Halacha — Page 12
Questions and answers on this topic, extracted from Jewish publications. Every answer names its author and the issue it comes from.
72,366 entries
What proportions do the Sages give for separating terumah from produce?
The text gives three proportions: one-sixtieth as minimal, one-fortieth as admirable, and one-fiftieth as the middle measure. The Vilna Gaon explains that the word terumah alludes to “two out of one hundred,” meaning the middle measure of one-fiftieth.
Rabbi Yaakov Asher SinclairHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
How does studying detailed laws help us experience Shabbat more fully?
Shabbat laws, including muktzah and the limits on rescuing property from a fire, require ongoing attention to what we do and how we do it. That attentiveness keeps Shabbat present in our minds. Planning, organization, and studying its laws help us appreciate Shabbat and gain more joy and spiritual growth from it.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Sages limit saving food from a burning house on Shabbat, and how much did they allow?
This applies only where there is no danger to life and carrying the items out involves no carrying prohibition. The Sages feared that distress over financial loss could lead to forbidden actions, so they established clear limits. The Mishnah’s first opinion permits saving food for the remaining Shabbat meals, but not for after Shabbat; Rabbi Yosi always permits food for three meals. All opinions allow saving as much drink as a person could potentially consume, even late in the day.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Why does splitting one Shabbat meal into two raise a dispute about unnecessary blessings?
The Behag permits ending the morning meal with Birkat Hamazon, washing again, and beginning another meal so that it counts separately. Tosafos objects that this generates unnecessary blessings, since the interruption serves only to count one meal as two. Other authorities explain that fulfilling the mitzvah gives those blessings a purpose, so they are not considered unnecessary.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can I fulfill the three-meal obligation by eating several of the meals at night or in the morning?
The Shulchan Aruch prescribes one meal on Friday night, one in the morning, and the third in the afternoon after the time for Minchah begins. Most authorities hold that concentrating several meals in one part of Shabbat does not fulfill the mitzvah. The Behag allows three separate meals over Shabbat without that restriction on timing. When the preferred arrangement is impossible, the author advises still eating three meals to fulfill the mitzvah according to the Behag.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
What is the basis of the dispute over three or four Shabbat meals?
The requirement for three meals is derived from the three occurrences of “today” in the verse about manna. The tanna kamma applies them to Shabbat as a whole, while Rabbi Chidka requires three daytime meals in addition to the Friday night meal. The Gemara’s analysis concludes that the Mishnah follows the tanna kamma’s position of three meals.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
Who is obligated to eat three Shabbat meals, and must the third include bread?
Both men and women are obligated to eat three Shabbat meals, even though this is a time-bound positive mitzvah. The rishonim disagree about whether the final meal must include bread. The Shulchan Aruch and most later authorities require bread, with hamotzi recited over two whole loaves or rolls.
Rabbi KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Terumah85, p. 6 · open and download the PDF
If I dress well on weekdays, how can my clothing express special honor for Shabbat?
Rabbi Eliyahu Ferrell suggests understanding the call for attractive Shabbat clothing as an effort to have garments reserved specifically for Shabbat. Their distinction from weekday clothing would then lie in their special designation as well as their beauty. He supports this with the Arizal’s statement, cited in the Mishnah Berurah, that one should not wear on Shabbat what one wears during the week.
Rabbi Eliyahu W. FerrellHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave56, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Does the prohibition of unsupervised milk apply to powdered milk?
The footnote cites the Chazon Ish and Rav Yonasan Shteif as including powdered milk in the ordinance. It also cites Har Tzvi as permitting it. The article therefore explicitly records a disagreement on this question.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Who may supervise the milking?
A footnote citing Aruch ha-Shulchan states that even a minor over nine years old may supervise. Citing Igros Moshe, it also permits relying on a non-believing Jew when the chance of non-kosher milk being mixed in is remote, because the original decree concerned non-Jews.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Must the milking itself be watched for the milk to count as supervised?
The footnote gives two forms of supervision: watching the actual milking or standing guard outside the milking area. In the second case, the purpose is to ensure that no other milk is brought in from outside.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
May one rely on the leniency for chalav stam in difficult circumstances?
A footnote citing Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky allows reliance on the lenient opinion in difficult circumstances when chalav Yisrael is unavailable. Business travel and hospital stays are given as examples. This refers to the article's discussed leniency for milk from large companies under government regulation.
Rav Y. KamenetskyHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
What did Rav Moshe Feinstein advise people who can obtain chalav Yisrael?
Rav Moshe Feinstein recognized grounds for permitting milk from large, government-regulated dairies, but did not personally rely on this leniency. He advised scrupulous individuals and bnei Torah to refrain from such milk and urged schools to stretch their budgets to buy chalav Yisrael. In the quoted letter, he wrote that when chalav Yisrael is obtainable, one should buy it even if it costs somewhat more or requires additional effort.
Rav M. FeinsteinHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
Can government regulation of dairies replace Jewish supervision?
Some authorities held that strict government regulation and fear of substantial fines prevent adulteration and can count as supervision. This supports the leniency for chalav stam from large companies; it does not extend to small farms. Other authorities argued either that the ordinance specifically requires Jewish supervision or that government regulation does not eliminate even a remote possibility of violations.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 13 · open and download the PDF
May one drink unsupervised milk if there are no animals producing non-kosher milk nearby?
The Peri Chadash permitted such milk because he saw no reasonable possibility of non-kosher milk being added. According to the article, however, almost all subsequent authorities rejected this leniency and treated the prohibition as an ordinance that remains binding. Some also argued that abstaining from such milk had become a binding custom, and the author therefore requires stringency.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
What if chalav akum accidentally gets mixed into permitted food?
The article states that chalav akum is nullified in permitted food or liquid when its volume is sixty times the volume of the milk. This rule is stated for an accidental mixture.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Do utensils require koshering after contact with chalav akum?
A utensil in which chalav akum was cooked may not be used without koshering. The same rule is given for a utensil in which cold chalav akum was stored for twenty-four hours.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why did the Sages prohibit milk produced without Jewish supervision?
The concern was that a non-Jew might mix a small, undetectable quantity of non-kosher milk into kosher milk. Although this was considered unlikely, the Sages prohibited unsupervised milk. As presented in the article, the ordinary prohibition of chalav akum applies even when other milk is unavailable or supervised milk is expensive; proposed exceptions are discussed separately.
Rabbi Doniel NeustadtHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 12 · open and download the PDF
Why does Rav Weinberg distinguish between a cornea transplant for someone blind in one eye and someone blind in both eyes?
Rav Weinberg does not permit a transplant for someone blind in only one eye, but permits it for someone blind in both eyes because of the danger of accidents. He compares this to the cited permission to give non-kosher food to treat epilepsy, since a seizure can cause someone to fall into a fire or pit. Nevertheless, he concludes that someone relying on the lenient opinions “does not lose,” because prominent halachic authorities have issued permissive rulings.
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Does a transplanted cornea's return to life remove the prohibition against benefiting from the dead?
Rav Unterman permits transplantation on the grounds that the transplanted organ returns to life, so the recipient benefits from something living. Rav Weinberg rejects this argument because the benefit comes from the donor, who remains dead. Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach endorses Rav Unterman's ruling, while Rav Ovadia Yosef endorses it only in a case of great need and when the donor authorized the posthumous cornea donation during their lifetime.
Rav Unterman; Rav Weinberg; Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach; Rav Ovadia YosefHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Does a cornea transplant count as an unusual form of benefit that may be permitted for a sick person?
Rav Tzvi Pesach suggests that receiving a cornea constitutes benefit in an unusual manner: the cited Talmudic rule permits such benefit from a prohibited item for a sick person even without a threat to life. Rav Waldenberg objects that benefiting from a transplanted organ is a conventional form of benefit from the dead, so this rationale does not permit the transplant.
Rav Tzvi Pesach; Rav WaldenbergHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Can a cornea transplant be permitted because the cornea is smaller than a kezayit?
Rav Tzvi Pesach suggests treating the cornea as a distinct body part smaller than a kezayit, exempt from the burial obligation and the prohibitions against benefiting from or dishonoring the dead. Rav Waldenberg, however, holds that these prohibitions apply even to the smallest body part. Rav Tzvi Pesach himself also raises the possibility that the relevant threshold is a perutah in value rather than size, in which case the cornea's small size would not remove the prohibitions.
Rav Tzvi Pesach; Rav WaldenbergHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
What opinions are presented about corneal transplants from the deceased?
Rav Eliezer Waldenberg and Dayan Weisz categorically prohibit corneal transplants. Rav Isser Yehuda Unterman permits them, while Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank is inclined to permit them. Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg permits such a transplant for someone blind in both eyes.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does worldwide communication broaden the concept of a “patient before us” in discussions of organ donation?
Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg holds that improvements in worldwide communication greatly broaden the concept of choleh lefaneinu, a patient before us. Dr. Abraham S. Abraham strongly disputes this position. The article records the disagreement without providing a further resolution.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
When may preparations to remove a donor’s kidney begin according to authorities who reject brain death?
The article states that, for authorities who allow such donation but do not accept brain death as Halachic death, kidney removal and the necessary preparations must begin only after the heartbeat has ceased. The basis is the prohibition against touching a dying person in a way that could shorten life even briefly. Preparations while the heart is still beating spontaneously therefore present a serious Halachic problem under this approach.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May an organ be taken from the deceased to save a patient’s life?
Rav Moshe Feinstein regards organ donation to save a life as a mitzvah if the donor is already dead according to Halachah; Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach likewise permits removal for an endangered patient who is before us. On this approach, lifesaving removal does not degrade the deceased, and Rav Shlomo Zalman stresses that the donor must already be dead rather than dying. Rav Eliezer Waldenberg and Dayan Weisz prohibit such removal because the deceased is no longer obligated in mitzvot and, in their view, cannot be compelled to surrender an organ.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Is a person’s prior consent sufficient to permit an autopsy for medical research?
The Binyan Tzion permits an autopsy with the deceased’s prior consent even when no dangerously ill patient is before us. However, the article reports that most Halachic authorities reject this permission, including the Chatam Sofer, Maharam Schick, Rav Moshe Feinstein, and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach. The Chatam Sofer explains that the body retains a measure of holiness after death, so a person cannot authorize its degradation.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May an autopsy be performed to save another person’s life?
The Noda BeYehudah prohibits an autopsy for the possible benefit of future patients but permits it to save someone whose life is presently in danger; the Chatam Sofer supports this distinction. The Binyan Tzion prohibits it even for such a patient because the deceased is no longer obligated to save lives and the harm cannot be adequately compensated. The Maharam Schick disputes this prohibition and defends permission for a dangerously ill patient who is before us.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
What Halachic issues arise when transplanting organs from the deceased?
Rabbi Chaim Jachter identifies three potential obstacles: nivul hameit, or degrading the deceased; failure to bury the removed organ; and the prohibition against benefiting from the dead. These questions require consideration even when the donor is already dead according to all Halachic standards. The article then examines whether saving a life can override these prohibitions.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Why did the wearing of techeiles cease, and how do the cited sources explain it?
The article states that the use of techeiles ceased after the period of the Gemara and its source was eventually forgotten. The Midrash describes techeiles as having been concealed. Some poskim interpret the Arizal's writings to mean that techeiles should not be worn until Moshiach comes; this is presented as the view of some authorities.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How does the article assess the kosher status of carmine food coloring?
Carmine is described as a colorant made from powdered cochineal insects. Some permissive arguments rely on drying the insects until inedible or on the status of a dead insect dried for twelve months. The author nevertheless reports that, to his knowledge, all major kashrus organizations treat carmine as non-kosher, despite the existence of permissive opinions.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Does a non-kosher substance become permissible after complete transformation?
Rabbeinu Yonah permitted musk as a flavoring because its transformation made it a new substance. Rosh disputes that conclusion in one place, although elsewhere he cites it approvingly. The author compares this with Rambam and Raavad's disagreement over musk: Kesef Mishneh explains Rambam's permission by the resulting powder no longer resembling its source.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How is the possible use of a non-kosher-derived dye in the Temple explained?
The article offers several explanations: the restriction may apply to the main object used for a mitzvah but not its dye, or drying or complete transformation may make the substance permissible. Another approach limits the kosher-source requirement to objects bearing sacred writing or Hashem's name. Under that approach, it does not apply to a regular kohein's garments but still applies to the tzitz and choshen.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
Is tola'as shani a dye from an insect or from a plant?
Some authorities identify tola'as shani with kermes, a scarlet animal-derived dye associated with scale insects. Rambam explains that the dye comes from a berry consumed by the worm rather than from the worm itself, and Rashi gives a similar explanation. The author regards this as probably the primary approach for a halachic ruling, while not dismissing the alternatives.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
How do argaman and tola'as shani differ if both are red?
Radak explains that they are different shades of red, without specifying the difference. The author also infers from Rambam's wording that argaman may require the correct color regardless of the dye's source. Tola'as shani, by contrast, requires a particular source rather than merely the right shade.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 4 · open and download the PDF
What color is argaman, and what fiber was used for it?
Rambam identifies argaman as red wool, while Raavad understands it as cloth woven from different types or colors of thread. Most opinions cited regard its material as wool, whereas Ibn Ezra suggests dyed silk. Rabbeinu Bachyei objects to silk because it comes from a non-kosher species.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
What must a regular kohein's belt be made of?
The Gemara records a dispute over whether a regular kohein's belt is entirely linen or also contains techeiles, argaman, and tola'as shani. Rambam rules that it includes these colored threads. This differs from the high priest's Yom Kippur belt, which is made exclusively of linen.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Why must the materials of the priestly garments be identified precisely before offering sacrifices?
Sacrificial service is valid only when the officiating kohein is properly dressed. Discussion of Rav Yechiel's proposal to resume offerings therefore raises the need to identify the garment materials, including the belt's dyes. Without identifying the required materials, the proper vestments cannot be assured.
Rabbi Yirmiyahu KaganoffHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave68, p. 3 · open and download the PDF
Does halacha permit permanent or semi-permanent cosmetic tattooing?
Almost all contemporary halachic authorities cited in the text prohibit permanent and semi-permanent cosmetic tattooing. They differ over the level of the prohibition: Rav Gestetner leans toward a biblical prohibition, while Rav Shneebalg leans toward a rabbinic one. Some authorities are inclined to permit it in cases of extraordinary need, but the text emphasizes the difficulty of establishing grounds for leniency.
Редакция «Parsha.net»HalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 10 · open and download the PDF
Is there an obligation to remove an existing tattoo?
The author cautiously concludes that there appears to be no general obligation to remove a tattoo: the prohibition concerns applying it and allowing its application. Rav Weisz advises removing a disgraceful tattoo where tefillin are placed without calling this an obligation under the tattooing prohibition. Rav Ephraim Oshry urges Holocaust survivors to retain their forcibly tattooed numbers as a badge of honor, while Rav Eliyahu Bakshi-Doron recommends removing a tattoo that serves as a reminder of a past sin.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Can preserving human dignity provide grounds for permitting cosmetic tattooing?
The article considers permission in exceptional cases for kevod habriyot, preserving human dignity, when the prohibition is classified as rabbinic. Rav Basri permits tattooing eyebrows for a woman who has none, and Rav Shneebalg leans toward permitting pigmentation to conceal a scar. The author emphasizes that only a rabbi of considerable stature is authorized to rule on such a case.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Does someone who merely allows a tattoo to be applied also violate the prohibition?
The Tosefta includes both the person applying the tattoo and the person allowing it to be applied to their body. Rambam makes the recipient's liability for flogging dependent on active assistance, but a lack of assistance does not itself make the procedure permissible; the article discusses whether the remaining prohibition is biblical or rabbinic. Using a non-Jewish practitioner likewise does not remove the recipient's prohibition.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Does making a tattoo for beauty rather than idolatry change the prohibition?
According to the cited explanation of the Chatam Sofer, the absence of an idolatrous purpose may mean a rabbinic rather than a biblical prohibition. The Aruch LaNer and Rav Gestetner hold that the biblical prohibition applies even without that purpose. Separately, Rav Basri treats beautification as grounds for excluding a biblical prohibition, while Rav Gestetner rejects that argument; a cosmetic purpose therefore does not provide a general permission.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 9 · open and download the PDF
Can cosmetic tattooing be permitted if it adds only color, without letters or a picture?
Rav Nebentzahl leans toward permitting semi-permanent makeup by combining two considerations: it involves neither writing nor a picture, and it is not permanent. Other cited authorities include inserting color alone within the strict interpretation of the tattooing prohibition. Rav Wosner prohibits cosmetic tattooing; the author suggests that resemblance to forbidden tattooing may be the basis even if the procedures are not fully equivalent.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does the tattooing prohibition apply only to letters or also to other designs?
The article presents a disagreement among the Rishonim: some connect the prohibition to tattooing letters, while others include markings without letters. Rav Basri and the Minchat Chinuch also disagree about which position predominates among earlier authorities. Rav Shneebalg considers markings without letters at least rabbinically prohibited, but the article also cites a more lenient suggestion by the Me'il Tzedakah.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
Does the order of cutting the skin and applying pigment affect the tattooing prohibition?
The Bach explains the differing descriptions of the procedure as different presentations rather than necessarily a disagreement. According to the cited understanding of the Shach, the biblical prohibition applies even when the order is reversed, although other authorities restrict it to cutting first. Rav Gestetner also applies the biblical prohibition when both actions occur simultaneously.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 8 · open and download the PDF
May I write on my skin with ordinary ink or receive a removable hand stamp?
The Minchat Chinuch distinguishes an indelible mark from ordinary ink writing that can be removed. The author concludes that ordinary writing on the skin and amusement-park admission stamps are not technically prohibited as tattooing, although he regards writing on the body as undignified. He also considers children's fake tattoos most likely permitted.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Can inserting pigment just beneath the skin count as tattooing?
Rav Shneelbag understands the Ritva to indicate that the prohibition can apply even when pigment is inserted immediately beneath the skin's surface. The author considers the Shulchan Aruch's description consistent with this reading. A shallow insertion therefore does not by itself exclude the prohibition.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Does a tattoo becoming invisible after a few years remove the prohibition?
The text presents a disagreement over whether the Torah prohibition requires a permanent tattoo or whether a long-lasting one suffices. Rav Gestetner considers three years a long time and holds that such cosmetic tattooing may be biblically prohibited; Rav Shneelbag leans toward a rabbinic prohibition. In Rav Shneelbag's view, a tattoo's impermanence does not by itself remove at least a rabbinic prohibition.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 7 · open and download the PDF
Is convenience enough to permit permanent makeup?
The author notes that the sources he reviewed provide no explicit permission for cosmetic surgery solely for convenience. Even if such surgery were allowed, permanent makeup would require a separate assessment because of the tattooing prohibition. Saving time does not by itself resolve that halachic issue.
Rabbi Chaim JachterHalachaRead more
Source: Parsha.net — Tetzave65, p. 7 · open and download the PDF