What is the concern with using a thermostat-heated mikveh on Shabbat, and what solution is proposed?
When few people are using the mikveh, someone entering mixes the cooler lower water with the upper water and may bring forward activation of the glowing heating element; the institute’s rabbis treat this as a concern involving the Torah prohibition of kindling. If the heater is already operating, merely prolonging its operation by delaying shutoff is permitted, but acting when its current state is unknown involves a dispute among halachic authorities. With a continuous flow of bathers, when the water is constantly mixed and each person’s effect is negligible, they do not consider this concern applicable. For quieter hours, they propose carefully planned timer-controlled starts that bathers cannot advance, allowing their influence at most to prolong heating already underway.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«לפיכך באותן שעות שיודעים שהטובלים במקווה הם מועטים היה מן הראוי לכתחילה שלא להפעיל את החימום,»
- Author
- רבני המכון
- Source
- אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 21
- Parsha
- Balak