In the dispute about a mat, does the craftsman’s intention or the buyer’s intention determine its status?
Bach understands Rosh to mean that once a mat has been made for lying on, subsequently buying it for sechach does not change its underlying status; if ordered beforehand for sechach, only the concern about appearances remains. Maharia HaLevi and Imrei Yosher disagree, holding that Rosh also accepts the buyer’s intention as decisive and that the prohibition concerns appearances. The article presents both interpretations without resolving the disagreement.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל בשו״ת מהרי״א הלוי (ח״א סי׳ קי״א) חולק על הב״ח»
- Author
- רבי אלחנן חיים פילאפף
- Source
- מבי מדרשא — מבי מדרשא — sukkos milin yakifrom a madrasarin lashon kodesh 5787, p. 8