May I use an urn with a broken boiling switch if Shabbat mode heated the water well before Shabbat?
The answer applies only to an urn whose thermostat is completely disabled on Shabbat and whose water reached at least 80°C before Shabbat, a temperature unquestionably considered yad soledet bo. Authorities disagree about further heating such water, and drawing water does not necessarily accelerate heating of the remainder, since incoming air and operating conditions also affect it. There are therefore grounds for leniency, although a stricter approach is preferable where possible. The best proposed solution is to fill the urn before Shabbat with previously boiled water that, following the Rema’s ruling, has not cooled completely.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«אך יחד עם זאת נראה כי מן הראוי להחמיר בכך לכתחילה, אם אפשר.»
- Author
- רבני המכון
- Source
- אספקלריה — אספקלריה — Balak 5785, p. 38
- Parsha
- Balak