Who must prove when a purchased item's defect arose if its timing is uncertain?
Sma explains that the outcome depends on whether the item has a presumption of soundness. An apparently healthy animal is presumed not to have been a treifah until proven otherwise, so the buyer must prove that a defect discovered after purchase existed before the sale; without proof, he must pay. Cheese inevitably spoils and does not have this presumption, so uncertainty is governed by the rule that the party seeking money must provide proof. If the cheese buyer has not yet paid, he cannot be compelled to pay in this situation.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Cheese, however, will inevitably spoil, so it does not have such a chazakah,»
- Author
- Sma
- Source
- Business Weekly — Business Weekly — Behar-Bechukosai 5783, p. 2
- Parsha
- Behar