Who pays when a driver swerves to avoid a suddenly braking car and hits a parked vehicle?
In the case discussed, another car ignored a stop sign and entered the main road, forcing the car ahead to brake. Under the ruling cited, damages cannot be recovered in a human court from the driver who entered the road, because his role constitutes indirect causation; although another opinion exists, the uncertainty prevents collection. The driver who was forced to brake and gave warning through his brake lights is also exempt. The driver who struck the parked car must pay for its damage, and the publication also notes his failure to maintain the required stopping distance.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«המתפרץ לכביש בפשיעה, אינו חייב בדיני אדם, כי הוי בכלל גרמא ולא גרמי,»
- Author
- שמרו משפט
- Source
- עושה שלום - ממונות — עושה שלום - ממונות — Toldos 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Toldot