Can the permission for meat after slaughter extend to a non-kosher animal that is still convulsing?
Meshech Chochmah proposes that a non-kosher animal in this condition remains forbidden to a descendant of Noach as a living animal: permission for a Jew cannot serve as the basis here, since its meat is forbidden to Jews. On this reading, the disagreement between Chizkiyah and Rabbi Yochanan concerns the animal’s status for Jews and ritual impurity, rather than permission for a non-Jew to eat it. This resolves Rabbi Akiva Eiger’s question about the Mishnah stating that slaughter does not permit a non-kosher bird to a descendant of Noach before it dies.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל בן נח לחזקיה גם כן מוזהר כל זמן שמפרכס»
- Author
- רבי מאיר שמחה הכהן
- Source
- משך חכמה — משך חכמה — Noach 5787, p. 3
- Parsha
- Noach