Money and work — Page 7
Questions and answers on this topic, extracted from Jewish publications. Every answer names its author and the issue it comes from.
6,089 entries
Where should I direct my energy when a dishonest person keeps changing the terms?
Using Jacob's example, the article recommends investing energy in excellent work and strengthening one's position. It presents this as a form of protection alongside contractual terms. Building oneself also helps keep bitterness and plans for revenge from consuming one's strength.
Редакция «כתב מרדכי»Money and workRead more
What should someone do if they want to return stolen property but cannot find its owner?
In the story, the rabbi explained that in certain such cases funds may be used for public needs, but a rabbinical court must decide. While that decision was being arranged, the repentant man prayed for a way to make amends and unexpectedly met his former employer. He confessed the thefts and offered repayment, and the owner explicitly and wholeheartedly waived the debt.
Rabbi YossiMoney and workRead more
Source: ליקוטי שמואל — ליקוטי שמואל — stories 40 — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Can taking an employer's goods be justified by saying that the employer pays too little?
The man in the story spent years calling the goods he took “side income” and justifying it by his inadequate pay. After returning to Torah observance, he recognized it as theft and resolved to make restitution. The story shows how convenient labels and self-justification can conceal the meaning of one's actions.
Rabbi YossiMoney and workRead more
Source: ליקוטי שמואל — ליקוטי שמואל — stories 40 — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Does greater effort guarantee a larger income?
According to Beit HaLevi, a person's labor and efforts cannot increase their sustenance beyond what has been decreed for them. The manna served as a sign for later generations: the one who gathered much had no surplus, and the one who gathered little had no shortage.
בעל 'בית הלוי'Money and workRead more
Source: אוצרות בן מלך — אוצרות בן מלך — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 11 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Bat Ayin refuse to let Rabbi Shmuel Heller give up medicine?
Rabbi Shmuel wanted to leave medicine because material from books required for his work distracted him during prayer. The Bat Ayin pointed out that his treatment benefited Jews, including through the gratitude of non-Jewish patients. He blessed the physician to be free of these distractions, and the account says they ceased.
הרה"ק בעל 'בת עין'Money and workRead more
Source: דרכי צדק — דרכי צדק — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 18 · open and download the PDF
How can earning a living be combined with wholehearted trust in God?
A person works at the livelihood available to them and trusts in God's blessing on their efforts. They therefore do not turn increasing income into an endless search for schemes. The article emphasizes confidence that disregarding even a minor requirement of the Shulchan Aruch cannot produce a genuine increase in livelihood.
הגה"ח הרב יוסף שיינברגרMoney and workRead more
Source: נועם ורצון — נועם ורצון — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 16 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Chafetz Chaim advise someone who received a large dowry to pray that any destined loss would happen immediately?
The advice concerned a case in which losing the dowry was already destined: it would be better for the loss to occur before becoming accustomed to luxury. The Chafetz Chaim explained that once a person grows used to excess, material desires entangle them and become difficult to escape.
חפץ חייםMoney and workRead more
Source: לב שומע - אידיש — לב שומע - אידיש — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why ask for enough to live on rather than either wealth or poverty?
Rabbeinu Bachya explains that both wealth and poverty can become trials that interfere with serving God. Asking for one’s necessary bread therefore means asking for enough to live on without these difficulties disrupting that service.
רבינו בחייMoney and workRead more
Source: לב שומע - אידיש — לב שומע - אידיש — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why did Rav Shach decline payment for studying with a young man?
Rav Shach believed that the young man did not need a teacher and that he therefore was not entitled to payment. They agreed to test whether the student could study Tosafot independently; when he succeeded, Rav Shach took no money.
הרב משה אהרן ריגרMoney and workRead more
Source: לקראת שבת מלכתא — לקראת שבת מלכתא — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Imrei Chaim praise someone for forgoing immersion in a mikveh on Shabbat?
Rabbi Yisrael Berezovsky’s father did not use an alternative mikveh because he had not paid in advance and feared forgetting the debt after returning home. At the third Shabbat meal, the Imrei Chaim praised him while discussing honesty in financial dealings. He highlighted the man’s care to ensure that his spiritual aspirations did not involve unfairness toward someone else.
ה'אמרי חיים'Money and workRead more
Source: לקראת שבת מלכתא — לקראת שבת מלכתא — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What did the Satmar Rebbe do when he remembered before Mincha that he had promised to repay a debt that day?
The Satmar Rebbe immediately sent for the person whom he had promised to repay that day. Only after the man arrived and the debt was paid did the Rebbe begin Mincha. The story illustrates his care in fulfilling a commitment to pay on time.
מרן הגה״צ מנאנאשMoney and workRead more
Source: מבאר רבותינו — מבאר רבותינו — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How can I recognize that work has taken over my thoughts?
In a humorous interpretation, Rabbi Mordechai Yechiel Luria read Yaakov's account of dreams about patterned livestock as a sign of excessive absorption in work. As long as Yaakov worked during the day without letting work possess his mind, he could endure the difficulties with Lavan. Once business entered even his dreams, it became, in this interpretation, a signal that it was time to leave.
רבי מרדכי יחיאל לוריאMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 30 · open and download the PDF
How can I preserve my faith when work draws me into worldly concerns?
Rabbi Yechezkel of Kazmir interpreted Yaakov's protection of his head as a lesson in guarding one's inner life. Even while earning a living, a person should preserve faith and keep worldly distractions from taking over the mind. As long as the “head” has not sunk into those distractions, one can still call for help and escape.
רבי יחזקאל'ע קאזמירערMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 29 · open and download the PDF
When does concern about earning a living become a trap for spiritual life?
The Baal Shem Tov interprets the image of a spread net as concern for one's livelihood taking over the mind and heart. When earning a living consumes a person completely, their heart has no room left for serving God.
בעל שם טובMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why is money compared to a ladder between earth and heaven?
Megaleh Amukot notes that the Hebrew words for “ladder” and “money” have the same numerical value. Money belongs to earthly life, yet it can raise a person toward heaven or bring about a profound downfall, so it requires great care.
מגלה עמוקותMoney and workRead more
Source: אמונת חיים — אמונת חיים — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How can I recognize that work has taken too much control of my thoughts?
Rabbi Mordechai Yechiel Luria offered a humorous interpretation of Jacob's account to his wives of his dream about the sheep. As long as Jacob worked during the day without becoming mentally consumed by it, he could endure the hardships with Laban. When work began appearing even in his dreams, this interpretation treats it as a sign that it was time to leave: earning a living was taking over his inner life.
רבי מרדכי יחיאל לוריאMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 20 · open and download the PDF
How can I go out to earn a living without becoming consumed by worldly concerns?
Rabbi Yechezkel of Kazmir advised a chasid to protect his “head” above all: keep worldly distractions from taking over his thoughts and preserve his faith. He compared this to a bird trapped in mud: as long as its head remains above the mud, it can still call for help. He interpreted Jacob's protection of his head with stones as an image of this spiritual protection before entering Laban's surroundings.
רבי יחזקאל'ע קאזמירערMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 19 · open and download the PDF
How can concern about earning a living become a trap for spiritual life?
The Baal Shem Tov interprets the image of a spread net as an allusion to preoccupation with earning a living. When that concern constantly occupies the entire mind and heart, no inner space remains for serving God.
בעל שם טובMoney and workRead more
Source: גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How should we understand the warning that the evil inclination waits immediately outside the study hall?
Beit Yaakov describes leaving the source of Torah as encountering the waiting evil inclination. The discourse explains that Torah was also given to people who go out to earn a living. Its suggested reading of the warning is to recognize the challenges that accompany that departure and be prepared for them.
Редакция «עצה ותבונה»Money and workRead more
Source: עצה ותבונה — עצה ותבונה — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What did the Rebbe advise Dr. Walinsky to change about his practice when relocating?
The Rebbe suggested arranging the practice at its new location so that the doctor would not need to work on Shabbat. According to the narrator, the advice was given gently, with a clear suggestion that observing Shabbat would improve his livelihood. The supplied portion of the story does not yet describe the outcome of this advice.
דער רביMoney and workRead more
I bought an apartment from heirs and found hidden money. May I keep it?
The money must be returned to the heirs, even if they authorized disposal of all the apartment's contents. They inherited the money as well, and their lack of knowledge about it does not constitute a valid relinquishment. Even if the previous owner had despaired of finding it, the answer states that the heirs acquired it through ownership of the premises; the buyer purchased the apartment, not the money.
Редакция «עושה שלום - ממונות»Money and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Noach 5787, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
I was unable to pay my bus fare and cannot remember the bus company. Must I pay every possible operator?
Under the rules enforceable by a court, payment to every possible company is not required, since none makes a definite claim. However, to fulfill one's obligation before Heaven, one must pay each company that may be owed the fare: the companies were not expected to know about the debt, whereas the passenger should have noted whom he owed.
Редакция «עושה שלום - ממונות»Money and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Noach 5787, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
If a relative handles one side of a match for free, may the other matchmaker demand payment from both sides?
A match handled by two matchmakers does not become the work of just one because a relative waives her fee. Each is entitled only to her own share, and the relative's waiver does not transfer that share to the other matchmaker.
Редакция «עושה שלום - ממונות»Money and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Noach 5787, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Must a matchmaker be paid if she initiated a match but then actively obstructed it?
If the matchmaker led a family to believe that the other side was no longer interested, and the match resumed only after the misunderstanding was clarified through another matchmaker, the first is not entitled to a matchmaking fee. Nevertheless, giving her a small gift is an act of piety, since she did contribute to the initial introduction.
Редакция «עושה שלום - ממונות»Money and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Noach 5787, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
What does Yaakov's resourcefulness while working for Lavan teach?
Haamek Davar sees Yaakov's actions as a model for his descendants' success in exile through diligence, intelligence, and proper conduct. Yet divine assistance is identified as the decisive factor, rather than human effort itself.
העמק דברMoney and workRead more
Source: עלים — עלים — shabbos gilyon email — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
How should one treat money intended to be repaid to others?
The publication offers another explanation of the burden of Avraham's wealth: money set aside for repaying debts placed a particularly strong responsibility upon him. Although people may be less careful with others' property, Avraham was more concerned about this money than about his own.
ר' דניאל חיים אלתרMoney and workRead more
Source: ניצוץ אחד — ניצוץ אחד — Lech-Lecha 5787, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
If a debtor pays part of an acknowledged debt only in exchange for waiving the balance, does the creditor lose the right to recover the rest?
In the case described, Harel Vaknin rules that this arrangement is not a genuine compromise but wrongful withholding of a debt. The debtor pays only part of what he already acknowledges owing, so the creditor receives nothing in exchange for waiving the balance. The author concludes that, under this coerced arrangement, the creditor may sign the waiver without a prior declaration before witnesses invalidating it and still retain the claim to the remaining debt.
הרה"ג הראל וקנין שליט"אMoney and workRead more
May a developer provide the cheapest finishes if their standard is not specified in the contract?
In the dispute described, the arbitrator required the developer to provide the standard specifications customary for that type of transaction. The decisive basis is established practice: when a customary specification exists, it defines the transaction even if the contract is silent. The article cites disagreement over whether an unspecified sale requires medium quality, so the final ruling rests specifically on custom.
Редакция «עושה שלום - ממונות»Money and workRead more
Why did the Chafetz Chaim fast after dreaming of wealth?
According to the story, the Chafetz Chaim saw two reasons to fast: if the dream came true, he would face the test of wealth; if it did not, it could reveal a hidden desire to become wealthy. Since he had not thought about this during the day, he considered the possibility of that deep desire itself a reason to fast.
החפץ חייםMoney and workRead more
Source: בלבבי משכן אבנה — בלבבי משכן אבנה — Toldos 5787, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
How can work and everyday activities become a way of serving God?
Those occupied with worldly affairs serve God by directing their actions toward Heaven and knowing Him in all their ways. In this way they bring holiness into everyday life, continuing Abraham's path of spreading awareness of God beyond his own surroundings.
כ"ק אדמו"ר מליובאוויטש זי"עMoney and workRead more
Source: א טיפערן בליק — א טיפערן בליק — Toldos 5787, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why can sudden wealth become a difficult challenge?
The author explains this as a lack of preparation for managing substantial wealth. Someone who builds a business gradually with the right outlook can also develop discipline and learn to handle money responsibly. A sudden windfall provides no such preparation, so the wealth may exceed the person's ability to cope with it.
ר' ש. קאפליןMoney and workRead more
What does skipping Torah study to save a small amount of money reveal?
In the teaching attributed to R’ Chaim Shmulevitz, such willingness reveals the value a person actually assigns to Torah study time. The example of waiting in a sale queue illustrates exchanging an entire learning session for a small saving. The article urges people to increase their appreciation of spiritual things, connecting that attitude with their reward.
ר' חיים שמואלביץ זצ"לMoney and workRead more
How does the article address the concern that wealth might distance Yaakov from Torah?
In the cited interpretation, Rivkah fears that material prosperity may lead to wrongdoing, and an opposing approach favoring poverty for spiritual steadfastness is mentioned. The answer distinguishes Yaakov from Esav: even with wealth, Yaakov is drawn to the house of study. Prosperity can therefore support Torah and mitzvot.
הרה״ק ממודז׳יץMoney and workRead more
Source: שמועה טובה — שמועה טובה — Toldos 5787, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why, according to Divrei Yisrael, did Yitzchak pray for his descendants to have wealth in exile?
Divrei Yisrael explains that exile brings heavy material demands, while poverty can interfere with serving God. Yitzchak prayed for wealth that would enable his descendants to withstand these hardships and observe Torah. In this interpretation, material abundance supports spiritual life rather than serving as an end in itself.
הרה״ק ממודז׳יץMoney and workRead more
Source: שמועה טובה — שמועה טובה — Toldos 5787, p. 5 · open and download the PDF
What lesson about honesty in business is attributed to Rav Weissmandl?
He is credited with an explanation linking the survival of many German Jews and the preservation of their property to honesty in dealings with non-Jews. According to this explanation, wealth acquired without deception was not mixed with other people’s money; dishonest dealings elsewhere are linked to the opposite outcome. The publication presents this as a religious explanation and a call for honesty in business.
ר' מיכאל בערMoney and workRead more
Source: הילולא דצדקיא — הילולא דצדקיא — Toldos 5787, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
How can a person remain unassuming after gaining wealth and status?
The interpretation of “the man grew great” emphasizes that Yitzchak remained a person among people even after his rise. He did not allow wealth to make him arrogant or distance him from ordinary human companionship.
רבי יצחק אב"ד אוליק וטורטשיןMoney and workRead more
Source: ניצוץ אחד — ניצוץ אחד — Toldos 5787, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Who pays when a driver swerves to avoid a suddenly braking car and hits a parked vehicle?
In the case discussed, another car ignored a stop sign and entered the main road, forcing the car ahead to brake. Under the ruling cited, damages cannot be recovered in a human court from the driver who entered the road, because his role constitutes indirect causation; although another opinion exists, the uncertainty prevents collection. The driver who was forced to brake and gave warning through his brake lights is also exempt. The driver who struck the parked car must pay for its damage, and the publication also notes his failure to maintain the required stopping distance.
שמרו משפטMoney and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Toldos 5787, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
May I claim unpaid wages after previously stopping my demands out of sympathy for my employer?
The employer must pay the debt even if the worker stopped demanding payment and said that he felt sorry for the employer and saw no prospect of collecting it. Such statements express giving up attempts to collect, rather than necessarily forgiving the debt itself; most authorities also do not recognize forgiveness expressed only in one’s thoughts. Even an assumed waiver is invalid if it rested on the mistaken belief that collection would never become possible. Despite a dispute over despair of recovering a debt, the publication does not allow the employer to retain the money on that basis.
מאורות תורת המשפטMoney and workRead more
Source: עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Toldos 5787, p. 2 · open and download the PDF
What segulah for livelihood does Rabbi David Shlissel cite?
He cites a segulah passed down through generations: calculate the previous week's profits and income accurately, and place the written account in the siddur while reciting “Veyiten Lecha” after Shabbat. The note is left there throughout the following week; the text associates this practice with blessing and success in earning a livelihood.
רבי דוד שליסלMoney and workRead more
Source: מעשה של פרנסה — מעשה של פרנסה — Toldos 5787, p. 1 · open and download the PDF
Must borrowed candles be replaced with candles of exactly the same size?
If the parties do not care about the candles’ size, the replacements need not be exactly the same size. The text discusses this allowance in relation to the prohibition of ribbit.
Редакция «הלכה ישרה»Money and workRead more
Source: הלכה ישרה — הלכה ישרה — Toldos 5787, p. 14 · open and download the PDF
How can the pursuit of a livelihood deprive someone of both earthly peace and spiritual life?
The Baal Shem Tov warns that the evil inclination can deprive a person of both worlds at once. One example is being so consumed by earning a livelihood that one has no rest by day or night and also has no time to attend to spiritual life.
בעל־שםMoney and workRead more
Source: דורשי יחודך רימ"ש — דורשי יחודך רימ"ש — Toldos 5787, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Why does George Gilder consider a material explanation of entrepreneurship incomplete?
Gilder criticizes the view that an entrepreneur merely combines existing material elements and takes advantage of available opportunities. In his view, this approach overlooks creativity, new ideas, and inventions, and therefore fails to explain the role of intelligence in human activity.
Джордж ГилдерMoney and workRead more
Why are wealth and poverty compared to a ladder?
Both wealth and poverty can lead to spiritual growth or decline. Wealth enables mitzvot and good deeds, but it can also foster arrogance. Poverty can cultivate humility, trust in God, and contentment with little, but it can also lead to bitterness, weakened faith, and depression.
Бааль Шем Тов; раби Меир из ПеремышлянMoney and workRead more
Why is Abraham's blessing cited in the Mishnah but not in the baraita?
Abraham tended flocks and participated in securing his livelihood, although his work enjoyed extraordinary success. Having servants did not make this a path of complete, miraculous freedom from work. His example therefore suits the Mishnah's account of blessing within the natural order, but does not establish the miraculous provision described in the baraita.
כ"ק אדמו"ר שליט"אMoney and workRead more
Source: Hagahos HaRebbe — 5710-11 כ"ף מנ"א תש"י, p. 31 · open and download the PDF
Is the path of studying Torah full time while others provide one's livelihood suitable for everyone?
In the dispute between R. Yishmael and Rashbi, the former calls for working at the appropriate times, while the latter describes studying Torah with one's work performed by others. The Talmud notes that many attempted Rashbi's approach without success. The discourse therefore identifies this path of miraculous provision as suitable for exceptional individuals rather than everyone.
כ"ק אדמו"ר שליט"אMoney and workRead more
Source: Hagahos HaRebbe — 5710-11 כ"ף מנ"א תש"י, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Can material wealth coexist with undisturbed service of God?
When God grants wealth, He can also grant the inner bittul needed to receive it properly. Material abundance can then avoid scattering a person’s attention or disrupting divine service. Moreover, Godliness can be perceived within material life itself, resembling the future revelation.
Source: Hagahos HaRebbe — 5725-03 (2) ש"פ ויצא תשכ"ה, p. 39 · open and download the PDF
How did Yaakov describe his honesty while working for Lavan?
Yaakov said that he had not taken any of Lavan's animals, had paid for losses himself, and had worked through heat and cold with little sleep. He spent twenty years with Lavan, even though Lavan repeatedly changed his wages. Yaakov explained that Hashem's protection prevented Lavan from sending him home empty-handed.
What does positive commandment 245 teach about purchases, sales, and gifts?
Purchases, sales, gifts, and transfers of property must follow Torah law. By observing these rules in property transactions, a Jew fulfills positive commandment 245.
РамбамMoney and workRead more
Why does the source of Yaakov's family's livelihood matter in the lesson?
The lesson treats material dependence on a spiritually alien environment as a source of that environment's influence. Drawing on Oznayim LaTorah and the Alshich, it explains that Lavan's wealth came through Yaakov and that the family's provisions in Egypt came through Yosef. The family was thus sustained by blessing associated with holiness, reducing the influence of the surrounding impurity.
האזנים לתורה; האלשיך; הרב צבי שורץMoney and workRead more
What did Yaakov do with the wealth he acquired in Lavan's household?
The cited Midrash relates that Yaakov sold all the property he had brought from outside the Land of Israel and offered the gold to Esav for his share in the Cave of Machpelah. Esav chose the gold. The lesson uses this story to show that accumulating money was not the purpose of Yaakov's labor.
הרב צבי שורץMoney and workRead more