Why is the wood gatherer’s punishment not considered a judicial error if his intentions were pure?
The Rebbe explains that the sentence followed God’s explicit instruction, although God knew the wood gatherer’s intentions. In this case, the earthly court judged an act that appeared to violate Shabbat: the lack of need for the work’s result was not evident when it was performed. His pure intention therefore did not cancel the sentence; the article derives a lesson about the decisive importance of action.
Quote from the source«ההסבר לעונש הסקילה של המקושש הוא: הכוונה חשובה, אבל המעשה הוא המכריע.»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- התקשרות — עלוני חב''ד; התקשרות שלח לך 1503 — Shlach 5783, p. 7
- Parsha
- Shelach