I sinned and now I'm suffering. Is it right to think "I deserve this punishment and I know why"?
The Yidden felt Hashem took them out of Mitzrayim only to kill them; the Seforno explains they were afraid because they had worshipped idols there. Isn't that a good reason to suspect Hashem is angry — an idolater is Chayav Missa? So why do Chazal call it "baseless crying"? One thing is sure: don't run after Fruma negatives; they can be a total Yetzer Hara. "But I sinned and Hashem is punishing me for good reason!" — beware of this "frum" trap. (On the other hand, sometimes your Cha'rata and pain about a sin do wonders; every case is different.) Rabbi Mandel had a bad case of Roiz (cellulitis), which normally keeps him in bed 2–3 weeks; he immediately discredited all his sins as the reason, defended himself and was Dan himself L'kaf Zechus — and the Roiz disappeared in two days. There is a major Yetzer Hara to feel guilty and punished. Being Osek in Teshuva in a light, happy way is the most Geshmake experience and should always be done — the more serious the better, as long as it's B'simcha. But blaming your issues on your sins is predominantly a total Yetzer Hara, no matter how much it looks like the reason (unless you have a positive, doable Tachlis with your blaming).
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Be very, very careful not to fall into the "frum" trap»
- Author
- Rabbi Yehudah Mandel
- Source
- Bitachon Weekly — Bitachon Weekly — Devorim 5785