According to Yaalat Chen, why did the lentil meal initially protect Esav’s oath but later cease to do so?
The author distinguishes an oath made in return for a benefit, whose release requires the benefactor’s consent, from an oath without such a benefit, where suspicion of violating it must be prevented. Initially, Esav valued the birthright no more highly than the lentil meal, so the food counted as a benefit that made release dependent on Yaakov’s consent. Once the birthright brought Yaakov the blessings, its greater value became apparent, and the author treats the sale as mistaken rather than beneficial to Esav. The remaining requirement was Yaakov’s presence when the oath was released, which explains why Yaakov left.
Quote from the source«כשנשבע בשביל טובה שעשה לו חבירו, אין מתירין לו אלא ברצון חבירו.»
- Author
- הג"ר ארי' יהודה ליב בן הג"ר יוסף תאומים
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Vayetzei