If a debtor pays part of an acknowledged debt only in exchange for waiving the balance, does the creditor lose the right to recover the rest?
In the case described, Harel Vaknin rules that this arrangement is not a genuine compromise but wrongful withholding of a debt. The debtor pays only part of what he already acknowledges owing, so the creditor receives nothing in exchange for waiving the balance. The author concludes that, under this coerced arrangement, the creditor may sign the waiver without a prior declaration before witnesses invalidating it and still retain the claim to the remaining debt.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ויכול המלוה לחתום על כתב ויתור ללא מודעא וידיעת האונס, ואעפ"כ אין מפסיד את חובו.»
- Author
- הרה"ג הראל וקנין שליט"א
- Source
- עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Chayei Sarah 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Chayei Sarah