Skip to main content
.

Food on Shabbat: the hot plate, blech, bishul, cholent

Keeping food warm without violating bishul and shehiyah: the hot plate, the blech, returning food to the fire.

307 entries

  1. After adding water to cholent, should I replace the lid before or after returning it to the fire?

    The article recommends replacing the lid before returning the pot to the fire. Some authorities prohibit covering a pot while it is on the fire even when its contents are fully cooked. Many other authorities do not insist on this restriction.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave60, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  2. Should I wait until cholent is completely dry before adding water on Shabbos?

    Ideally, water should be added before the cholent dries out completely. Some authorities consider dried-out cholent roasted, so adding water would constitute prohibited cooking after roasting. Other authorities rule that this concern need not be taken into account.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave60, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  3. How can I avoid making an urn fleishig when pouring water into meat cholent?

    Steam rising from meat cholent can make the kettle or urn fleishig. After uncovering the pot, first allow the steam to escape and only then bring the urn close to it.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave60, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  4. Is it enough for water in a Shabbos urn to be hot before adding it to boiling cholent?

    Water in a Shabbos urn does not always reach boiling point, and bringing it to a boil in the cholent may violate the Torah prohibition of cooking. The article gives a required temperature of 212°F, or, according to another opinion, at least 175°F. If the water previously reached the relevant temperature and cooled only slightly, it may be added; the footnote explains that it must still be considered hot by someone wanting a hot drink.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave60, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  5. How may hot water be added to cholent on Shabbos?

    The discussion permits adding water when the cholent is fully cooked and the heat source is covered with a blech or aluminum foil. The preferred method is to remove the pot and hold it in the air; the next options, in order, are supporting it partially on a surface, setting it down without releasing one's grip, and moving it to a hot part of the blech. Adding water while the pot remains on the heat source is allowed only as a last resort, slowly and gently, and some authorities object to this method. Preferably, transfer the water directly from the urn or with a parve ladle that has first been left in the urn for several seconds. Pouring it into a cup and immediately emptying it into the pot is a last resort, since some authorities do not permit it.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave60, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  6. How can cholent be served from the oven on Friday night and kept hot until morning?

    According to many authorities cited, even fully cooked, still-warm food may not be returned to an ordinary oven without a special covering of the heat source; serving from a pot while it remains on the fire is also prohibited. The proposed solution is to slide the rack partly out so the pot is not directly over the flame, while part remains inside an area at yad soledet bo temperature. The pot is then not considered fully removed and may be slid back. The notes permit returning food when an oven insert is present, while a minority opinion permits it when the controls are covered or removed.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vaeira60, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  7. May cholent be cooked in a bag inside a crock pot to keep the pot clean?

    The article permits placing the cholent ingredients in a bag inside a crock pot according to all the cited views on hatmanah. The reason is that the bag serves to keep the pot clean, rather than to insulate the food.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vaeira60, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  8. May wrapped kishke or kugel be placed in cholent before Shabbat?

    The article records a dispute about fully cooked food in closed wrapping: some authorities consider submerging it in cholent prohibited hatmanah, while others permit it. It states that all permit food placed there to finish cooking; the footnote requires it to be fully cooked before Shabbat or the heat source to be covered. Fully cooked food may also be submerged in a partially open, punctured, or porous wrapping, which allows it to absorb the cholent's flavor and is not treated as insulation.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vaeira60, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  9. Does lining a utensil with paper or foil exempt it from immersion?

    According to the ruling cited from Sefer Tevilat Keilim, serving utensils require immersion even when a lining always separates them from food. Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach nevertheless exempted pitchers primarily intended to hold a bag of milk. Different approaches are cited for a blech: some exempt it because food is not normally placed directly on it, while Rabbi Hershel Schachter compares it to a covered serving platter that requires immersion.

    Rabbi Michoel ZylbermanHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vaeira67, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  10. When should the cholent pot be covered after water has been added?

    The article advises replacing the lid before returning the pot to the fire. Some authorities prohibit covering a pot while it is on the fire even when the food is fully cooked, although many others do not insist on this restriction.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  11. Why should water preferably be added before cholent dries out completely?

    Some authorities consider completely dried-out cholent to be roasted, so adding water would constitute prohibited cooking after roasting. The article therefore recommends adding water before it dries out completely. Other authorities do not require concern about this issue.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  12. How can one avoid making an urn meat-designated when adding water to meat cholent?

    One must account for steam rising from the meat cholent toward the urn or kettle. The article instructs readers to uncover the pot and let the steam escape before bringing the urn close to pour.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  13. Is hot water from a Shabbat urn necessarily hot enough to add to cholent?

    No: the article warns that urn water may not have reached the required temperature and could boil upon entering the cholent, potentially violating the prohibition of cooking. It gives a threshold of 212°F or, under the cited more lenient approach, at least 175°F. Water that previously reached the relevant temperature may be added after cooling slightly. The footnote explains that it must still be hot enough to satisfy someone seeking a hot drink.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  14. What is the preferred way to transfer hot water from an urn to cholent on Shabbat?

    The preferred methods are pouring directly from the urn or using a pareve ladle that has first remained in the water for several seconds. Pouring into a cup and immediately emptying it into the pot is listed only as a last resort. Some authorities do not permit the cup method.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 2 · open and download the PDF

  15. Where should the pot be when boiling water is added to cholent on Shabbat?

    The article permits adding boiling water to fully cooked cholent when the heat source is covered with a blech or foil. The preferred method is to remove and hold the pot in the air; subsequent options are partial support, resting it without releasing one's grip, and moving it to a hot area of the blech away from the direct heat. Adding water while the pot remains over the heat is a last resort and must be done slowly and gently. The footnotes note disagreements over some of these methods.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  16. How does the article instruct readers to use a crockpot for Shabbat cholent?

    The cholent should preferably be fully cooked before Shabbat; if half cooked, or one-third cooked in difficult circumstances, it may remain and continue cooking. Below that level, the article requires heavy-duty foil over the heating element and covered controls, subject to the previously cited opinions. Returning the inner pot on Shabbat requires foil over the heating element and the conditions for returning food, including complete cooking and retained warmth. The article does not address hatmanah, which may prohibit the use of certain crockpots.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  17. May cholent be returned to an oven on Shabbat?

    Many of the cited authorities prohibit returning cholent to an oven without an oven insert. A minority permits it without an insert if the controls are covered or removed and the stated conditions for returning food are met: intention to return it, complete cooking, and retained warmth, with the pot ideally not rested on a surface.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  18. How cooked should cholent be before it is left in an oven for Shabbat?

    It is advisable to have the cholent fully cooked before Shabbat begins. If this was not done, it may remain in the oven when half cooked, or one-third cooked in difficult circumstances. If it has not reached that degree, the article permits leaving it only with an oven insert.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  19. Under what conditions may cholent be returned to the stovetop on Shabbat?

    The pot is removed with the intention of returning it, and the flame must be covered with a blech; covering the controls depends on the opinions cited. The cholent must be fully cooked and still warm when returned. Ideally, the pot should be held without resting it on any surface.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  20. When should the flame under cholent be covered with a blech before Shabbat?

    Under the rule presented in the article, a blech is required if cholent is less than half cooked; in difficult circumstances, one-third cooked is sufficient. Covering the flame is customary even when the cholent is fully cooked. Some authorities recommend also covering the controls, while others require it. A footnote cites Chazon Ish's differing view that a blech is unnecessary for fully cooked food and does not help for uncooked food.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  21. Which prohibitions must be considered when leaving cholent for Shabbat?

    The article distinguishes the Torah prohibition of cooking on Shabbat from rabbinic restrictions on leaving food on a heat source before Shabbat and returning it during Shabbat. These restrictions prevent increasing the heat; returning food can also resemble cooking. They apply to a stovetop, an oven, and a crockpot.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Vayakhel57, p. 1 · open and download the PDF

  22. What alternatives to placing food directly on a blech are discussed for warming cooked food on Shabbat?

    The article cites opinions allowing fully cooked food to be warmed beside the fire or blech, or on top of a pot already standing there permissibly. It also mentions a part of the blech far enough from the fire that food can become warm but can never reach yad soledet bo. These are approaches presented for study rather than an independent practical ruling, and the author advises consulting one's own rabbi about their application.

    RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — VayakhelPekudei62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  23. May fully cooked dry food from the refrigerator be returned to a blech on Shabbat?

    The article presents a stringent approach requiring the food to remain warm, the pot to remain in one's hand, and an intention to return it when it was removed. Cold food from the refrigerator therefore fails these conditions. Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik is quoted as permitting fully cooked dry food if it was on the blech when Shabbat began and was first removed on Shabbat, treating its return as a continuation of the original placement. Many authorities reject this leniency, so the author directs readers to their own rabbi for practice.

    RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — VayakhelPekudei62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  24. Why can't fully cooked dry food simply be placed on a flame to warm on Shabbat?

    Even when reheating is not biblical cooking, the rabbinic prohibition against an act that looks like ordinary cooking remains. The article therefore prohibits placing such food directly on a flame or burner. A metal covering, or blech, is discussed as a way to alter the heating arrangement, but it does not by itself remove the other conditions; practical guidance should come from one's rabbi.

    RABBI MICHAEL TAUBESHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — VayakhelPekudei62, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  25. May food be served from a pot standing directly over a flame on Shabbat?

    The article prohibits serving food from a pot directly over a flame, whether or not the food is fully cooked. This remains prohibited even if the pot is too heavy to remove, although a somewhat more lenient opinion of the Chazon Ish is noted. If the pot stands on a blech away from the area directly over the flame, many authorities permit serving from it.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  26. When is stirring food in a pot prohibited on Shabbat?

    Hot food may not be stirred in a pot standing on a fire or blech, even if it is fully cooked. After the pot is removed from the fire or blech, stirring remains prohibited if the food is not fully cooked.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  27. May hot water from an urn be added to soup or cholent on Shabbat?

    The article lists adding hot water from an urn to a pot of soup or cholent as permitted. Its footnote explicitly notes, however, that this permission involves many details that are not explained here.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  28. How may a baby’s milk bottle be warmed on Shabbat?

    Hot water from an urn may be poured over a cold bottle of milk. Another permitted method is to pour hot water into a separate vessel and then place the bottle in it. The article directs that the bottle not be completely submerged to avoid hatmanah, while its footnote records more lenient opinions on this point.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  29. Must foil be opened when warming food on top of a pot on Shabbat?

    The article directs that the foil be partially opened to avoid hatmanah, the prohibition on insulating food. Its footnote records a disagreement over whether this wrapping constitutes hatmanah. If the foil serves only as a plate rather than retaining heat, all the cited authorities permit it. If more than one piece of foil is wrapped around the food in this situation, all the cited authorities prohibit it.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 10 · open and download the PDF

  30. How may cold, dry, cooked food be reheated on Shabbat?

    Dry, fully cooked meat, chicken, or kugel may be placed on top of a soup or cholent pot standing on a blech or in a crock-pot. These foods may also be placed on a radiator, subject to the restrictions on insulating food. This permission does not cover frozen food with ice crystals on it. Cold food may not be placed directly on a fire or on an area of the blech where it could become hot.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  31. May challah be dipped into hot soup and a cookie into hot tea?

    The article permits dipping challah into hot soup or cholent because cooking a baked food in a third vessel is allowed. Contact between challah and a hot davar gush is also permitted, as it is treated as baking an already baked item. By contrast, dipping a cookie or cake into hot tea or coffee is prohibited as cooking a baked food in a second vessel.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  32. May croutons, noodles, or cold cooked meat be added to hot soup or cholent?

    The article permits adding croutons to a bowl of hot soup: deep-fried croutons are already cooked, and for baked ones the bowl is treated as a third vessel. Fully cooked noodles may even be added to a hot soup pot removed from the fire, because dry cooked food may be cooked again. For the same reason, hot cholent may be eaten together with pieces of cold cooked meat.

    RABBI DONIEL NEUSTADTHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro62, p. 9 · open and download the PDF

  33. Do oven racks, grills, or a blech require immersion?

    A stove, oven rack, or blech normally used to support pots rather than food itself does not require immersion. A grill or toaster-oven rack on which food is placed directly requires immersion with a blessing.

    Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Yisro73, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  34. May dry food be reheated on top of another pot on Shabbat?

    The lesson cites the Shulchan Aruch's permission to rewarm dry food on a pot containing food because this is not a normal method of cooking. It separately discusses a wide water-filled vessel, a “kediera” blech: some permit placing food on it, while others treat it as an ordinary blech that does not resolve the problem.

    Rabbi Shimon IsaacsonHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — AchreiKedoshim78, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  35. When does removing dried dirt or food from clothing violate the prohibition of grinding on Shabbos?

    Even when the stain-removal rules would allow cleaning, dried mud or hardened pieces of unprocessed fruit and vegetables may not be scraped off if they crumble, because of the prohibition of grinding. This prohibition does not apply to previously ground food or to beans and potatoes from cholent cooked so thoroughly that they count as already ground. The restrictions concerning removal of the stain itself still apply. When necessary, a non-Jew may be asked to remove this dried material.

    Rabbi Doniel Yehuda NeustadtHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — BeharBechukosai59, p. 8 · open and download the PDF

  36. May food be served from a pot that is still on the flame on Shabbos?

    The text prohibits serving food from a pot directly on a flame, whether or not the food is fully cooked. A pot being too heavy to remove does not override the stated prohibition, although a more lenient position of the Chazon Ish is noted. If the pot is on the blech but not directly over the fire, many poskim permit serving from it.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  37. When is stirring hot food in a pot prohibited on Shabbos?

    Hot food in a pot on the fire or blech may not be stirred, even when fully cooked. After the pot has been removed from the fire or blech, stirring remains prohibited if the food is not completely cooked.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  38. May a cold wet ladle be put into hot soup on Shabbos?

    A cold wet ladle may not be put into a pot of hot soup even after the pot has been removed from the fire or blech. This applies both to tap water and to cooled soup remaining on the ladle, because cooking or reheating cold liquid in a kli rishon is prohibited.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  39. How may a baby's bottle of milk be warmed on Shabbos?

    The text permits pouring hot water from an urn over a cold milk bottle, explaining that the bottle rather than the milk inside undergoes cooking-level heating. Another permitted method is to pour the water into a separate vessel and then put the bottle into it; the footnote bases this on reheating a previously cooked liquid in a kli sheini. The bottle should not be fully submerged because of hatmanah, although more lenient opinions are also cited.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  40. Must foil be opened when reheating food in a permitted way on Shabbos?

    The text advises partially opening the foil to avoid prohibited hatmanah, or insulation to retain heat. A footnote records a dispute about food fully wrapped in one sheet in the case described. If the foil serves only as a plate, all the cited authorities permit it; if more than one sheet is wrapped around the food, all prohibit it.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  41. How may cold cooked meat or kugel be reheated on Shabbos?

    Dry cooked meat, chicken, or kugel may be placed on top of a pot of soup or cholent that is on the blech or in a crock-pot. The text also permits placing such food on a radiator. This permission does not apply to frozen items with ice crystals, because cooking ice is prohibited; wrapping the food also requires attention to the rules of insulation.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  42. Why may challah be dipped into hot soup, but a cookie may not be dipped into hot tea?

    The text permits dipping challah into soup or cholent served by ladle, because this is a kli shelishi, where cooking a baked item is permitted. Contact with a davar gush is treated here only as baking the challah again. Cake or cookies may not be dipped into hot tea or coffee in a kli sheini, because cooking a baked item in that vessel is prohibited.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  43. May cold cooked meat be eaten together with hot cholent on Shabbos?

    Hot cholent may be eaten together with cold cuts or other pieces of cooked cold meat. This applies whether the cholent is soupy or contains solid chunks, because the meat is already cooked.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  44. How does reheating cooked dry food on Shabbos differ from reheating liquids?

    Fully cooked dry food may be reheated by a permitted method. A previously cooked liquid may be reheated only while it is still warm from its earlier cooking. This does not permit placing cold food directly on a flame or on an area of the blech where it can become hot.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Emor59, p. 3 · open and download the PDF

  45. How should a gas cooktop be kashered for Pesach?

    After cleaning and 24 hours of non-use, expose the grates to flame for at least ten minutes, for example under a blech, treating one burner at a time and avoiding excessive heat. The alternative given is one hour in an oven at 550 degrees. Pour hot water over the pan beneath the grate and cover the stovetop with heavy foil; a stainless steel surface may be kashered with hot water.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — MetzoraHagadol82, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  46. How should burners and the stovetop be kashered for Pesach?

    Turn each burner to its highest setting for ten minutes, covered with a chametz blech or pot; doing one burner at a time is advisable. Pour boiling water over the pans beneath the grates and cover the stovetop with heavy aluminum foil; a stainless-steel surface may be purged with hot water.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachPtOne65, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  47. How does the publication instruct readers to prepare a stovetop for Pesach?

    Wipe the top and sides with a cloth soaked in household cleaner; some people also cover them with foil. Clean the grates and then run all burners at maximum heat for five to ten minutes. The text preferably recommends placing a blech over them to spread and intensify the heat.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — PesachTzav64, p. 5 · open and download the PDF

  48. Does chalitzah remain valid if the promised payment is not made?

    Rashi explains that an unfulfilled condition does not invalidate chalitzah. Invalidation for failure to meet a condition applies to acts that can be performed through an agent, whereas chalitzah cannot be performed through an agent. Any financial obligation is considered separately from the validity of the chalitzah itself.

    RashiHalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — Tzav60, p. 6 · open and download the PDF

  49. How should an electric warming tray and a blech be prepared for Passover?

    The text recommends thoroughly cleaning an electric warming tray and covering it with sturdy foil if it will be used. A metal blech must either be kashered or completely covered; a separate Passover blech is presented as a more practical solution. In discussing foil on a blech, the text warns of possible harmful and unpleasant fumes.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — TzavHagadol66, p. 12 · open and download the PDF

  50. What does the text say about preparing electric stovetops and warming trays for Passover?

    The article treats a continuous glass or porcelain surface with heating elements beneath it as impossible to kasher; if a suitable covering interferes with operation, it suggests a separate Passover stove. Exposed electric heating elements require cleaning but not kashering. An electric warming tray should be cleaned well and covered with sturdy foil, while a metal blech should be kashered, fully covered, or replaced with a separate Passover one.

    Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more

    Source: Parsha.net — TzavPesach67, p. 7 · open and download the PDF

Collections