Why did the sages not follow the heavenly voice in the dispute over the oven of Achnai?
The sages ruled according to the majority, following the principles that the Torah is not in heaven and that one follows the majority. Rav Nissim Gaon explains that the heavenly voice tested their loyalty to the rules they had received. The Ran offers a different explanation: the voice truly expressed the truth, but authority to decide had been entrusted to the sages. The article raises difficulties with both explanations: how could a heavenly voice communicate something false, and how could a ruling contrary to truth be called true Torah?
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ההכרעה נמסרה לחכמי הדורות, ואשר יסכימו הם הוא אשר ציווהו ה'»
- Author
- רב ניסים גאון; הר״ן
- Source
- מעיינותיך - למחשבת חב''ד — 49, p. 5