I'm prone to depression. Should I be crying on Tisha B'Av?
There are plenty of people who Davka shouldn't cry even on Tisha B'Av: they are way too depressive, and the crying business can be detrimental. They need to spend these days doing Teshuva on "you did not serve Hashem with joy and gladness of heart." They may need to go extreme and almost totally forget about any sadness during this Matzav — of course with a Rebbe who is monitoring their actions. Even during Eicha and Kinos, these people keep writing down the happy things going on in their lives, as many as possible, especially their own greatness, and that Hashem hurts them because they have super lofty souls that need to be tested in order to save Klal Yisroel with their pain.
Quote from the source«There are plenty of us who Davka shouldn't cry even Tisha B'av. They are way too depressive»
- Author
- Rabbi Yehudah Mandel
- Source
- Bitachon Weekly — Bitachon Weekly — Devorim 5785