If opposing Torah opinions are true, why must one be chosen in practice?
According to the Hasidic explanation presented, opposing opinions arise from a shared foundation in Torah that includes both approaches. In concrete action, however, one cannot treat the same object as both pure and impure or apply both exemption and liability simultaneously. Choosing one opinion expresses a higher level of Torah that resolves the dispute and is revealed through the sages of Israel below. A practical ruling therefore has an inner basis and is not merely a necessary compromise.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ההנהגה בפועל בגשמיות אינה סובלת שתי דעות.»
- Author
- Редакция «מעיינותיך - למחשבת חב''ד»
- Source
- מעיינותיך - למחשבת חב''ד — 49, p. 6