Does answering amen remove the obligation to pay for a taken mitzvah opportunity?
The article cites an approach among the early authorities under which reciting the blessing aloud and having the injured party answer amen can remove the payment obligation, because of the special merit of answering. The Sema limits this to mitzvot incumbent on everyone and excludes the father's particular obligation to circumcise his son. The Shach writes that most authorities disagree with that limitation; the article separately discusses a father's actual agent, where answering amen does not remedy the loss of the mitzvah itself.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולפי"ז בכל מקום שחוטף מצוה מחבירו וחבירו עונה אמן, פטור מלשלם.»
- Author
- Редакция «משפטים»
- Source
- משפטים — משפטים — במדבר- נשא א' תשפ''ג[20242] — Behar-Bechukosai 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Behar