Why is the special need for intention when observing the mitzvah of sukkah connected with the clouds of glory?
The article presents the Bach's view that even if other mitzvot do not require intention, sukkah is different because the Torah says “so that your generations may know”; it presents the Magen Avraham as disagreeing. It suggests connecting this disagreement to whether the sukkah commemorates the clouds of glory or actual huts in the wilderness. Remembering the clouds requires conscious thought, whereas sitting in a hut itself recalls such dwellings.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לעומת זאת, המג"א סובר שמצות סוכה היא זכר לסוכות ממש, על כן אין צריך כונה»
- Author
- מהרי"ץ דושינסקי
- Source
- שבת בשבתו - אנטוורפן — שבת בשבתו - אנטוורפן — sukkos shabbos bshabatoi - antwerp lashon kodesh 5787, p. 1