Can one fulfill the mitzvah of the four species if a hadas taken accidentally without payment became mixed with purchased ones?
In the case discussed, a person paid for three hadasim, accidentally took a fourth, and bound three of them with his lulav. The ruling allows reliance on the permissive opinion but notes a dispute over whether the mixture resolves the ownership problem and satisfies the requirement that the species belong to the person using them. To fulfill the mitzvah without this doubt, another person's four species should be acquired as a gift on condition that they be returned after use.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«יש לו על מי לסמוך לצאת בהם יד"ח»
- Author
- ר' יצחק זעקיל הלוי פאללאק
- Source
- שבת בשבתו - אנטוורפן — שבת בשבתו - אנטוורפן — sukkos shabbos bshabatoi - antwerp lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2