily. He explained that additional study required adequate nourishment; otherwise, it was better to go to sleep earlier. The students accepted his instruction out of respect for their father and teacher.
Р. Авраам Хаим АдасHealth and soulRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
How did Maimonides help a poor scholar who came to him pretending to be ill?
In the story, Rabbi Avraham ibn Ezra could not find Maimonides at home and went to his hospital pretending to be ill. Maimonides prescribed an unusual “medicine”: four hundred gold dinars. The help addressed the man's actual need—his poverty.
Исраэль СпекторCommunity and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How did Baba Haki respond to restrictions on a mikveh's operation because of a lack of funds?
After receiving a complaint, Rabbi Yitzchak Abuhatzeira came personally and demanded immediate funding for repairs to the mikveh. He insisted that Jewish family purity must not be set aside because of budgetary excuses. Following his intervention, workers were brought in and the mikveh opened.
Раби Ицхак Абухацира (Баба Хаки)Community and tzedakahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How can parents and teachers remain patient with an unresponsive child?
Rav Aryeh Katzin advises remembering one's educational mission and the lesson of the rock to which Moses was supposed to speak. Parents and teachers should address children lovingly, overcoming anger and despair rather than hitting them. They should retain faith in a child's ability to receive Torah even when the child currently seems unresponsive.
Рав Арье КацинFamily and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
What did the staff Moses was told to take to the rock symbolize?
Rav Shimshon Raphael Hirsch explains that the staff had already served in Egypt as proof of Moses' divine mission. When the lack of water led the people to question that mission again, the staff was to remind them that Moses acted as God's messenger. Awareness of that mission required patience and setting aside personal hurt.
Рав Шимшон Рафаэль ГиршWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What error does Maimonides identify in Moses' conduct at the rock?
As presented in the article, Maimonides views Moses' striking the rock instead of speaking to it as evidence of anger. The error is connected with allowing a personal emotional reaction to enter the fulfillment of God's command.
МаймонидWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How can parents tell whether their response to a child's failures puts the child's welfare ahead of their own reputation?
The article distinguishes concern for a child's future from anger rooted in personal embarrassment. In Dr. Avraham Twerski's account, a father demanded an unnecessary hospitalization for his son because he feared damage to his reputation. This negative example shows how self-interest can be presented as concern for a child.
Доктор Авраам ТверскийFamily and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
What should parents consider before sending a troubled teenager to a military-style camp?
Rav Aryeh Katzin suggests first examining whether the parent is acting for the child's benefit or for personal convenience. He says that such a camp may protect a child from immediate danger but may also cause estrangement from the family. It is therefore not a universal solution.
Рав Арье КацинFamily and educationRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
How does the author explain the rescue of Soviet Jews following Stalin's death?
Rav Bentsion Zilber describes Stalin's death as an evident act of divine intervention to save Jews. According to the article's account, it led to the cancellation of a planned deportation that threatened mass loss of life. The author refers readers to the memoirs of his father, Rav Yitzchak Zilber.
Рав Бенцион ЗильберBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Why do Jewish communities celebrate a local Purim?
A local Purim preserves the memory of a community's miraculous deliverance from danger. Such celebrations may be named after the place, the rescuer, or even the principal enemy. The article presents them as accounts of rescue alongside the tragedies of Jewish history.
Рав Бенцион ЗильберHolidays and datesRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Why does the psalm call on all nations to praise God for His kindness to the Jews?
Rav Itzele Volozhiner explained that Jews do not always know about plots against them or how those plots were thwarted. Those who planned the harm, however, know how their plans failed. They therefore have particular reason to marvel at God's deeds.
Рав Ицеле ВоложинерBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Can we be unaware of miracles God performs for us?
Yes: the article presents the miracle at the Arnon as a rescue of which the Jews were initially unaware. According to Rashi, the mountains came together and destroyed the enemies hiding in ambush, while the Jews crossed above. Only after God revealed what had happened did they sing a song of thanks.
РашиBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why does the Torah repeat Israel's requests to pass peacefully through foreign territory in detail?
Rabbi Yitzchak Zilber compares the requests to pass through Edom and Sichon's land with the account of Og advancing against Israel. When Edom refused, the Israelites took a detour, while Sichon and Og themselves marched against them. The author explains that the repetitions emphasize that Israel did not initiate these clashes and presents this as a general principle.
рав Ицхак ЗильберWeekly parshaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What does the account of the ambush at the Arnon teach about hidden miracles?
In the account, enemies hid in mountain caves by the Arnon to ambush the Israelites, but died when the mountains moved together. The Israelites passed through without knowing about the danger and learned of their deliverance only later. The author explains that people, too, can be saved from many troubles without even knowing what threatened them.
рав Ицхак ЗильберBitachon and emunahRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How can treating someone kindly help keep them from sinning?
Rabbi Meir relates that Aharon would warmly greet and speak with someone who had begun behaving badly. Later, when tempted to sin, that person would remember Aharon and feel ashamed at the thought of facing him afterward. The righteous man's respectful treatment became a reason to turn away from sin.
раби МеирMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How did Aharon help people reconcile after a quarrel?
Aharon spoke privately with each person in a quarrel and said that the other deeply regretted what had happened. As a result, when they met, they became friends again. His example presents peace as something to pursue actively by helping people overcome estrangement.
рав Ицхак ЗильберMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What should you do if you think being angry is a mitzvah in the present situation?
When Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Lubavitch was told that anger was required in a particular case, he consulted the Talmud and legal codes to verify the claim. While he searched, the initial surge of anger subsided. The story suggests examining the basis for one's belief first, allowing time to cool down.
Раби Менахем-Мендл из ЛюбавичейMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can a person change a hot-tempered disposition?
Rabbi Nachman of Bratslav related that he was naturally very hot-tempered. Through working on himself, however, he reached a point where he no longer became angry regardless of what others said or did. His example illustrates the possibility of changing one's character through personal effort.
Раби Нахман из БрацлаваMussar and characterRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 35 chukat 2017, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
By weekly parsha
- Bereishit
- Noach
- Lech-Lecha
- Vayera
- Chayei Sarah
- Toldot
- Vayetzei
- Vayishlach
- Vayeshev
- Miketz
- Vayigash
- Vayechi
- Shemot
- Vaera
- Bo
- Beshalach
- Yitro
- Mishpatim
- Terumah
- Tetzaveh
- Ki Tisa
- Vayakhel
- Pekudei
- Vayikra
- Tzav
- Shemini
- Tazria
- Metzora
- Acharei Mot
- Kedoshim
- Emor
- Behar
- Bechukotai
- Bamidbar
- Naso
- Behaalotecha
- Shelach
- Korach
- Chukat
- Balak
- Pinchas
- Matot
- Masei
- Devarim
- Vaetchanan
- Eikev
- Re'eh
- Shoftim
- Ki Teitzei
- Ki Tavo
- Nitzavim
- Vayeilech
- Haazinu
- Vezot Habracha