What does the story of the Maharshal’s ruling about a widower’s promise never to remarry illustrate?
In the case described, the Maharshal ruled that his student’s promise to his dying wife never to remarry was not binding because it was an oath to violate a commandment; the student was to establish a family and have descendants. The story then recounts the student’s death after remarrying and his miraculous return to life following the Maharshal’s written command. The account is presented as an illustration of the power of Torah.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«עפ"י דין תורה השבועה לא חלה, שכן היא שבועה לעבור על המצוה»
- Author
- המהרש"ל
- Source
- ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים — ליקוטים וסיפורים נפלאים - שלח תשפ''ג — Shlach 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Shelach