What was Miriam’s sin if she meant well and spoke only to Aaron?
Miriam’s mistake lay in her initial assessment of Moshe’s conduct: given his exceptional spiritual stature, she should have judged him favorably. Her subsequent actions rested on the mistaken conclusion that he was acting improperly. Her pure intentions and discreet approach to Aaron therefore did not prevent her words from being lashon hara; unintentional slander is still slander.
Quote from the source«But unintentional slander is slander nevertheless.»
- Author
- R’ Ben Tzion Shafier
- Source
- The Shmuz — the shmuz BaHalosicha — Behaalotcha 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Behaalotecha