Did the rabbis invent the annulment of vows contrary to the Torah's words 'he shall not break his word'?
No. Rabbis cannot issue rulings that contradict the Torah and have no right to permit what the Torah forbids (the reverse is possible: the Sages forbade things the Torah permits, such as polygamy, levirate marriage, blowing the shofar on Shabbat). So who released us from 'all that comes out of the mouth'? The Torah itself, the Oral Torah, in this case the Talmud, which is as binding as the Written Torah: Moshe received both parts of the Law at Sinai, inseparable from each other. What is required of us is emunat chachamim, trust in the Talmud, submission to the authority of the Sages and the effort to preserve the chain of tradition from teacher to student; if it breaks, we will vanish from the map of history, and Creation, losing its connection to the Creator through the Torah, will return to chaos. When we receive a mitzvah, it does not matter whether it is formulated in the Written or the Oral Torah.
Quote from the source«Нет, раввины не могут выносить постановления, противоречащие Торе.»
- Author
- Нахум Пурер
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №402 Матот
- Parsha
- Matot