Does repentance restore an honored position that has already passed to someone else?
The teaching attributed to the holy gaon of Tolchva explains that atonement does not cancel rights already acquired by someone else. Even if repentance allows the offense to be treated as involuntary, exempting the offender does not require another person to surrender what they received. This explains why the service was not restored to the firstborn after they repented for the golden calf. By the same reasoning, Esav’s repentance did not require Yaakov to return the birthright he had acquired.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל אם לאחר העבירה ניטל ממנו הכבוד וניתן לאחר, שוב אין התשובה מועלת להחזירו לו.»
- Author
- הגה"ק מטאלטשווא
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 4
- Parsha
- Vayetzei