What do the words "and they shall not appear before Me empty-handed" (Shemot 34:20) refer to — to the redemption of the firstborn?
According to the plain meaning, Rashi explains, this is an independent statement unrelated to the firstborn, since the mitzvah of the firstborn involves no "appearing" before God. It is a separate prohibition: when you go up on the festivals to appear before the Lord, do not appear empty-handed — you are commanded to bring a burnt-offering of appearance (Chagigah 7a). According to the Baraita (Kiddushin 17a), this part of the verse is superfluous, since the command was already given in 23:15, and it serves for a gezerah shavah with "do not send him away empty-handed" (Devarim 15:13): the severance gift to a Hebrew servant must be five sela'im of each kind — like the redemption of the firstborn.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«вам предписано принести жертву всесожжения при предстоянии»
- Author
- Раши
- Source
- Chitas — Хитас Ки Тиса Пятница 5786
- Parsha
- Ki Tisa