An automatic hot-water urn failed to switch to Shabbat mode. Is closing the cold-water inlet enough?
For the automatic/manual urn described, closing the cold-water inlet is not a complete solution: in weekday mode the thermostat remains active, and drawing hot water may affect activation of the heater. In this device’s proper Shabbat mode, the heater operates at preset intervals independently of water consumption. Nevertheless, the institute’s rabbis do not categorically prohibit using it in the situation described, because several uncertainties are involved.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«אמנם הלכה למעשה לא ניתן לאסור באופן מוחלט את השימוש במיחם במצב שכזה, בשל כמה וכמה ספיקות בדבר.»
- Author
- רבני המכון
- Source
- אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 36
- Parsha
- Balak