Shabbat and technology: timers, smart home, appliances — Page 2
Shabbos timers, Sabbath mode, refrigerators, motion sensors, hot-water urns — halachic answers from Jewish publications.
526 entries
May a refrigerator be opened on Shabbat if doing so affects its thermostat?
The text presents differing opinions because incoming warm air may cause the motor to start. Some recommend a timer and opening the refrigerator only while its power is off. Others permit opening it without a timer but only while the motor is running, while some do not require that condition either.
Рав Яков-Йехезкель ПозенHalachaRead more
Source: Fond Nasledia — offline 320 miketz 2022, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May a non-Jew be asked to turn the gas or electricity back on during Shabbat to keep food from getting cold?
If the food can be eaten cold, the text prohibits asking a non-Jew to turn the gas or electricity back on to keep it warm. The enjoyment of hot food and the mitzvah of oneg Shabbat do not permit this, even in a restaurant serving many guests. If a non-Jew was nevertheless instructed to do so contrary to halacha, the text states that no one may eat that food during Shabbat.
May a non-Jew be asked to turn on the synagogue lights if the congregation cannot pray without them?
If the electricity fails on Friday night or the evening of Yom Kippur and the congregation cannot recite the prayers from memory, a non-Jew may be asked to restore it in a case of urgent necessity. For a communal mitzvah, the text permits relying on Baal HaItur and other halachic authorities, while also citing the stricter rule of Rambam and Shulchan Aruch concerning asking a non-Jew to perform work prohibited by Torah law. If possible, one non-Jew should be asked to instruct another, which some authorities regard as a double rabbinic prohibition for the sake of a mitzvah.
How should electrical appliances be prepared before Pesach?
Before the festival, make sure the refrigerator is in Shabbat mode and, outside Israel, prepared for two days. Air conditioners, lighting, and the hot-water urn should also be arranged, the refrigerator light switched off, and the Shabbat timer set with the expected end of the Seder in mind.
Редакция «מדריך הלכתי - פסח תשפ״ו»HalachaRead more
Source: Other — -5786-מדריך פסח תשפו הפצה, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
How should a refrigerator and freezer be prepared for Pesach?
Before cleaning, unplug the refrigerator, defrost any ice, and clean the surfaces, walls, crevices, and seals. Narrow inaccessible parts should preferably be dismantled for cleaning; if that is impossible, they should be covered. Where covering would obstruct cooling, the dirt should be treated with a strong cleaning agent safely and without damaging the appliance. After cleaning, cover the shelves with paper or tear-resistant plastic.
הרב לוי שפרינגער; הרב שמואל מקמלHalachaRead more
Source: Other — -5786-מדריך פסח תשפו הפצה, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Which places must be searched for chametz?
Every place where chametz may have been brought must be searched. The article lists food cupboards, refrigerators, lunch bags, children's bags and pockets, areas under beds and cupboards, vehicles, and synagogues, among other examples. The same rule applies elsewhere whenever there is reason to suspect chametz was brought there.
הגאון הרב יניב עזיזHalachaRead more
Source: Arutz 2000 — ויקרא תשפו ערוץ 2000, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Must refrigerator shelves be covered with foil after cleaning for Passover?
Asked about a refrigerator cleaned for Passover whose shelves were not covered, the rabbi replied that his own refrigerator has no foil either. His answer indicates that in the situation described, the absence of foil does not prevent its use.
הגאון הרב בן ציון מוצפיHalachaRead more
Source: Arutz 2000 — ויקרא תשפו ערוץ 2000, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
How should fire and electrical devices be prepared before the festival?
On Yom Tov, a new flame may not be created; fire may only be transferred from an existing flame. Leave a flame burning before the festival for cooking and for lighting candles if they will be lit after the festival begins. Set timers and appliances with Shabbat modes beforehand as well.
Редакция «Другое»HalachaRead more
Source: Other — מדריך ביד רבני חבד - פסח תשפ''ו, p. 15 · open and download the PDF
How should a refrigerator and freezer be prepared for Pesach?
The refrigerator and freezer should be thoroughly cleaned with detergent, and the door seals cleaned with a toothbrush. Placing a covering beneath food on the shelves during Pesach is recommended but not required.
Source: Other — ПЕСАХ – праздник свободы, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
May one bathe in hot water on Yom Tov?
Rabbi Yaniv Aziz prohibits heating water on Yom Tov to wash the entire body. He nevertheless permits bathing in water heated by a solar water heater entirely without electricity. For an electric heater, he permits water heated before the holiday or heated during it by a timer set in advance.
הגאון הרב יניב עזיז שליט"אHalachaRead more
Source: Arutz 2000 — שבת חול המועד פסח תשפו-ערוץ 2000, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
May I use lighting restored by a non-Jewish waiter on Shabbat?
If the electricity goes out during a Shabbat meal at a restaurant or hotel and a non-Jewish waiter restores it, Jewish guests may use the light subject to a condition. The waiters themselves must also eat by that lighting.
May I use electricity on Shabbat from a company staffed by non-Jews?
The text permits using electricity on Shabbat produced by a company whose employees are non-Jews. This permission also applies in a city where most residents are Jewish.
Which foods should be prepared before Yom Tov?
Food whose flavor will not deteriorate if prepared in advance must be made before the festival. For example, salads that retain their flavor in the refrigerator should be prepared beforehand in sufficient quantities for the entire Yom Tov.
Редакция «Шабат Шалом»HalachaRead more
Source: Shabat Shalom — Shabat-Shalom_ Бамидбар 990-5786, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May gas be extinguished using overflowing water, the flame sensor, or a Chagaz timer?
One may not boil water so that it overflows and extinguishes the flame, or isolate the flame sensor from heat to shut off the gas. A Chagaz gas timer may be used provided it was set before the flame was lit.
הרב אלירן שמר, הרב ישראל יהודה, הרב שמואל מקמל, הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — -5786-מדריך חג השבועות, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May an electric stove, oven, or induction cooktop be used on Yom Tov?
A conventional electric stove or oven may be arranged on a timer beforehand, but food should be placed for cooking only while the heating element is already operating, to avoid activating the thermostat. One may not manually turn the stove on or change its heat setting; timer-controlled shutoff is permitted. The guide advises against cooking on induction even with a timer.
הרב אלירן שמר, הרב ישראל יהודה, הרב שמואל מקמל, הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — -5786-מדריך חג השבועות, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
How should electrical appliances be prepared for Shavuot followed by Shabbat?
The refrigerator should be prepared in Shabbat mode for two days, and air conditioners, the hot-water urn, and other appliances should be arranged beforehand. Lighting timers should accommodate the custom of staying awake on Shavuot night.
הרב אלירן שמר, הרב ישראל יהודה, הרב שמואל מקמל, הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — -5786-מדריך חג השבועות, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
May gas be extinguished with overflowing water, by manipulating the sensor, or with a Chagaz timer?
One may not boil water so that it overflows and extinguishes the flame. Nor may one isolate the sensor from the heat: the guide does not treat this direct manipulation as permitted indirect extinguishing. A Chagaz gas timer may be used if it was set before the flame was lit.
הרב אלירן שמר; הרב ישראל יהודה; הרב שמואל מקמל; הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — מדריך חג השבועות, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
May one cook on an electric or induction stove on Yom Tov?
A conventional electric stove or oven may be set on a timer beforehand, but it should be used for cooking only while the heating element is actually operating, not during a thermostat pause. One may not switch the stove on manually or change its heat setting; switching off by a timer is permitted. The guide recommends avoiding cooking on an induction stove even with a timer.
הרב אלירן שמר; הרב ישראל יהודה; הרב שמואל מקמל; הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — מדריך חג השבועות, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Which household appliances should be prepared before Shavuot?
When the festival is followed by Shabbat, the refrigerator should be prepared in Shabbat mode for two days, and air conditioners and the hot-water urn should be set appropriately. The lighting timer should accommodate the Shavuot night custom of staying awake.
הרב אלירן שמר; הרב ישראל יהודה; הרב שמואל מקמל; הרב לוי שפרינגערHalachaRead more
Source: Shoneh Halachot — מדריך חג השבועות, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How should the eruv tavshilin be stored, and when may it be eaten?
Keep the eruv in a protected place and guard against losing it; refrigerate the cooked dish and retain it until preparations for the Shabbat meals are complete. Ideally, use the eruv bread as lechem mishneh at all Shabbat meals and break it at the last meal.
How should candles and appliances be prepared when Shabbat immediately follows the festival?
Those using candles in glass cups should prepare separate new disposable candles for Shabbat to avoid a possible muktzeh issue when replacing them. Timers and refrigerators with a Shabbat device should be set in advance for both the festival and Shabbat.
What should be done on Shabbat if the light in an old mechanical refrigerator was not disabled?
The preferred initial solution is to place a towel between the door and the refrigerator to prevent the door from closing. If the lack of a tight seal could spoil the food, one may hint to a non-Jew to turn the bulb and disconnect it. If no non-Jew is available, the door may be closed in an unusual manner or by a child, but it may not be reopened afterward. This ruling applies only to a mechanical refrigerator, since digital models present additional issues.
הרב ירון אשכנזיHalachaRead more
Source: HaDibrot — -5786-1779788423-עלון-756-בהעלותך-הדברות, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
May I unplug an appliance on Shabbat while its timer has switched it off?
The general instruction in the answer is to leave electrical appliances alone on Shabbat. In a case of great need, an appliance connected through a Shabbat timer may be unplugged while it is off. Preferably, two people should do this together, or it should be done in an unusual manner.
הג"ר אברהם יוסףHalachaRead more
Source: HaDibrot — -5786-1781374709-פרשת-759-חוקת-הדברות, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
If a freezer breaks on Shabbat, may raw meat or fish be moved to another freezer?
If a refrigerator or freezer stops working and raw meat may spoil, the text permits moving it to another freezer at home or at a neighbor’s house. This is not considered forbidden preparation on Shabbat for a weekday. Raw fish, however, is considered inedible on Shabbat and classified as muktzeh machamat gufo, so it may not be moved.
May I weigh ingredients on mechanical scales on Shabbat when a recipe requires exact proportions?
Precisely weighing ingredients on mechanical scales or measuring them against a measuring cup’s markings is forbidden as weekday-style measuring, even without electricity. The permission to measure for a mitzvah applies when the measurement itself has halachic significance, so preparing a Shabbat meal does not by itself permit weighing. Ingredients may be added approximately, using an ordinary spoon or cup without aiming to establish an exact measure. If exact proportions matter, weigh out the portions before Shabbat.
May a child be asked to open a refrigerator if its light was not disabled before Shabbat?
If the child understands that opening the refrigerator turns on its light, one may not ask them to open it to obtain food for the family. If the child does not yet understand this, they may be told to take a favorite food from the refrigerator, so that they are opening it for their own benefit and enjoyment. When the child has no relevant understanding at all, such as below age three, this also does not violate the parents' obligation to ensure the child's Shabbat rest.
Редакция «חוקי חיים»HalachaRead more
Source: חוקי חיים — חוקי חיים — Ki Savo 5786, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May a child play with an electric toy car on Shabbat without turning it on?
If a toy can be played with without electricity, such as rolling a toy car, it may be used that way as a kli shemelachto le'issur for a permitted purpose. It may be given to a child with instructions not to activate the electricity. If a child under three subsequently activates it independently, one need not stop them, while a child above three must be stopped.
Редакция «חוקי חיים»HalachaRead more
Source: חוקי חיים — חוקי חיים — Ki Savo 5786, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May a toddler be given a toy on Shabbat that can only be played with using battery power?
A battery-powered toy that cannot be played with without activating electricity is muktzeh machmat issur. It may not be handed even to a child under three, since it is clear that the child will activate it. If such a toddler takes the toy independently and plays for their own enjoyment, there is no obligation to stop them; above age three, the parents must intervene.
Редакция «חוקי חיים»HalachaRead more
Source: חוקי חיים — חוקי חיים — Ki Savo 5786, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May a child be asked to open a refrigerator if its light was not disabled before Shabbos?
A child who understands that opening the door turns on the light may not be asked to open the refrigerator to obtain food for the family meal. If he does not yet understand that opening it causes a forbidden activation of the light, he may be told to take something he likes from the refrigerator. He is then opening it for his own benefit, so this is not considered actively causing a transgression. If he has no understanding at all, such as a child under three, the obligation of ensuring one's child's Shabbos rest is also not violated.
May a young child be given an electric toy on Shabbos?
A battery-powered toy that cannot be played with without electricity is muktzah and may not be handed even to a child under three. If a toddler who does not understand takes it independently for his own enjoyment, he need not be stopped; after age three, his parents must stop him. A toy that also allows play without electricity, such as a toy car, may be given to a child with instructions not to switch it on. If he nevertheless activates it, the same age distinction applies.
May a broken refrigerator be replaced during the Nine Days?
A refrigerator may be purchased to replace a broken one. The reason given is that this is a necessary purchase.
Rav Shmouel EliahouHalachaRead more
Source: Kol Tsofaich — Kol Tsofaich — Devorim 5786, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May a broken refrigerator be replaced during the Nine Days?
A replacement refrigerator may be purchased when the old one breaks. It may also be put into use immediately because it is essential.
Редакция «קול צופייך»HalachaRead more
Source: קול צופייך — קול צופייך — Devorim 5786, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
May I ask a non-Jew to open my fridge on Shabbos if the light will turn on?
The article treats opening a fridge with an automatic light as psik reishei, an unavoidable but unintended result. The Alter Rebbe permits the request even if the non-Jew knows the light will turn on, because switching on the light is not part of the Jew's instructions. It also presents objections from other poskim, including the view that opening the fridge directly performs two functions and therefore is not an ordinary case of psik reishei.
May electricity be switched on or off on Yom Tov, and how should a permissive custom be addressed?
The ruling prohibits switching on electricity on Yom Tov as creating fire and also prohibits switching it off. Where people follow a permissive ruling from their rabbis, the text advises explaining gently and pleasantly that they should refrain. Where there is no such established custom, it calls for objecting to the practice of those who permit themselves to switch it on.
ילקוט יוסף, כרך ה; שו״ת יביע אומר; שו״ת יחוה דעתHalachaRead more
Source: פנינים — פנינים — Pinchas 5784, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May I use an urn with a broken boiling switch if Shabbat mode heated the water well before Shabbat?
The answer applies only to an urn whose thermostat is completely disabled on Shabbat and whose water reached at least 80°C before Shabbat, a temperature unquestionably considered yad soledet bo. Authorities disagree about further heating such water, and drawing water does not necessarily accelerate heating of the remainder, since incoming air and operating conditions also affect it. There are therefore grounds for leniency, although a stricter approach is preferable where possible. The best proposed solution is to fill the urn before Shabbat with previously boiled water that, following the Rema’s ruling, has not cooled completely.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 38 · open and download the PDF
I forgot to enable Shabbat mode. May I use the manual pump if my urn normally does not boil again?
In their response to the case described, the institute’s rabbis accepted the questioner’s reasoning in favor of using the manual pump. On a very cold winter night, when the kitchen is also cold, there is greater concern that incoming air could trigger reheating. However, this is not considered an inevitable result: the keep-warm element simultaneously has less water to heat, creating a certain balance between cooling and heating.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 37 · open and download the PDF
An automatic hot-water urn failed to switch to Shabbat mode. Is closing the cold-water inlet enough?
For the automatic/manual urn described, closing the cold-water inlet is not a complete solution: in weekday mode the thermostat remains active, and drawing hot water may affect activation of the heater. In this device’s proper Shabbat mode, the heater operates at preset intervals independently of water consumption. Nevertheless, the institute’s rabbis do not categorically prohibit using it in the situation described, because several uncertainties are involved.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 36 · open and download the PDF
Can I rely on an electric hot-water urn’s “Shabbat mode” label?
Without reliable halachic certification, this label does not establish that the urn is suitable for Shabbat: the setting may merely keep the water warm while leaving the thermostat active. Drawing water could then, under certain conditions, cause the heating element to switch on again. Water in the level gauge may also have remained uncooked before Shabbat or cooled down, and could enter the urn and cook when water is drawn.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 35 · open and download the PDF
Does a “Shabbat mode” label guarantee that an urn’s thermostat is completely disabled?
In the case described, the institute declined to approve an urn because its thermostat remained active even in Shabbat mode. A user later reported that drawing several cups consecutively caused it to boil again in that mode. The authors do not declare use of this appliance unequivocally forbidden, but regard it as far from meeting stringent standards.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 34 · open and download the PDF
May water be transferred from an electric thermo-pot to a pot on a fire on Shabbat?
In the SL-6081 model discussed, a low-power heating element operates continuously in Shabbat mode. Nevertheless, the institute rabbis consider there to be grounds for refraining from transferring its water to a pot on a fire, out of concern that cooking by fire after electric heating may count as a new act of cooking involving a Torah prohibition.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 33 · open and download the PDF
Where should one begin when teaching a beginner how to use a hot-water urn on Shabbat?
In the case described, the first priority is to reinforce the woman’s decision to stop adding cold water to the operating urn on Shabbat and help her prepare enough hot water beforehand. If she has a thermo-pot, she should be taught to use only the mechanical pump, not the electric one. The authors suggest postponing discussion of buying a reliably approved appliance until she is ready to hear it, since there are grounds for leniency in pressing circumstances when dispensing water in keep-warm mode.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 32 · open and download the PDF
May an urn without a special Shabbat mode be used if it heats on preset cycles?
If the appliance uses a simmerstat that activates heating on preset timed cycles independently of water temperature, this control system permits Shabbat use. However, all the water must not be withdrawn if doing so triggers the safety cutoff. Water in the level gauge must have been cooked before Shabbat, and Sephardim following the Beit Yosef must also ensure that it does not cool below yad soledet bo.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 31 · open and download the PDF
May water be taken with a ladle from a thermo-pot whose manual pump is broken on Shabbat?
If the rest of the appliance is functioning properly and it is in Shabbat mode with the thermostat disabled, the institute rabbis permit taking water with a ladle. They rely on the accepted permission to remove water even from a primary vessel standing on a fire, without concern for stirring during cooking or appearing to cook; care must be taken to avoid hot steam when opening the lid.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
Is it enough that a refrigerator light does not come on to use it on Shabbat?
If the bulb has merely burned out, been removed, or been loosened, the problem remains: opening the door can directly switch the internal fan off and on while the motor is running. If the mechanical or magnetic door switch itself has been properly disabled, leniency is possible under certain conditions, which this reply does not list.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 29 · open and download the PDF
What temperature should a hot-water urn maintain in Shabbat mode?
In the institute rabbis’ opinion, the water must remain above 60°C to be unquestionably at the level of yad soledet bo. In practice, the continuously operating heating element generally maintains 80–90°C; because it operates without a thermostat, the temperature varies with the amount of water and surrounding conditions.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 28 · open and download the PDF
How can a timer switch a hot-water urn between weekday and Shabbat modes?
The device described can be fitted to order with an internal weekly or astronomical timer that controls its operating modes. An ordinary Shabbat timer only connects or disconnects the power and does not itself switch between these modes.
הרב אברהם משה הלפריןHalachaRead more
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 28 · open and download the PDF
How can a thermo-pot be used on Shabbat if its dispensing tube contains water that is not boiling?
If the other Shabbat requirements are met, including a mechanical pump and a disabled thermostat, enough water should be dispensed before Shabbat, after boiling and switching to Shabbat mode, to clear any potentially uncooked water from the tube. Sephardim who follow the Shulchan Aruch regarding reheating cooled water should also drain the tube into the sink before each serving on Shabbat and only then dispense hot water for use.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 27 · open and download the PDF
What is the concern with using a thermostat-heated mikveh on Shabbat, and what solution is proposed?
When few people are using the mikveh, someone entering mixes the cooler lower water with the upper water and may bring forward activation of the glowing heating element; the institute’s rabbis treat this as a concern involving the Torah prohibition of kindling. If the heater is already operating, merely prolonging its operation by delaying shutoff is permitted, but acting when its current state is unknown involves a dispute among halachic authorities. With a continuous flow of bathers, when the water is constantly mixed and each person’s effect is negligible, they do not consider this concern applicable. For quieter hours, they propose carefully planned timer-controlled starts that bathers cannot advance, allowing their influence at most to prolong heating already underway.
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 21 · open and download the PDF
May I pass active motion sensors on Shabbat if their ability to turn on the lights has been disabled?
Rabbi Avraham Moshe Halperin writes that the sensors should preferably be completely disconnected from electricity whenever possible. If this cannot be done, for example because residents object, permission depends on the sensors’ remaining activity having no consequences whatsoever. When passersby derive no benefit from that activity and have no interest in motion being detected, they need not avoid passing there on Shabbat.
הרב אברהם משה הלפריןHalachaRead more
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
Do I need the accommodation owner’s permission to connect the refrigerator to a timer for one Shabbat?
The institute’s rabbis distinguish between regular and one-time timer use. Regularly operating a refrigerator through a timer on Shabbat may possibly cause cumulative long-term damage whose extent cannot be precisely assessed. According to their response, a single instance of sensible and responsible use causes no damage, so the accommodation owner’s permission is not required.
Редакция «אספקלריה»HalachaRead more
Source: אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
Collections
- Shabbat and technology: timers, smart home, appliances
- Medicine and health on Shabbat
- Shabbat step by step: candles, kiddush, the meal, havdalah
- Food on Shabbat: the hot plate, blech, bishul, cholent
- Kashrut in practice: meat and milk, the kitchen, guests
- Shidduchim and dating: what may be asked, lashon hara, engagement
- What is allowed on Shabbat: muktzeh, walks, games, reading
- Talmud and Midrash: what the sources actually say