Why is another Torah scroll taken out for one kind of error but not for another?
Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Meislish proposes understanding the Rema’s distinction through the frequency of scribal errors: when an error is common, there is no reason to assume that another scroll is more accurate. He acknowledges that this reading of the Magen Avraham is not explicit and distinguishes it from the Minchat Chinuch’s understanding that the spelling found might itself be correct. This explains allowing continued reading when “מגרשיהן” and “מגרשיהם” are interchanged, since both occur in the same passage and are easily confused. He treats “רחבה” in place of “רחבו” as an uncommon error for which another scroll should be taken out.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«המגן אברהם לא שאל לא על המשמעות ולא על הקריאה, אלא שאלה אחת: האם טעות כזו מצויה אצל הסופרים.»
- Author
- הרב צב"י הירש מייזליש
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 3
- Parsha
- Vayetzei