Are considerations of saving lives sufficient to permit territorial concessions for peace?
The author first explains that saving lives could make surrendering land permissible and even obligatory, since the prohibitions discussed are not among the three exceptions to the rule of pikuach nefesh. He then cites Minchas Chinuch and other authorities who hold that the ordinary priority given to saving lives does not operate in the same way during a Torah-mandated war, because war itself entails danger. The article qualifies this as a war that can be won and states that there is no obligation to fight a losing battle. A decision therefore requires determining whether concessions will actually bring peace and save lives, whether a state of war exists, and whether victory is possible; the article gives no definitive practical ruling.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«This may not, however, necessarily be the case.»
- Author
- RABBI MICHAEL TAUBES
- Source
- Parsha.net — Achrei63, p. 2