Why is the prohibition of meat from an animal still convulsing after slaughter explained differently before and after the giving of the Torah?
According to Meshech Chochmah, before the giving of the Torah this meat was forbidden to all descendants of Noach while any life remained in the animal. After the Torah was given, authorities who permit it to a non-Jew base this on its permission for a Jew: something permitted to a Jew should not be forbidden to a descendant of Noach; Rambam nevertheless prohibits it. This explains the difference between “בשר בנפשו,” which includes residual life, and “הנפש עם הבשר,” which indicates a full attachment of life to the body.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל קודם מתן תורה הוה אסור מפרכסת לדידהו»
- Author
- רבי מאיר שמחה הכהן
- Source
- משך חכמה — משך חכמה — Noach 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Noach