Is it true that kashrut exists for health reasons and kosher food is healthier than non-kosher?
The Rambam finds the reason for the prohibitions in medicine — everything the Torah forbade is harmful — and the Rashbam writes that the forbidden animals 'are repugnant to Jews and harm bodily health'; many hold this view and even claim that non-kosher food is the cause of all illnesses. But one cannot say that healthfulness is the only reason for kashrut. First, it is hard to prove kosher food is healthier: are forshmak or cholent healthy foods? Second, modern technology can neutralize the harm in food (as in infant formulas), and then someone will say the prohibitions are 'outdated.' Third, the Torah is not a medical book: it only instructs 'guard your souls very carefully,' and each person must work out for himself what benefits his health; the Torah does not say to eat meat only after consulting a doctor, and many harmful plants are not mentioned in it at all. Fourth, Jews who keep kosher do not look healthier than non-Jews who eat everything. Therefore many commentators do not accept the health explanation.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«нельзя сказать, что полезность кошерной пищи — единственная причина соблюдения кашрута»
- Author
- Раввин Авраам Вольф
- Source
- Chevrutah24x7 — 184 RUS SHEMINI #26