How does the custom of maot chittin differ from the obligation to bring joy to the poor on a festival?
The author distinguishes the basic obligation to bring joy to the poor on a festival from the additional communal collection for Pesach wheat. In his explanation, that collection was connected to a communal tax and remained a custom after such taxes ceased. The obligation to provide festival joy for the poor does not depend on this collection and also applies to Sukkot.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«שוב אין כאן חיוב מעיקר הדין, ונשאר הדבר בתורת מנהג.»
- Author
- יואל לאנדא
- Source
- מבי מדרשא — מבי מדרשא — sukkos milin yakifrom a madrasarin lashon kodesh 5787, p. 6