What happens if a Jew swears to violate a Torah law, for example to work on Shabbat?
Such an oath is vain. Among the laws of oaths there is a rule: if a person took two contradictory oaths, the second is invalid. And the whole Jewish people swore at Mount Sinai to do all that God commands, repeated the oath in the plains of Moav and a third time at Mount Gerizim and Mount Eival, for themselves and for future generations (Devarim 29:9-14); no one can annul it. Hence an oath to violate a Torah law is vain, and a person is punished merely for having taken it. The words 'to bind his soul with a bond' imply the right to forbid oneself what is permitted, not to permit what is forbidden. Not fulfilling such a bond adds nothing to the sin of a vain oath, while by violating a Torah law a person becomes an oath-breaker; if he also swore to violate it, he sins doubly.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Значит, клятва нарушить закон Торы напрасна, и человек будет наказан за то, что дал ее.»
- Author
- Рав Ицхак Зильбер
- Source
- Nasledie — ФОНД НАСЛЕДИЯ рава И Зильбера №402 Матот
- Parsha
- Matot